A Walk Down Memory Lane!. I loved this local restaurant and after leaving the area 11 years ago, I finally returned to see if they were as good as I had remembered. Well, it was great. To say I loved their food would be an understatement. There were so many Italian dishes I would eat over and over again. So this past wkend, I stopped in and savored one of my favorites...Linguini with white clams. I wasn't disappointed. It was wonderful especially since I don't eat pastas anymore. All I can say is if I'm back in the area again they will certainly get my business. I even introduced some people to this place and I know they will be back. Keep up the good job Mama Theresa's. The waitress was wonderful and very informative. This place brings back wonderful memories.
Really good pizza, but the food is top notch.
Really good food. Very fair prices. Nice wait staff.
This place has pretty good food. The cool thing about it is that you can sit at a table and order food, or tell the people there your getting pizza and they will deliver it, or just give you a slice in infront of you!
Hands down the BEST buffalo chicken pizza I have ever had!! Reheats super well in the air fryer too. I am also in love with their salad pizza. It is super vinegary with a generous amount of toppings including onions, tomatoes, and olives.
Always a delicious place to eat. Been going there since I was a kid. The prices have gotten a little bit high but I guess that's just the way things are now. Either way we will be back and I know my kids loved it too.
![5]( "Recensione")
I have enjoyed visiting all three of Mama Theresa's in Nassau County. Conveniently located in shopping centers, there is always ample parking. The Garden City Park location is on the North side of Jericho Turnpike, just east of Nassau Blvd. The food here is plentiful and robust. I recommend the Hot Antipasto Appetizer. It is served on a platter and can quickly become even your dinner favorite. If not, there's plenty to share. Tonight, the four of us dug into and a fantastic selection of Italian favorites. My girlfriend enjoyed Eggplant Rollatini. Cooked to perfection, the cheese and sauce complemented the thinly sliced eggplant. Their Chicken Verdi is served with your choice of pasta and vegetable preparation. It has white wine, butter sauce that is light and flavorful. I chose mine to be served with sauteed spinach and covered in melted mozzarella cheese, bet you can't finish this dish! The Linguine with Clams came with a hearty portion of clams, garlic, and linguine. It was hard to fathom my husband ate the entire bowl. And to my surprise, my friend's fiancee managed to eat his whole linguine meal La Toscana. This delectable dish includes sauteed broccoli rabe, jumbo shrimp, pignoli nuts, white wine and garlic topped with seasoned toasted bread crumbs. Just an awesome presentation. And they also have ample seating nearby the pizza prep area so you can see up close the many options if you are in the mood for pizza — all in all, a star in the trio of the chain.
This place has the absolute BEST chicken Parm dinner, chicken marsala dinner, penne Ala vodka, plain slice, marsala slice, Buffalo slice I've ever had. They are so good it's almost upsetting. How can you be this good? How?! Seriously- they are the best. Excellent take out/ pick up or dine in service. The ambiance isn't anything to write home about, just a busy hometown pizzeria with some comfortable booths if you want to stay. Danny is the man. The whole staff is honestly just stellar. During COVID their pickup line never stopped- it was always out the door. You know why? Because they are THE BEST 👌 👍. GET A MARSALA SLICE and when it rocks your world, tell Danny, Big John sent ya 😉👍
Good service. Food was fantastic. We ordered Calzone and Baked Cheese and Ravioli. It was so delicious. Good place for an Italian Restaurant. I rated it 4 star because the place was very loud.
Excellent excellent excellent. I have the eggplant Parm very often and for the first time last week I tried the pecan salad. It is now my go-to salad. I've had it twice since first trying it. And excellent each time.
Often super busy, especially on weekends. Food is not chesp, but quality and taste make up for it. Portions are very generous. They are always willing to customize your orders. Workers are polite. I've never had problems coming here. It's a great establishment.
Mama Theresa's is an institution. Pick a slice, any slice, and it'll be excellent. Pizzas, hero's, pastas, entree's... do what I do; loosen your belt and order like you're carbo-loading before the big meet.
It's a pizza place, a really good pizza place. And restaurant combined. It's not fine dining but the food makes up for the lack of ambiance
Best family restaurant that never fails it's clients. Quality food with Great staff's. Highly recommend to try their buffalo chicken/pizza, calamari.
The So called Mama TheresA’s Pizza 🍕 is for sure a good choice.
The best pizza from there one should for sure try is “Marsala Chicken Pizza”
The prices are really very way high than usual pizza places, I didn’t find any much difference compared to other places in general. At the end of the day for a PIZZA 🍕 is PIZZA however you make it you would love it if you have your favourite toppings ❤️.
The chicken bacon ranch pizza from here wasn’t so interesting for me, I would rather try some other pizza from them.
I've been going here for years.. Back when my grandma fran Was alive... I was there just the other day and it's not the same. The food is still good but the service is poor.. There are long lines.. There's no method to how the food is distributed when they were picking it up were sitting in.. I've known the prices to always be reasonable.. But in ten years I can understand why it's a little high end. My overall experience Was good not great. .. Still the best sicilian pizza pie.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes