The food was very bland and overpriced. I think the schools pizza is better then this place. There is definitely better food and pizza on the island don’t waste your time and money here!
Meatball sub was dry....very little to no sauce at all....had cannollis there was cream 1/2 inch on both sides and 0 cream in the middle, at all. What a terrible mistake by them. Will not be back this summer at all.
The best pizza in Nantucket. My favorite better than NJ or NY. Get the clams as appetizer.
I have had the pleasure of going to Pi Pizzeria only once as I only get to Nantucket for work, but good lord was it wonderful.
First of all, the owners (Maria and Evan) CLEARLY put a lot of love into their place. It is warm and comfortable and inviting.
The service was great as were the server's r
The pizza was great and the owners were extremely nice
I usually love this place, but we got take out last night that was so poorly prepared. The meatball sub was falling apart, bread cracked and dry, no marinara. Manicotti pasta was falling apart in strips. Chocolate cake was dry, tiramisu was so overwhelming with its booze content, overpowered any oth
Pizza was amazing. Staff was super friendly and considering how busy it was, pizza came out super quick. Thin, cooked perfectly, and hit the spot. Not only the best pizza shop on the island, but one of the better ones I’ve had around.
Charming place with good food, good service and a great atmosphere. I love their pizza and steak but my personal favorite is Esposito's Sausage served on pasta in a marinara sauce. Sit at the bar. Lots of fun and good conversation there.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes