We had mushroom pizza, fried mushrooms, chicken bacon cheesesteak snd French fries. Delicious!! And you can bring a bottle of wine because it's BYOB. Great service from our server Debbie . Wonderful long time restaurant and open all year too. Can't wait to return!
Great friendly staff!! The chicken francaise is out of this world! I will definitely be returning and I will recommend this place to everyone! Thank you !
Anthony makes one of the best pizza's I've had down here! Tried a Buffalo chicken tonight for me more hot sauce and blue cheese. Other then that it was awesome! Love this place!!
We were on vacation and went in 4 times in one week and loved our food. Service was even better!!! Thank you to Marissa and Martina for making us feel welcomed and making sure our special orders came out the way we ordered them. Have a great summer!!!
Jennifer Lynne McLimans
+5
The pizza was awesome, but the service was absolutely amazing! Very friendly family place!!
Pasta Night tonight! Get the secret word and a great dinner. The dinners are fresh and homemade every Wednesday night.
Bay shore is not just for great pizza anymore! The chef is doing a wonderful job with dinner specials. The steak dinner special is better than most steak house steaks!
I love bayshores. Everyone that works there is so accommodating and nice! I love the new wedge salad! Linguini with crab is amazing!
Stephanie Mioni Kaminski
+5
Our favorite place to eat when at the shore. 🖒🖒
Robin Matalucci Montresor
+5
Always good, servers are very nice and quick. Prices reasonable, we love it there. The sauce is very good and I am fussy about sauce.
Victoria Matthews Magee
+5
Food is excellent and service is always so friendly! We had the bruschetta salad and island tortilla pizza Saturday night and again on Sunday!
Meat ball Pizza was delicious, can’t wait to try other dishes!
Well it’s byob which I’m so happy we were told! Amazing bang for your buck the pizza is so amazing we went for prime rib Sunday and for 3 course it was great! Service was awesome my salad had so much fresh blu cheese prime rib needed a little more salt but was perfectly cooked !
So glad we decided to have our dinner of 18 people at Bayshore restaurant. The food was outstanding. They have a vast menu of home made recipes. The atmosphere was very comfortable and the staff went out of their way to make sure everyone was happy. Thanks Bayshore.
Really good pizza recently.. I assume they're using top ingredients.. Pizza was on the thinner side light crisp, (my favorite style).. Not doughy or mushy... Perfectly cooked.. Owners are sweet too
4.5 . Birthday dinner for my sister. She had salmon which she really enjoyed, I had prime rib special. The rib was large and was done pretty much exactly as I asked for it and it tasted great. We had a very nice dinner. Cost for the two meals was not outrageous
Had an excellent meal tonight, salmon with a honey bourbon glaze. And who knew, the broccoli dipped into that honey bourbon would be so good. Nice job. This special is for the week, so stop in soon. (Google asked for an update, another great meal) #supportlocalresturants
Been coming there for 20 years always great service and great food. I dropped a star because Saturday we were greeted by a hostess who discouraged us from waiting. We wouldn’t have minded waiting we knew they were packed but the server missed out on one of the biggest tipping families in NJ. You never discourage people from staying to wait….you never know who you’re turning away.
First time going inside to pick up dinner. The pizza was great, ready before estimated, friendly staff, and such a cute restaurant. I'm planning to dine in next time!
Picked up a pepperoni pizza and it was good. Only reason for 4 stars on atmosphere is because it seemed strange inside.
Placed a to-go order for a certain time. Order was on time. Food was hot and delicious. Friendly staff. Restaurant was clean and orderly.
Delicious food -the homemade GF ravioli especially a treat for my husband, who has celiac. No gluten exposure.
My family dined in and were very happy with all our food. The first thing I noticed as we entered the dining room was the ambiance! Very homey and inviting and love the music they play! The second thing I noticed is the extreme cleanliness. This is most important to me since I am eating there. So many restaurants I have visited throughout the shore towns that are high end are not this clean. The owners take pride and it shows. Last but certainly not least the food was fresh, cooked to order, came out piping hot, yes hot, many restaurants serve warm food or less than warm and most importantly it was delicious! A restaurant with all these qualities is hard to find. Keep up the good work!
I order the « beast » pizza. It was perfeect !! Really reslly good and fast service !!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes