Sluurpy > Restaurants in Newark > Gencarelli's Pizzeria

Gencarelli's Pizzeria - Newark - Photo album

First time ordering from Gencarelli’s. Probably will be my last. I ordered the Stuffed Shells & 8pc Buffalo Wings. The pasta sauce for the Stuffed Shells was not tantalizing at all. The Shells themself were not good at all neither. The Buffalo Wings were extremely salty and inedible. First time in m

Good pizza. I only have an issue with their buffalo wings. Their buffalo wings are perfectly cooked. The problem? They ruin their wings with too much seasoning. If they cut down on the salt, garlic powder, or whatever type of seasoning they put on their wings by 25-50 percent their wings would be pe

I was not given what I paid for...No refund....No make up....No. Care that I didn't get what I paid for. Shame? This is so wrong...BUT HEY THAT'S THE WAY BUSINESSES ARE DOING THE BEST PAYING CUSTOMERS THESE DAYS!!!…Received a Reply from the manager we will see just what will become of this issue…

This pizza is authentic cooked to perfection flavorful, & tasty👌.. I don't even get the $8 pies anymore (try extra cheese, fresh garlic, mushrooms, green peppers, half sausage half pepperoni 😉).. reminds me of NYC.. Gencarekli's.. for-get a bout it!! (Not crispy If that's what you like)❗

Good pie, thin crust— good sauce, super fast delivery on Door Dash, good low prices. Kids loved the mozzarella sticks. White pizza was a hit. Will use again.

The $6 Pizza fell all the way off; you get what you pay for.. Dough,sauce and a little bit of cheese.. I called ahead,the pie wasn't even hot,I had to reheat when I got home!!👎👎Not going back..

My vegan sub was absolutely delicious! The customer service is very typical of Newark… but the sub!!

I ordered pizza for take out and as I waited and started to look around there were mouse droppings all over the place. In every corner of the floor, window seal and countertops right next a basket where exposed napkins for people to grab. I was totally turned off. They need to be shut down and embar