Sluurpy
Reset

There are 3 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Bagels in New Rochelle

There are 3 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
H And R Bialy
89/100 (153 ratings)
Restaurants
Breakfast
Lunch
Bagels
Breakfast
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"I was wondering where all the new reviews are! I just went today and I must say, beautiful store. You’ll wait in line but for a good reason...."
Laura Fullman
"Best bagels around, much improved under the new management. The fish is always consistent. Lots of flavors of cream cheese, I like the bacon cream..."
Jonathan Sacks
"Wonderful, quick service. Bagels are delicious. Wide variety of fresh cream cheeses, best tuna, and so much more. Best of all, the place is always..."
Felicia Berkovitz
"Great BEC for a great price. $12 for the bagel sandwich and an extra large coffee which is amazing for the area. The staff is top notch in regards to..."
Thomas Murtagh
"Best bagels around and the guys are..."
Nancy Kaplan
"Closed temporarily while new owners —hopefully — don’t screw up what were the best bagels in the area. Sammy's is 2nd. There's usually a line..."
Kitz W
"What is going on? These bagels are a gift of the gods. Now the place is shuttered? COVID? Bagel maker died? Renovations? We need to know. Will you be..."
Albert Maroun
"This is a hole in the wall with great bagels. This place has no place to sit and the line is often out the door. The workers are nice but busy in the..."
Jerry Kurtze
"These are the best bagels I have ever had. It's a bonus if you can get them hot right out of the oven. They are so good, you can eat them plain..."
Monique Harding
"Best Bagels in Westchester. Mike the owner is a great guy, very friendly, we have known him for years. Cash only, but their is a Chase Bank next..."
Sean cohen
"Easily the best bagels in Westchester! It’s cash only but totally worth it. They also have tofutti vegan cream cheese. The costumer service isn’t..."
Piper Martz
"Delicious bagels, friendly and clean. I just wish they would put some tables in the..."
Lia N
Traditional Bagel Cafe
88/100 (366 ratings)
Bakeries
Lunch
Breakfast
Bagels
Breakfast
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Loved this bagel place. Personally not a fan of the huge bagels you frequently see... throws off the bagel to ingredients ratio for an egg sandwich...."
Anthony Mejia
"The local traditional bagel cafe is an absolute gem. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of freshly baked bagels welcomes you. The menu boasts a..."
Adin Triolo
"Friendly service and delicious bagels! Just wish the everything bagel had a little more..."
Kelly Kay
"One of the best New York bagel you can have (outside of Manhattan). The owner is super nice and keep the place super clean and organized. He also..."
Gerardo Manzo
"It’s just a bit degrading for their own sake and service, where the food is actually pretty good the portions and the “dishes” are a bit..."
Manny Guardiola
"We had toasted bagels and flat bagels with ham, egg and cheese and they were great! The staff is polite and really quick. The place is clean and..."
Georgia Konstantinou
"Without doubt the best bagels in Westchester county. Nothing else compares to the size, quality and finesse of this place. New Roc at its..."
Jose Enrique Arrioja
"Best bagels in the area. Great service and atmosphere. Outdoor seating is nice and everything is kept very clean. Tables always being wiped down and..."
Ralph Saracino
"This the best bagel store in the New Rochelle area. Conveniently located near Quaker Ridge and Wycagal it’s right across the street from Starbucks...."
Stephen Popkin
"They have great bagels and make a good egg sandwich. The cream cheese spreads are all tasty as well. Definitely gets busy in there on the weekends..."
Amy Rose
"Delcious bagels and fresh cream cheese ! That hot cherry pepper cream cheese-woa ! Good stuff. Friendly and attentive staff. Thank you ! Good cup of..."
Jatinkumar “Jay Audi” Patel
"Excellent food & friendly service. I'm not in their neighborhood often, but when I am, I always make sure I treat myself..."
Lisa p
"Outstanding bagel. Cooked properly..Given to me hot, crispy on the outside and soft and fresh inside. Staff helpful and friendly. Quality food, very..."
David Branch
"This place is so cute! I came here with my friends and the owner came to our table personally to make sure we were enjoying our breakfast and later..."
alex dawson
"Probably one of the best bagels I've ever had! The bagel was nice and doughy with a crispy crust. The cream cheese was amazing as well!! I've never..."
Diane Hwu
"One of the few places I find sesame flat bagels.. they are amazing.. I always ask for very well done and usually they do listen... Very crunchy and..."
vintage shopper
"Best bagels in town. There are so many choices of bagels, cream cheese, and sandwiches. They always cook my sandwich to perfection, i usually ask for..."
Meaghan Tully
"We have been coming here since they opened and this place is essentially family. Our kids have grown up eating here and the owners are family to us...."
Prem Shunmugavelu
Sammy's New York Bagels
81/100 (176 ratings)
Bakeries
American
Bagels
"So feel good food place. Mu becon eggs and cheese bagel was amazing. Perfect for a quick bite. I would definitely come back again. I would give it my..."
TonyTesla
"To the ladies at Laura’s your random act of kindness was very appreciated. It’s always a pleasure to see your smiling faces in the morning. Not..."
dianna w
"They have great bagels and cream cheese. They are a bit on the expensive side though. But the staff is really..."
Shantell Ortega
"Love these bagels I've been buying these bagels since they were on North Ave under the original owners. The new owners have kept the recipes true to..."
mz gunnie
"My most favorite bagels in town! I’ve been coming here for years and their bagels have been consistently..."
Joana B
"i've been getting bagels here all my life. nothing out of the ordinary but great..."
Based Chapo
"Love their bagels, reminds me of Brooklyn early morning finds that are no longer available. Thanks..."
Valerie Johnson
"Can't start my morning until I get my bagel fix from Sammy's. Love their bagels here and the service is always fantastic. Happy they're open for take..."
Jarred Wisniewski
"Our favorite local bagel shop. Favorites are Sammy Stick (a straight everything), Black Russian, and egg. Can order ahead (recommended for Saturday..."
Adam Leader
"It was a little pricey but when the food is good i don't have a problem paying a little..."
TERRAINE BROOKS
"Great neighborhood cafe/deli. Bagels are fresh each morning, staff is friendly, place is clean. What more could you ask for. The food is good too..."
Rui Saturnino de Oliveira
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use