Reviews Erin Mckenna’s Bakery

I didn’t know this bakery was vegan and gluten free. This was a pleasant surprise. This was one of the best cupcakes AND doughnuts I ever had. It was so flavorful and it wasn’t dense. I highly recommend this place. 100/10

Mission: Put together a selection of vegan goodies for my son's 40th birthday. The process: Not being in Manhattan, in fact, being in NC, I had to Google vegan bakeries and there's quite a few. After viewing a dozen websites, I called a half dozen to inquire about building a spectacular selection for a surprise gift. I read over a hundred reviews to determine options and finally came up with what I felt was a perfect variety. Ordering was . . . . a piece of cake, so to speak. We ran through the menu items, decided on quantities and talked about the delivery. I requested pictures before they delivered and they complied and are attached to this review. Courteous, professional, timely and customer focused, and, by the way, the cakes, brownies and cookies were, as I heard, quite delicious. I'm only sorry I didn't get to try anything. 15/10 recommended, you should try it.

Idk what kind of sorcery this bakery applies but the gluten free/ vegan donuts are beyond the best I’ve ever had. I have been disappointed by others and have found other “good” ones but this raises the bar to what is possible for GF/Vegan. Thank you so much Erin, you’re a wizard and make GF people like me very happy. *im not celiac, just gluten and dairy free.

1.plain "bagel" is not a bagel. it doesn't taste good, and is dense and dry. Should be called a scone and have a different shape because so dense and not fluffy at all 2.lemon donut: very good 3.coconut donut: nice texture of the frosting, quite sweet, couldn't eat more than 1/3 4.pumpkin spice loaf (fall): dense (not fluffy) but soft and great flavors. only can eat 1/3 or 1/2 in one sitting. good overall and satisfies your sweet tooth. Could omit frosting, doesn't add much apart from make it sweeter 5.chocolate/brownie bite: dense, very rich, sweet, small and satisfying (almost a bit small), one more bite would be ideal 6.mocha donut: donut base tastes like lemon. frosting taste like coffee. expected the frosting to be crunchy because of the "crumble"-like texture but it tastes like frosting and is smoother than one may think. Very pretty 7.sprinkle (pink) vanilla donut: very good donut, although quite sweet and, once again, dense (not fluffy or light). almost a hint of lemon, perhaps from cross contamination. Took off the frosting 8.chocolate crumb cake : decadent, sweet and rich. syrup glaze on top (chocolate). sort of syrup that is unnecessary. The cake tastes a bit off, probably because I'm used to regular chocolate cake with wheat flour? looks fluffier than it tastes. the top of the cake is sweeter but more moist than the bottom (almost as if cooked in 2 times). too sugary. 9.jalapeño cheddar biscuit: disgusting. dry, tastes off. doesn't preserve well. gross. Staff is friendly, baked goods are ideal for a tea party, dessert for yourself or a gift

I love this tiny & cute 100% gluten free bakery. The doughnuts are unbelievably good– most things they make are unbelievably good but there are some things that I think fall into the category of just "good." They are expensive but not too crazy when compared to other GF/vegan/allergy friendly products in NYC. Overall can't recommend more if you have allergies– or to anyone. I think people who can eat anything would be shocked at how delicious these baked goods are!

Top me off With a cupcake top that is, only found at @erinmckennasbakery ! Right across the street from me is this awesome bakery. They’re gluten free and vegan and use natural sweetness like agave. The cupcake top is a vanilla cupcake with chocolate frosting sweetened with that agave. And that full cupcake is a chocolate brownie cupcake with mocha frosting. You’d never guess that they are gluten free or vegan

I have to say, THANK YOU!!!! The staff here are such a pleasure to work with, and I'm really glad we chose them for our wedding cake! We did a tasting box, which was a ton of sugary fun, but I also had THE BEST Samoa flavored donut that even my gluten loving husband gobbled it up!! We chose a carrot cake with cream cheese frosting... while the texture is small bit different, for a vegan frosting, it was phenomenal!! I'm so glad we bought a bigger cake than I originally intended, because our guests wound up choosing our cake instead of regular desserts!! We had only a small bit left over. Everyone loved it!! It was STUNNINGLY beautiful! Thank you again for making our day extra special!! Oh!! When I picked up the cake, I picked up some extra goodies... the VeggieBomb!!!! WOOOOOOW!!! I have to come back for a few more because I wound up having to share... begrudgingly! It was seriously delicious!

I got the cake here for my son’s first birthday and it exceeded all the expectations! The cake was vegan , cane sugar free , gluten free. And simply the most delicious cake i have ever tried and trust me , I’ve tried a lot. The design was very accurately done based on the pic I showed them . My son enjoyed every bit of it!

Pretty sure I've never had anything gluten-free that tasted this good. The donuts were firm and moist (not crumbly and wooden), the little choco muffins actually tasted like chocolate and that jalapeno scone was bigger than my head. Got a mixed box of goodies and everything was giving.