Sluurpy > Restaurants in New York City > Old Homestead Steakhouse
Old Homestead Steakhouse - New York City - Photo album
Old Homestead Steakhouse in NYC offers a delightful experience with its inviting ambience, impeccable service, and delectable food. The atmosphere exudes classic charm, creating a perfect setting for a memorable dining experience. The attentive staff adds to the overall positive impression, ensuring
A delicious bite of history. Good wine selections, outstanding french onion soup. My ribeye was perfectly cooked, went nicely with a baked potato and asparagus with hollandaise, and as full as I was, I was sad my steak was gone when i finished gnawing on the bone.
Very poor selection of champagne by the glass or half bottles. Proseco is not champagne. The chopped salad was perfect. Nicely tossed with dressing not drowned! Dry Aged sirloin for two was exceptional! Perfectly prepared. However, we ordered the sauce trio and they arrived cold as did the
Really enjoyed dinner here. Calamari was outstanding, very tender and flavorful. Steaks were cooked perfectly. Sides were on point. Really recommend trying this steak house out. #yumcity
Dinner was delicious, the steak was cooked perfectly, the asparagus was still firm but without any stringy parts and the mashed potatoes were beautifully whipped. The creme brulee was perfect.
This place is a classic! Too bad I waited so long to come here. Food was excellent and considering prices today, it was fair for what you get.
Sat in the library room which was nice and quiet until it fills up but it was still pleasant. I assume it's better upstairs than downstairs.
I'll definitely
My wife and I went here for dinner yesterday to celebrate our wedding anniversary. We’ve been before and really enjoyed the experience. This time was no different. The food was amazing and the staff was very attentive. We particularly enjoyed the yellowfin tuna sashimi, filet mignon with applewood
I was there to try the famous Gotham (pictures) on this very traditional / historical Steakhouse.
I had the feeling that it took to long for the meat to come. Also felt that there was not enough salt, and after the 1st bites I had the impression it was over cooked.
Digging a little deeper into the m
Dined at Old Homestead Steakhouse whilst in a business trip. Had the rib eye steak and chips. Cooked exactly as requested. Exceptional quality and taste, one of the best I've tasted.
There is a credit card surcharge here. Everything here was nice, funny waiters, Henry and Jose; high quality steak nicely flavored, and nice good school decorations. We enjoyed everything here including the sides and drinks.
We just happened upon Old Homestead after getting into town and what a great surprise to find such a gem! The ambiance is just perfect for a bustling place and the waitstaff are just wonderful. George took care of us this evening and the recommendations and execution of the overall meal was impeccab
This place is so consistently good. Definitely one of the best steakhouses in the city. And do not skip the crab cake or burger. Soooo juicy and tender.
Best steak we had in NY. The colossal shrimp to start was delicious, we shared a tomahawk steak between 3 (us being Brits so it was enough for 3!), and shared Mac and cheese, greens and fries on the side. Our bottle of red was also delicious - will be back when I’m next in NYC!
This was a nice little place and had such a neat location/surroundings. Tried Japanese Wagyu Steak for the FIRST time. It was DELICIOUS! Super tender and juicy!
This was an amazing dining experience from start to finish. We started with some raw oysters which were so fresh and delicious. Our steaks were perfectly seared on the outside, seasoned beautifully and cooked exactly as we requested them, quite rare. The meat was so tender you barely had to cut it o
Very good food and service. We had cosmopolitans and cherry temples for drinks. To eat, we had the giant shrimp, baked clams, and sashimi. We also had a ribeye and a dry aged rib steak for two. For dessert we had the crème brûlée, sunday, and chocolate cake. Everything was excellent. I feel the choc
Our friends had recommended Old Homestead and we were not disappointed. Excellent steaks and superb cocktails- the best we have had in a long time. I had the ribeye and wife the filet- so good. Excellent service. Recommend reservation- it was packed on Saturday night. 😋😋
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes