Sluurpy
Reset

There are 2 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Mushroom Pizza in Omaha

There are 2 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria
91/100 (2140 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
American
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Pasta
Marsala Waffle
Wine
Bloody Mary
Salad
Ceasar salad
Truffle Fries
Wings
Brussels Sprouts
Mac and cheese
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Calamari
Mushroom Pizza
Calamares
Pizza of the Week
Shrooms Pizza
TiramisĆŗ
French Toast
Burger
Chorizo Tacos
Meatball Appetizer
Meatball Hoagie
Tiramisu
Half Order of Onion Rings
Meatballs
North Atlantic Salmon
Pesto
Bianco Verde Pizza
Sangria
Sit down
Pizza
American
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Highchairs Available
Wheelchair Accessible
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Late Night
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I love Pitch, I've never had a bad dish here. Funny thing is they are a pizzeria and I've never actually had their pizza... Their appetizers are all..."
Thomas VanDeventer
"Clean, great quick service considering the crowd, and delicious food. Husband had herb wings - great size, flavorful, and filled him up! Burger with..."
Krissy N Trevor Putnam
"Went to the location at 52 and underwood last night. The food was excellent, and the wait staff was ok. We got the pleasure to sit at the kitchen..."
Erik Peters
"First time eating at PITCH yesterday, it was a busy Sunday (Father's Day). The host was quick to find us a place to sit, the server was friendly and..."
Romulo Rj Vega
"Amazing food we had the burger and spaghetti and meatballs. Service was outstanding Thank you Carley. Would highly recommend. Our new go to place we..."
Jim Downing
"Hands down one of the best meals and dining experiences we have ever had. Couldn't make a reservation because it was just two of us but we were..."
Gabrielle Ryan Merchant
"The shroom pizza was THE best pizza I have ever eaten.. but more than that the wait staff were wonderful; friendly, engaging while offering..."
Peggy OToole
"I went mainly because the place I intended to eat at, which shall be nameless here, was reported to have an amazing burger. As it turned out, I was..."
Kyle Shaw
"One of the best experiences in a restaurant I have had in a very long time. Friendly owner, friendly staff, food good enough to take a picture of..."
Rhonda Myers
"Pretty darn good! The wife, 6yr old boy and I had a lovely Sunday dinner after the World of Wheels auto show. Good atmosphere, music, service, beer,..."
Corey Spreeman
"Blown away by our server Jacob, his menu knowledge, personality, and table maintenance were all top notch. Had the Marsala pizza and it was..."
Brett Kastrup
"Best Margherita pizza in town. Also, fantastic atmosphere, great wine selection, and great customer service. I would also highly recommend the..."
Miranda Griffiths
"The meatball pie was yummy! The buffalo wings were amazing! The meatball appetizer was amazing! Our server was super nice and helpful. Thank you for..."
Vanessa Young
"The Bianco verde pizza was delicious, there was a perfect balance of flavors, and the caramelized onions tasted splendid. The truffle fries were so..."
Nicole Izquierdo
"Dynamite Meatballs! (Name that movie!) Big chunks of squids! Not just one chunk- the whole squid! Pizza? =Great! Waitress was informative about what..."
MtZ Reviewz
"As someone who looks for the nicer niche places out there I felt this was exquisite the pizza was extremely unique excellent atmosphere and perfect..."
Haunted Abyss (HauntedAbyss)
"Holiday party for my Wife's firm was organized and executed wonderfully. Had servers walking around with the hors d'oeuvres and refilling drinks..."
Marc Johnson
"Pitch, I love you. The food here is always incredible. Just be prepared to spend some money. I dream of this sausage, asparagus pasta often. The..."
Maddie Parker
"We had a fantastic meal at Pitch Dundee. We didn't have a reservation because we were eating early but we definitely needed one (Note: even early on..."
Jill Hart
"The pizza was fantastic. I made a custom pepperoni, sausage and mushroom pizza and it was fantastic. Crust was cooked to perfection and the mushrooms..."
jeremy cavazos
"It was our first time here, and we loved it! My salad was delicious. And I stole several bites of my husband's Angus burger. Wow. We will be back...."
D. L. T.
"I was would give Pitch 6 stars if I could- This place gets better every time I go! Food, service, and atmosphere are all great here. The meatball..."
Katherine Merrill
"Great food. Prices are not the lowest but you get a good amount for your money. Great place to hang out. They have a menu with a big variety. ..."
Barbara Mendez
"So many unique pizzas that were really tasty. We tried 5 different slices and none disappointed. The staff were so helpful and..."
Amanda Makoski
"My wife and I have tagged Pitch as our ā€œGo-Toā€ restaurant in Omaha since we moved here a year ago. This place is super consistent with great food..."
Alec Wisecup
"Pitch is great, whenever I'm in town I make sure to go. The atmosphere and decor in the Dundee location is wonderful and the service and food are..."
Steve Bycroft
"I had an amazing experience hosting an event at Pitch! From pre-event communication with Anna to incredible service day-of from Nick, they made it..."
Kate Bracciano
"Lovely location, cozy inside, plus outside seating. Service was excellent. I had the Buffalo fries and the beef stroganoff. The fries were hot, with..."
Craig B
"Itā€™s no secret that Pitch has a certain vibe. The atmosphere is different and comfortable. The wait staff is above average and the food never..."
Joseph Kenney
Don Carmelo's Pizzeria
79/100 (329 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Meat Pizza
Peppers
Large Pepperoni Pizza
Mushroom Pizza
New Yorker Pizza
All Meat Calzone
Anti Pasta Salad
Regular Stromboli
Cheese Bread and Salad
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Table Service
Seating
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Took my son here for a late lunch after errands. I have lived up the road for 6 years and never knew about this place!! I had the antipasta salad..."
Nicholas Dembinski
"We are lucky to live near Don Carmeloā€™s Pizza. We usually get our food to go. The store is small but has a number of comfortable tables. The pizza..."
Steve Tafolla
"Don Carmelo's Pizzeria for the first time last night to celebrate National Pizza Day! And OMG. Don Carmeloā€™s just made it into my top 5 pizza..."
Morgan R.
"Great, laid back place tucked in Rockbrook. Our pizza was very good! We have a hard time with New York style as most of the time our pizzas come out..."
Madi Nicole
"Best local New York Style Pizza in Omaha. The slices are large, hot and the pizzas are made to order. Itā€™s Saturday Evening and our food came out..."
LAURA Steimer
"Our usual haunt was closed on Sunday & ran across 108th&Pacific Don Carmelo's. Very Cute inside! Got garlic cheese bread, pizza & antipasto salad..."
Sabertooth Tiger
"Very good NY style pizza. The website says they have delivery but this location does not offer delivery..."
Amanda M
"Saw the sign from West Center and stopped for some food. The place smells fantastic! I got a veggie pizza with pepperoni. Hands down the best pizza..."
Jamie Cochran
"Great New York style..."
David Nicholson
"Not usually a NY pizza guy, but this pizza is great! Plus my wife and I love the atmosphere of this little place, so that we will drive from Council..."
Eric Schall
"Love the classic-ness of this always great NY Pizza. The original and still..."
Jay Liebenguth (Fresh Media Lab)
"The pizza crust is the right thin. The toppings are delicious. The customer service is very good. I liked the atmosphere, too. It's a good place to..."
Becky Cheek
"Nice place with honestly great tasting pizza and reasonable pricing. Definitely takes me back to Italy just a little while eating here. Maybe not so..."
Drew Rash
"This place is the best!!! My favorite place with the best pizza and the best staff! Itā€™s so clean and the customer service is unbelievable here...."
Mimi D
"Amazing food! My 2 year-old and I stopped in on a whim and were not disappointed. We had a classic cheese pizza, and it may have been one of the best..."
Lauren Correa
"It was a very cute place. The food was delicious and the service was really..."
Nevaeh Seward
"Love this long-time Omaha restaurant. Pizza was a takeout, but walking in tables were clean and friendly staff greeted us as soon as I walked in. My..."
Christine French
"This is our favorite place to get pizza! Always ready fast with friendly service. And most importantly, itā€™s delicious! Itā€™s maybe a little on..."
Sara Bisanz
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use