Sluurpy
Reset

There are 5 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Nantucket

There are 5 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Pizzeria Gemelle
89/100 (156 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Takeout
Lunch
Dinner
"Delicious pizzas and fast, friendly service! I didn’t get pictures of the whole pies (everyone dug in before I could get a chance 😀,) but we had..."
Nikki Montgomery
"This is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. If you eat meat, their sausage is so perfect on the potato/rosemary pizza (I also added Gorgonzola)...."
Jonathan McEuen
"Shared the prosciutto pizza for lunch on a bench, so fresh, ready in 5 minutes and hand delivered to us outside by the friendly staff. Perfectly..."
D M
"Very good pizza! Just wish they had..."
Grace Gherman
"Great pizza made really quickly, plus homemade gelato, cannoli, and a nice Aperol Spritz! Perfect meal. My favorite pizza so far is the Capricciosa,..."
Lisa
"This is the best pizza on Nantucket. Great ingredients, great crust, great..."
Brian Robles
"Great new spot for neopolitan Pizza on the island. Prices are reasonable and the food was great. As with all wood fired pizza make sure to order it..."
Alexander Moschella
"Delicious pizza with fresh toppings! Service is also..."
Ali & Nic
Ventuno
87/100 (1000 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Drinks
Dinner
Late Night
Polenta
Lobster
Meatballs
Suckling Pig
Salad
Ice Cream
Crab
Gelato
Scallops
Crostini
Clams
Lamb
Duck
Pesto
Broccoli rabe
Oyster
Fish
Risotto
Pork
Antipasti
Crostino
Swordfish
Shrimp
Halibut
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Seating
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Table Service
Reservations
Dinner
Drinks
Fine Dining
"After reading all of the mixed reviews on here, we didn’t know what to expect! We were pleasantly surprised to find delicious food and incredible..."
Anthony Saltarelli
"Great fresh food and awesome drinks. Can’t say enough about this place…. A must try if you like Italian when on Nantucket. The meatballs are..."
Scott Briggs
"Nice what I would call italia style restaurant. Nice selection of small plates, pasta and then mians. We were in for a light quick meal and it..."
Richard Stratton
"I started with the rabbit pasta and it was fantastic, I would place it in my top 3 pasta dishes ever! My main course was a very tender and jucie lamb..."
Connor McKeon
Boarding House
87/100 (354 ratings)
Restaurants
American
French
French
American
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Eggs Benedict
Waffles
Lobster
Pesto
Pasta
caesar salad
Baked Alaska
Salad
Hummus
Crab
Oyster
Scallops
Black Truffle Fries
Seared Sea Scallops Risotto Verdura
Oyster
Yellowfin Tuna Martini
Risotto
Tuna
Lobster Roll
Swordfish
Halibut
Sit down
American
French
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Full Bar
Accepts American Express
Outdoor Seating
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Fine Dining
"Another amazing dinner on the patio! A long time favorite of ours due to the history on island and friendly, professional staff. The dishes (Summer..."
Elizabeth Buckman
"Very friendly professional wait staff. The food was outstandingly delicious. I had the halibut that was simply scrumptious, probably the best I've..."
Jo-Anne Wallace
"Been here 3 out of 5 nights, returning to eat the halibut. It's the..."
Alda Tedeschi
"Seth and Angela Raynor are the example to follow on Nantucket and any dining arena. The Boardinghouse is a consistent favorite for good reason--the..."
Annie B. Copps
"One of my favorite spots on ACK!! Such a great casual vibe in the bar setting. If you want to have a more fancy dinner downstairs it's really cozy in..."
Colleen Clare-Coen
"We had a lovely evening at the boarding house. Quite possibly, the best salad that we have ever had. The waitstaff were very..."
Elizabeth Brown Armstrong
"Fantastic food. The hush puppies were divine. Great service, tasty cocktails, and lots of Christmas Stroll..."
M.A. Tarver Gallerani
"An "all appetizer" dinner for us tonight! It was..."
Manny Almagro
"Scallops are..."
Beverly Cataldi Turney
"Awesome brunch! Great art gallery next door! Beautiful sculpture garden! Check it..."
Joyce Coviello
"Went for dinner stroll weekend. Our table wasn't quite ready so the host bought us a drink and checked on us every few minutes to see if there was..."
Howard Shirley
"Myself (Teddy )and my husband Steven had dinner at Boarding House tonight. We were seated in a very cute private corner upfront the kitchen. The..."
Teodora Stockigt
"We got a table withing 5 min for 3. My wife and I are dairy free and they were happy to a comadate, the octopus was amazing, cooked perfect..server..."
Frederick Caribardi
"We had excellent service and an incredible meal. Our scallops were cooked to perfection - not overdone. The tomato and strawberry salad was fresh and..."
Steve Keefe
"Boarding house has top notch service (ask for Hannah Johnson- she's fantastic). The food was spot on, fresh, locally sourced and prepared well. Can't..."
Elizabeth Guynn
"Food we delicious and the Bartender was great. We just stayed for a little while during our drink and app crawl that my wife and I do, but we were..."
Chris Johnson
"Best meal I have had in a long while!! Very accommodating place for dietary requests!! Great food and..."
larissa greene
Pi Pizzeria
85/100 (368 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Deli
Pizza
Bar
Italian
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Calamari
Calamares
Meatballs
Pesto
Antipasti
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The Rustica Pizza is the best slice I have ever eaten. My favorite thing on the..."
Chris Shackleton
"Excellent!All down the line.Every meal I've ordered has been..."
Mark Reindel
"Intimate, deliciously consistent, warm and friendly....I love Pi Pizzeria almost as much as the owners. Truthfully, there isn't a better pizza on..."
Susan Jemison
"One of our favorite restaurants on the island. My husband loves the steak. We love the cold appetizer small plates, the olive tampanade. I love the..."
Patricia Victoria
"The food at Pi Pizza is insane and any review that is less that a 5 has been written by a..."
Liz Cannavo Gruber
"Ahhh Pi Pizzeria! So many reasons to go! Best pasta on the island! Incredible lunch and dinner specials! Oh, and the only wood fired oven and..."
Doreen Costanzo
"Pi Has fantastic pizza, amazing pasta and perfect tiramisu!! All served in a warm, cozy atmosphere. We love this..."
Carrie Culp
"Love it all! Best steak on the island! Friendly staff makes all the..."
Gretchen Gigi Callahan
"All of my meals here have been amazing !!! 5 stars..."
Lisa Bouchard
"Best Pizza on the Island! Try the Mozzarella..."
Lee Milazzo
"Without a doubt the fall is back and Pi is perfect for the crisp nights. John Burdock is amazing. Always so welcoming. Will gladly wait for seats at..."
Tanya Jill McDonough
"Pi Pizza if I had to describe it in one word "Quality"it's evident in every bite,And the hospitality warms me it's like visiting family (you know the..."
Robert Souza
"Great Staff and Best Food in a truly Fun Atmosphere. What every neighborhood restaurant should..."
Dave Ryan
"I never write reviews but I feel like this is what it's all about!! You completely satisfied my craving tonight!! My husband came with a margarita..."
Darya Afshari
"I love Pi Pizzeria - Pizza, Pasta and INCREDIBLE Daily Specials for Dinner! I also love to eat lunch their because not crazy..."
Malcolm Brooks
"The best pizza in Nantucket. My favorite better than NJ or NY. Get the clams as..."
Sheri Matarese
"I have had the pleasure of going to Pi Pizzeria only once as I only get to Nantucket for work, but good lord was it wonderful. First of all, the..."
Chris Vaughn
"The pizza was great and the owners were extremely..."
Sweetburrito
"Pizza was amazing. Staff was super friendly and considering how busy it was, pizza came out super quick. Thin, cooked perfectly, and hit the spot...."
Douglas Macedo
"Charming place with good food, good service and a great atmosphere. I love their pizza and steak but my personal favorite is Esposito's Sausage..."
William Crispin
Fusaro's
81/100 (375 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Drinks
Dinner
Pasta
Salad
Scallops
Clams
Calamari
Calamares
Ribs
Shrimp
Meatballs
Bolognese
Lasagne
Pesto
Eggplant
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"We had a fantastic experience at Fusaro's! The atmosphere was beautiful and clean. Our waiter was very pleasant and professional. The food? Oh the..."
Maine Point Marketing
"One of the best values on Nantucket. Authentic Italian food served by a nice staff. Their Caesar salad is really good too one of our favorites. Pasta..."
Jon Zack
"The best Italian food on the island! Comfy setting and wonderful staff. A must visit for visitors. Especially because no resy..."
Vishvaruchi G
"Wonderful place , excellent service so friendly and the food yumiiiii I got the scallops pasta was very very well done love it..."
claudia valle
"Great service and awesome food. Had the Nantucket Scallops, Fettuccini Alfredo with chicken, Linguini and Clams, Scallop Chowder, and Eggplant..."
Brian MacDonald
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use