Reviews Bellmore Bagel Cafe

5
Ant-knee
+5
Probably the best bagels on long island and the 5 boroughs if u ask me. I bring back 2 dozen to Florida each time im here.
4
jamie flexer
+4
Been to several locations & the hours stink plus gotta get there before sun up for hot bagels also what gives with every bagel shop throws a can of coke into the mix to call it original when my opinion if I wanted a sweet bagel I'd order a sweet bagel!! Be original guys & stick with tradition!!
5
Shaquoya Delona
+5
Really good bagels, great sandwiches and nice employees. Sandwiches are a little pricey but I'm always satisfied with my orders.
5
Joanne Lotempio
+5
Bagel and coffee, you can't mess it up. Weekends are chaotic, parking is impossible at times. My bacon egg and cheese on plain toasted was spot on.
5
Di Ana
+5
One of the better long island bagel cafes on the island. There mac salad is so good. Bagels are always delicious. They are consistent, which makes it one of my go to bagel spots when im in town.
5
Nicole Cole
+5
The best bagels!! Every time I'm in town I buy a dozen or two extra ones to show non-New Yorkers what a real bagel is. 👊 pro tip for anyone else who does that, too: wrap each bagel in saran wrap and seal them up in a freezer bag to freeze. When ready to eat, pop them in the oven for a few minutes and they're like fresh bagels! Much better than microwaving them. 👌
5
Jean Garcia
+5
Delicious bagels. Not crowded. Nice place to dine in also.
5
Rodney Turner
+5
I got the Black Russian with fried egg. It was delicious. I had a hard time ordering but the hostess was patient. It also reminded me of Chompies in Phoenix. Love them and will love this place as well.
5
Brian Tomazic
+5
This place has the best bagels on Long Island! There's often a long line in the morning but it moves super fast and is well worth the wait! I've been going here for nearly 15 years and it never disappoints.
5
Jen Garone
+5
I do not give many 5 star review but this place deserves it. The bagels are quintessential NY bagels. The egg sandwiches are perfect every time. I love the coffee cake. The variety is just amazing. The quality is top notch.
5
joanne lotempio
+5
Bagel with cream cheese and another with butter and coffees. I could have one of everything they display. Coffee was hot and fresh, line was long but moving. People were friendly. Would I go back, yes! For something scrumptious or a sandwich.
5
Arianna Gaffney
+5
excellent bagels and fast service even when they line is long
Clicca per espandere