The place is small but definitely worth waiting to get in. We went during a busy time and got a small table. The food was awesome. Everything we tried was incredible. The decor is quirky and fun. A great date spot! Raw bar menu tells type of oysters, size, location from and taste which helped with our decision. Wait staff was excellent too. Definitely recommend for fresh delicious seafood!!!!
Catch Oyster Bar is a popular local spot and their lobster roll was voted for top 5 in Long Island.
We got their Signature Lobster Roll to share. The split top roll was from Blue Duck Bakery, it’s soft and fluffy. The lobster was cooked perfectly with refreshing lemon mayo.
Catch did an outdoor party for us. They arrived on time, set up a beautiful spread, cleaned up, and the food was absolutely delicious. Their party coordinator, Maisie, was extremely accommodating and great to work with. Thank you, Catch!
Hidden gem in patchogue. Top ten best food experiences I've had. Oysters were amazing, but the creme de la creme was the soft shell crab BLT. Easily the best sandwich I've ever had. Can't wait to go back. Highly recommended for a nice night out on the town. Tell them Tony baloney sent you.
Delicious!!! Great people, great service and every single thing we tasted was fantastic!!!
Cozy spot that looks pretty standard but seriously knows about seafood. Can’t speak much to the raw bar, however the apps were amazing. Fried calamari + baked clams were some of the best I’ve had.
Main courses were all DELICIOUS. Like, easily top five best fish sandwich goes to the classic fried flounder sandwich with fries and slaw. Simple, yet perfected. Friends got the fish tacos blackened tuna wrap - equally DELICIOUS! Highly recommended!
Only downside would be that the place is a bit on the smaller side so can see it getting tight quickly, and street parking is a bit hit or miss due to the busy location!
My wife and I visited Catch on 7/2 Saturday afternoon. Everything was spot on starting with the stuffed clams. Nice flavor . The lobster roll was perfect, served warm and buttery. The Flounder sand which was the BEST I have had in a very long time. The portion was generous , fresh flavor , just perfection. Thank you very much. Makes us appreciate coming back to visit Patchogue. We will be back. 4.5Stars!!
Absolutely amazing food and people. Rubi is amazing, kind and you can tell she cares about what she does. Ask for her, she will take care of you❤️😊
Update...came back again, this time for the lobster roll. Love the vibe here, again Rubi is amazing. The food is amazing. A must try!!
Ridiculously great food. THEY BEST OYSTER SHUCKING IN LONG ISLAND. Very good prices. There is always just one waiter/waitress so make sure to leave a generous tip!
Great food & tap beer selections, we tried three different IPA and it was excellent. The food was awesome, we ordered crabcake slider and chowder, Tai Calamari and Hook Line& Sinker, definitely going back again.
What can I say about this place, it's phenomenal. We stumbled here while working locally and gone in almost daily since. The food is fantastic, super service and great atmosphere. We will be back for sure. Pick anything on the menu and you'll love it. Thank you
Just really, really, really excellent oysters. Fits maybe 15 people. Sit at the bar for the full experience and see the excellent shucking and sizzling and simmering in action.
Three times in four days. I guess you could say we like it. Best Lobster Rolls.
I loved this place. A real neighborhood Oyster bar. Tiny, only a few tables. The bar was great. Terrific drinks and outstanding food. The waitress had a great knowledge of the different Oyster selections. Expensive, but great seafood always is
Happy Hour (M-F 3p-6:30p) is THE TIME to go to Catch! Avoid the crowds and save with specials! We tried almost all the happy hour appetizers and were stuffed. Can't wait to go again to try the amazing oyster variety! Atmosphere (5/5) Food (4.6/5) Service (4.7/5)
Short: Great original recipes and good selections for drinks.
I sat at the bar with Kim as my bartender/waitress. I started off with requests for favorites. Good recommendations.
I went with 4 raw oysters. Oyster Rockefeller, these are outstanding. Then a clam chowder bowl which was tasty. I left feeling full and satisfied. The staff were very friendly and the atmosphere is charming.
My wife and I split the Hook, Line, and Sinker platter and it was plenty of food for both of us. Just as importantly, it was all delicious! All of the components tasted incredibly fresh and you could tell they were prepared with care rather than being mass-produced. Reasonable prices and a friendly atmosphere. I would highly recommend!
Love it so much!
All courses taste good.
Love oyster and scallop the best.
Cape Cod meets Long Island. My husband said it was the best clam chowder he’s ever had, and the steak fries, OMG! Small town feel, very cozy with a local following. Seriously fantastic across the board!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes