Holy Smokes this place is popular! Definitely order ahead if you can! We enjoyed our sausage, egg and cheese bagels, and I LOVED the blueberry pie cream cheese! And the sweet potato mash side was really delicious!
Absolutely delicious! Some of the best bagels I've ever eaten. I do recommend ordering ahead online as it is very packed in there with not a lot of standing room.
Best bagel I’ve ever had outside of NYC. Definitely give this place a try! The Nova Scotia smoked salmon sandwich was delicious, and the employees are all very kind.
Chaotic and a long wait and worth every second. I’m a former NYer who refuses to eat bagels outside of NY. EXCEPT for at Proper Bagel. The lines are very, very long, and even when you get to the front, you have to wait longer, but the bagels are so good that it’s definitely worth it!!!
We really liked our lattes and the cream cheese was very good but the bagels weren't anything spectacular. We like bagels but definitely aren't bagel experts, they tasted mostly like any other bagel and we found the onion bagel to be a little strong.
Also very expensive, $30 for 2 bagels and 2 latt
VEGAN BAGELS ARE INSANE. Such unique flavors and creamcheese pairings.
Im from NJ and we brag our bagels are the best but i have to be honest this is the best bagel ive had. Make sure you ask for light cream cheese because they tend to put alot.
Here are my go to options:
Pumpernickel with vegan
Yummy!! The server asked if we liked a lite or thick later of cream cheese. If you like a hearty serving of cream cheese, then this is what I would expect if you ask for that! I'm only in town for a little bit, and I'm already planning on going back!
Fantastic bagel, nice fish product flown from Brooklyn. I get it, and I’m not even mad at the $15 + for a nice sandwich with those specialty meats. Being nickel and dimed on the coffee though? I don’t know how an oatmilk latte (an allergy for some) is $9. That’s nearly twice the price of the bagel I
Sooo good! First time and will definitely come back. The staff was super friendly and would go out of their way to check on you and make sure everything came out okay. The wait time wasn’t bad at all, I think I maybe waited 10 minutes for an order of 3 bagels and an iced latte. Highly recommend 😊
The best bagels and cream cheese ever! We went here for breakfast during the week and it was everything. There were a lot of people in there which let me know how popular this place is. They moved the line pretty quickly and there was a small wait which I didn’t mind as the space was so pretty. Ther
Expensive but very good. Bagels taste phenomenal and the avo-egg combo can’t be beat. The black and white cookie was also great as well as their coffee. The various flavored cream cheeses are tasty too, though I would add a little less of them to the bagels. Lovely place but I dislike the practice o
Found this cute bagel shop on TikTok and it did not disappoint. Friendly service and amazing bagels. The owner is also amazing. Highly would recommend anyone that loves New York bagels. Thanks for a great meal and keep up the great work!!!
The bagels were amazing—especially the sourdough!! We loved the side of sweet potato mash and I got a dirty ice chai that was great as well
Must stop at Proper Bagels while you’re in Nashville! The lox bagel on an everything bagel was on point. 👌🏻Wish I could have tried more from their menu!
As a former New Yorker and a bagel snob, I was very impressed! The food was great as was the service! I’ve never been in a restaurant that was constantly cleaning and checking on guests. The staff were all equally great which was a welcome change from what I often see. Highly recommend!
I was excited to see the variety of bagels and cream cheese. I tried the pumpkin bagel and birthday cake cream cheese and my sister has the everything bagel with scallion cream cheese and we really enjoyed them.
The closet thing to NYC bagels in Nashville! They are fluffy, fresh, and have so many flavors to choose from. Their cream cheese selection is also super well rounded. Highly recommend!
I can’t believe I hadn’t been here before. SO SO GOOD!
Wait times can be a bit long, so I’d recommend going for a walk around Belmont area in the meantime or ordering ahead.
Incredibly fresh quality bagels and cream cheeses. I’m somewhat of a bagel snob living in NYC for 10 years and many visits to Montreal (if you know you know). These bagels tug at the heart strings and closest I’ve had to NYC bagels outside of NYC. Yes, even LA.
Busy? Yes, obviously. They’re delicio
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes