Sluurpy > Restaurants in Nantucket > Company Of The Cauldron

Company Of The Cauldron - Nantucket - Photo album

I am not too sure about the price & whether it is justifiable for the island or not.. but I was underwhelmed with the overall service, atmosphere, and plating. The food was rich with lots of butter & it takes away some of the other flavors that you want to taste with the courses. If you tend to ea

Didn’t live up to the hype and at $150+ per person not worth it. Fried chicken, popover, cupcake were great. The salad and sides and SERVICE were on par with a school cafeteria. Soooo disappointed.

The quality of the food was fair to middling at best. Kind of like food at a wedding. When you take into account the price, you end up with an incredibly disappointing experience. That said, the popovers were good.

This place is special. Perfectly romantic and refreshingly old school. Chef is impressive and the wine flows if you get the tasting menu, which I highly advise.

This food is bad. Like, not bad for the money - but bad for any money. We had a Caesar salad with over salted croutons then a rib eye that was half inch thick at most, rare, overly fatty, and (not joking) covered in BBQ sauce. The “sides” were one cut up raw carrot covered in thick congealing butter

this was by far the best dining experience my family and i had while on the island. the food, service, and dedication was truly remarkable. i felt both inspired and fulfilled throughout the entire meal, and i can’t wait to one day return. amazing!!

Truly one of the best dining experiences I have had. My husband and I always make a point of getting a reservation here whenever we are on island. The ambiance, service, and the quality of food are unparalleled. Truly top notch. Cant wait to go back this summer! Run, don’t walk!

Amazing on all levels Michelin star ⭐️ chef dinner party. With. Outstanding food and hospitality from a seasoned, top notch team to create unforgettable dining experiences. Do the wine pairing!