TOP 10 BEST Restaurants in United States - Updated November 2024

Matteo's Ristorante Italiano

85/100 (5713 ratings)

Restaurants

Italian

Vegan Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Gluten Free Options

Vegan Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Gluten Free Options

Dinner

Lunch

Tiramisu

Meatballs

Lasagne

Tortellini

Shrimp

Tortelloni

Creme Brulee

Chicken Wings

Eggplant

Bruschette

Pasta

Pesto

Salad

Fish

Calamari

Calamares

Crème Brulée

Sit down

Italian

Seating

Table Service

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Highchairs Available

Full Bar

Accepts Mastercard

Accepts Credit Cards

Accepts Visa

Takeout

Private Dining

Accepts American Express

Live Music

Accepts Discover

Reservations

Lunch

Dinner

Mid-range

"The waist staff was attentive and knowledgeable, but not hovering, the crusty bread dipped in oil could have been a meal in itself and the Quattro..."

Denise Gilbey Moe

"Simply amazing! Amazing atmosphere, amazing food, amazing service!!! You have to try the Tortellini Matteo’s, it is to die for! But there isn’t..."

Julie Callantine Mahern

"My husband took me out tonight here for our anniversary dinner. The food was amazing and our waiter Mark was wonderful. We enjoyed everything about..."

Grace Schilling

"We had a fabulous experience while dining here for dinner last night. The food was delicious and the wine choices were great! Our waiter was..."

Kelli Pickering

"I moved to Indiana ten years ago, and was disheartened by the dearth of interesting local flavour. On a whim we tried Matteo's, and I cannot sing..."

Sarah Klein Ratekin

"We ordered carry out for a nice anniversary meal. We were told it would be ready to pick up in 15 minutes but it took a little while longer than..."

Krista Pascoe

"Great food, great service, one-of-a-kind atmosphere, in wonderful downtown Noblesville. Worth the drive from..."

Julie Ward

"We had a private event for my daughters birthday and everything was perfect. Everyone was so friendly, easy to work with, they accommodated us in..."

Victoria Amich

"Amazing!!!...truly authentic and fresh Italian food. Pretty nice place and warm service. Creme brulee is a must. Can't wait to go..."

Roberto Moctezuma

"Excellent menu, great wine list. Prices decent. Great ambience. Wish we had one here in Muncie,..."

Barbara Hesselgrave

"My husband and I love this place. Our first wedding anniversary we found this online and decided to try it out. We have been back for anniversary..."

Morgan Miller

"Lovely lunch! We had the calamari panini and the prosciutto panini. Both were delicious. The bread was homemade and had just the right crunch. We..."

Donna Marie Dispoto-Smith

"Matteo's is the best Italian restaurant in the area! The service is excellent, the food is delicious, and they make celebrating special occasions..."

Kelly Daneri

"Weekends are always busy, make a reservation! Delicious meals, Lots of choices on menu, Daily specials are always tasty. Staff has..."

Jim Pedzinski

"Stopped in for lunch and was very pleased. Had shrimp over pasta with homemade marinara sause which was outstanding. The hot bread is homemade and..."

Richard Dworkus

"It's a bit of a drive for me to get to Matteo's but it's always worth it. I've always had excellent, friendly service and outstanding food. The..."

Joe Seibert

"Half Fettucine Alfredo. Absolutely the best I have ever..."

Facebook User

"Ate at Matteo's tonight with the family. What a cool, classy restaurant! I really like the cool old decor - high, stamped tin ceiling, faux granite..."

Eat At Mo's

"So good!! This little spot is lovely. Their homemade chicken sausage will change your life. The dessert, pana cotta I believe, is too good to..."

Yummmy

"Wonderful Find!. I just got on here yesterday to find a nice fancy place to dine at last night, and based on the many good reviews decided to give..."

Justolliek

"Great place! Food was amazing and the service is second to none! Literally the best place in Hamilton Co for authentic Italian food. I recommend..."

Ginger

"Worth the visit. I was very pleased with the service, price, and quality of the food. Although I do wish they would get some better wines because the..."

Jeremiah Merrell

"Have been coming here for years and have always had great service and food. Very authentic Italian fare. Go without..."

Lance Boyden

"Second time there with our family, great food and..."

Mike

"We love Matteo's!!! Food is outstandingly true authentic experience! And the service? It is top-notch...ask for..."

Bonnie Mark Helmer

"Perfect. This is the best italian restaurant I've been to. It's a very nice atmosphere and the servers are always very helpful. We had a holiday..."

Lori H

"Great Authentic Italian. Had a wonderful evening out with my family. The wine list was very extensive but the knowledge of the staff helped me to..."

Pahri

"Great Food, Great Service, Cool Location!. I love Matteo's, the food is wonderful and the decor is something out of an old movie. I really like the..."

Emmy

"I ate at matteos for the first time Thursday. My waiter suggested a nice white wine to drink while dining outside in the heat. The lasagna was great..."

Meredith W

"Since moving to Noblesville my goal has been to eat more locally! Matteo's was my first attempt! They have live entertainment, an excellent piano..."

JillTarah

"Great date night and date lunch place. My husband and I love it! Great family place..."

JimandCathleen- Baker Vieceli

"Very good. Our best friends and me and the hubs ate here when we took a train ride from Fishers to Nobelsville. The train called "The Hamiltonian"..."

Armywife

"Good Italian. The meal started out with complimentary bread and olive oil. This olive oil is infused with an interesting combination of herbs, and is..."

Sherrel Harris

"Grew up in NJ, alwys wished for "good" Foodd to remind me of home. This place is actaly better then what I grew up with. The only thing that is an..."

Dennis Irlbeck

"I went to this restaurant with a group of people for lunch. The dinner menu is shown within this profile. The lunch menu is similar, but less..."

Adam Manwarren

"Great Place. Matteo's atmosphere is the first thing that hits you. It's a wonderful, historic old building on the courthouse square. The food is..."

Copcritic

"This is one of my favorite places! Excellent food! My parents come from kentucky to eat..."

Westfield Mom

"The food was AMAZING. Hands down best Italian restaurant I've been to. The Italian decor and atmosphere was very nice. Always has a special of the..."

Natalie Glidden

"We came here with my family on May 2021 for dinner to celebrate cousin’s college graduation for nursing school at the Marian University. We had..."

Aileen M Cruz

"Matteo’s combines cozy, elegant, ambiance with friendly attentive service. The fresh bread and dipping oil are delicious as is the Chopped Salad...."

Lynn Jordan

"The food was fresh and delicious. Our first visit here. Our waiter didn't inform us of daily specials, but we heard the other two tables receive list..."

Debi Feathers

"My mom had her wedding in the alley next to Matteo’s while they accommodated everything we needed. I can’t stress enough how perfectly they..."

Maddy Springer

"So.. Most important.... Food was AMAZING! I had the special lasagna... Wife had the veal. Both dishes melted in our mouths. Best pomodoro sauce I..."

J Filler

"The Greatest Italian Restaurant in Indiana. I’ve been coming here for 10+ years— when i was a child and now as an adult. Jenn is the greatest..."

nc

"First time here and service was awesome and so was the food and drinks! We will be..."

Marybeth Hoopengarner

"THE OLIVE APP & CANOLIS!! best Canolis in the city!! I've never had anything like the olives. Service was upscale but we weren't dressed up and..."

Shannon Lamb

"Made reservations for valentine's day and neither of us had been here before. Parking spots were scarce, but we arrived early and didn't have too..."

Joe S

"Went here for the first time and it was excellent. Doug our waiter was outstanding and very courteous. They were extremely busy and it took a very..."

Steven Sexton

"Matteo’s is our new number 1 restaurant—possibly in all of Indy-area! Wife and I went for a date night and were blown away. The atmosphere was..."

Brady Severs

"Relaxing atmosphere in downtown Noblesville. Everything we tried was top notch: appetizers, salads, main dishes and desserts. Staff was..."

Nick Wilcox

"The food was incredible fresh the owner came to the table nice touch in today's world of suffering silence dining highly recommend these guys it was..."

MR. Iykyk

"We visited Matteo’s in July 2023 for our anniversary. It had been probably 10yrs since the last time we ate here. Unfortunately the food quality..."

Sean Baylor

"What a gem! Tried this little place nestled down town Noblesville on a Monday evening for my birthday. It was a whole vibe; quiet, warm elegant and..."

Moni F

"We had a wonderful experience with our family. First time any of have been here. Our waitress was on it. The atmosphere screamed excellence. Dishes..."

Sean Daniels

"4th time visitor. Always impressive. This Filletto di blu gorgonzola is a 10 star kind of dish. 8 oz filet baked in a puff pastry. Served with a..."