Old school, local color atmosphere. Traditional pasta and entree resaurant. Focus on quality and a relaxed good time. I had the rib steak wirh rigatoni. Service is attentive. No pretense but attention to the customer here.
Food was great. Service was good. My steak was overcooked but still delicious. I ordered medium and it came with just a slight pink (see pics). Overall experience was good and we will give it another try. Small dining room so there most definitely be a wait if you go around 5 to 6. Bar is huge!
The portions are generous. I have never had a bad meal. There is consistency throughout the menu. Barb, Marie, and Crystal are outstanding!
This is absolutely one of the best kept secrets in N.E. Ohio!!! The surf and turf is amazing! It's not cheap... But if you want quality food, you pay what it's worth. The veal in the bernaise sauce with crab was decadent. The prime rib was fork tender with succulent mushrooms. My daughters salmon was cooked to perfection. I have no complaints, at all. Great food at fair market price! Can't wait til my birthday!!! Great job Silvestro's.
We went on a Wednesday afternoon at 430..perfect time because it got very busy after. The fried shrimp were just that. The side of spag and meatballs was huge. The others were good. The price was too much for pasta and fried foods but the bread was good and the butter spreadable.
A great place with excellent food.Taken there a few years ago by great friends of ours usually go there when we visit them.When you walk in the door you expect to see Dean Martin& Frank Sinatra sitting at the bar. I had recommended it to another couple who were visiting that area and they were so happy they went to it.Also they serve the best bread made locally.
The food is excellent and portion size is large. Love this place.
Stopped on a whim. This is an old school place that hasn't been updated in 50 years. Walked in and heard Dean Martin music playing, which I love. Got the Veal Silvestro and it truly was amazing. Very tender, very delicious. No frills here. Waitress was very nice and very attentive. You should go, if nothing else to take a step back in time!
I ordered a lobster tail. It was one of the largest best tasting best cook lobsters I’ve had in years there’s a must stop in Lake County. I haven’t seen a restaurant like this since I was a kid.
Excellent food every visit! Best prime rib with mushrooms and fresh horseradish! Love their pasta side dish. Homemade salad dressings all delicious!
By far my favorite restaurant. One of those rare places where the food, atmosphere, and service is all top notch. They have definitely perfected their craft in every way.
A stellar meal. I cannot express the quality of the food consumed today. Service was friendly and fast. Food was cooked perfectly, and tasted amazing. It was not crowded, and I would go to say this is a hidden gem in Painesville. I would recommend this as a great place for a date and home cooked meal. 10/10
Lots of menu choices. My veal parmesan and rigatoni were very good. The servings were large.
Best Surf & Turf in Ohio, People! Heather & Maria are the bomb especially for our party. Best Family Gatherings, Every time. Oh, Queen cut Prime Rib is mouthwatering.
Absolutely amazing food! Shrimp cocktail tasty, fresh, and great! Prime Rib and lobster was fantastic. Bring an appetite!
Old school. Dated decor. Cramped or cozy depending on your post of view. Place was packed, which I understand is the norm. Enjoyed my meal. Service was fine.
Always great food, old fashion in a good way. The best prime rib that I have found in northeast Ohio.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes