Reviews Pies & Pints

5
Emily B.
+5
Great pizza & sandwiches, prices are great esp for families. Nice place to take a break from shopping. Nice & polite staff. Very clean restaurant. Im looking forward to returning and trying their salads.
4
M T
+4
Was nice to try something different. The pizzas were really good. I read reviews saying the pizza skins were a must. For me they were a must not. While they were ok I can't say they were worth the price. Speaking of price I couldnt find any prices on the menu, but then saw the QR to scan for prices. Not convenient! While overall it was OK, I can't see myself making it a destination place.
5
Stephanie Bradford
+5
We ordered the house salad for 1-2 people, it is so good and I could have just ate that as my meal alone. Our favorite pizza so far is the pine and swine. They have a variety is dalds, sandwiches of pizza to choose from, plus apps. A large selection of beer and soda. In door and outdoor seating.
4
Sue Ream
+4
This is an update edit from my earlier review below. Visiting on a busy Saturday night was a very different experience. We waited 45 minutes for a table and then when it was our turn, they seated two tables of 8 in front of us that had just walked in off the streets. Apparently if you have a party that is large there are tables reserved and you can get in immediately and skip the line. This is great if you are the large party but not so much if you are the party of three that has been waiting for 45 minutes. So that meant the staff allocation and pizza orders for those two tables went in before ours as well, and that once we got to our table it was another 40 minutes to pizza. 😡☹️ ******************************* Initial review: This is not your usual Papa John’s/Domino’s pizza. In fact the closest you will get to that is the Classic Specialty pie. However, if you are willing to try grapes on your pizza, enjoy roasted garlic and have an experimental mindset, you will enjoy this. The antipasto is delicious. Down side- service is slow.
4
Mike Hotel
+4
We were excited to be able to order from a selection of ciders. The one we wanted was out of stock, but the backup choices, a cherry pom and blueberry lemonade, were good subs. We waited about 20-25 minutes for our spinach salad to arrive on a slow Sunday afternoon. It was tasty but smaller than we expected. My husband loved his classic pizza. My mushroom garlic pizza was okay. I would probably order something else next time. Our server was kind and professional.
5
Tiffany L
+5
Delicious gourmet pizza. We tried mushroom and bbq and ate it all. We love our pizza and will be back to try others. Cute place on the corner in the town center.
5
Hannah Weidner
+5
We have gotten takeout from here once before and we came in to dine for the first time. They seemed a little bit understaffed but our server was pretty attentive. I had noticed it was taking quite a while for our pizza to come out. Finally after it had been 45 mins since we ordered our pizza, our server told us he was going to talk to the kitchen to see what was going on. A few moments later, the manager on duty came out to talk to us. He told us that our server made a simple error of hitting “save” on our order instead of “send” to the kitchen. He told us they were rushing our pizza and that it would be on the house. He also gave my bf another beer for free, and he brought out chips and salsa to snack on while we waited which we were really appreciated because we had been there for over an hour at this point. The server came out and apologized and the manager was also super apologetic and thanked us multiple times for being patient. I’ve worked in the serving industry and we all make mistakes, but they made it right and that’s what matters. Pizza came out fresh and delicious, and we will definitely be back!
5
Sarah Beth Pugh
+5
We had my birthday lunch here before go- karting! We were sat right away but it took about 15 mins before we were greeted by our server and gave a drink order. We didn't drink (since we were going to drive go-karts) but the root beer on tap is very tasty! Our pizzas were all delicious, excellent topping options and cooked well. Not a crispy undercarriage but still very tasty! Would highly recommend and will be going back!
5
Bud Morgan
+5
Absolutely LOVE this place! My wife and I ordered our pizza ahead. We got the Mediterranean Shrimp and Chicken Gouda 1/2 & 1/2 pizza. It was amazing, as always. We also ordered the seasonal Oktoberfest pizza which was also tasty! We ordered our pizza early so we wouldn’t have to wait when we showed up, but when we got there decided to order a couple beers while we ate. Our server was Ray, and he was fantastic. He was very engaging and seemed to genuinely care about our experience, and our daughter’s (who carried in a Happy Meal). He was a wonderful server, and we absolutely hope he is here the next time we come back.
5
Alex
+5
Favorite pizza place in Indianapolis so far. Those wings were amazing! Will come back for sure, several time and very soon. The Italian pizza is my favorite one. Got some German beer which was great too. Oh the strawberry cheesecake is a must every time. Highly recommended! Server was very cool too!
5
Jay Williams
+5
The service was exceptional, the prices are fair, the pizza is absolutely one of the best in Indiana. Hats off to the general manager super nice guy. Will be returning soon.
4
Alivia Lehman
+4
Garlic cheese bread, the best! We also got a 16" pepperoni pizza. It was delicious. It's a thin crust pizza with the edges a little thicker. The outside edges are crispy. I love it! Not a large place, so I would expect a wait or they do have call ahead seating.
5
J B
+5
Wow ! This is a fabulous selection of unique pizzas and salads! We tried the we tried the Arugula and Goat cheese salad, as well as a half and half of Mediterranean shrimp and Margherita, as well as a small pistachio and cherry pizza! All with the hand tossed crust and each delicious!
5
Olivia T
+5
Yesterday my friends and I went here the food was good but the after math messed us all up. Currently in my bathroom blowing it up while my friends are gripping on to the bathroom sink with their lives from whatever Pies and Pints made our bodies expel. If me and my bowels could leave a zero star we would. Edit: The manager handled the situation very well the food was phenomenal we appreciate the kindness pies and pints gave us definitely going back despite my bowels.
5
Bill Gustin
+5
A buddy and I went last weekend for the first time, and were equally impressed with the pizza 🍕 The service at the bar was great, and they gave us some good insight on what to try. I had the Italian Pie, and my friend tried the Peppadew. Both were excellent, and I’d easily go back for another one in the future.
5
Laura Lechner
+5
Great food, great service. We had flatbread and nachos for appetizers, four different pizzas and two types of sandwiches, six types of beer - everything was delicious!
Clicca per espandere