Reviews Amici's Pizzeria

First time here. Was very impressed with the food. Will definitely be back. In pictures below are Chicken Picatta, Chicken Sorrento, Cheesecake (Rogatta), and a Tartufo.

My new construction project just started next to here. I got their chicken Parm and pepperoni pizza and tastes great! Been going there multiple times by now and won’t be going anywhere else for the time being. Would probably be gaining a few pounds after a while, but who cares the food taste great! Sincerely, Atrin H

Best pizza in area! Excellent, friendly service, quick delivery and food is hot upon delivery. My family and friends have tried other local places for pizza that don’t compare to Amici’s quality.

Wonderful service, the food was delivered so fast and it was fresh out of the oven hot

So, far my review is only for the classic pizza parlor side of the business. With that in mind, while this place has had its ups and downs over the last decade or so and changes in ownership, I can firmly state, NOW it's VERY good again. The pizza is excellent and no one outdoes their pepperoni pie slices: further, It has that authentic Peekskill Pizza feel once more (less sweat and less salty), with lots of additional excellent take-away options from a full menu. I didn't realize how good Peekskill pizza generally was until I left the area. What's interesting to me, is that these folks have managed to capture the profile of an "older" , to me, more traditional type of pizza: A bit like the original Napoli's, if you were lucky enough to enjoy that pizza in Peekskill, that long ago (BTW: they are still up in Lake Mohegan). It also seems that these owners have changed the atmosphere of the dine-in side; The formerly closed in feeling, sit down dining area seems more open and inviting: you can easily see in and out, but it's still insulated/separated from the in/out pizza side of the operation. I'm looking forward to trying that side of their business. I've developed gluten intolerance so i only enjoy a slice once in a great while and I pay the price; but in this case, it's worth it. My family loves the pizza here, and we (They) get it frequently. Haven't sat down in the dine-in/restaurant side here in many years and through the different owners, so ' don't know about that end of things. It certainly looks very good from the pictures and reviews and I look forward to trying it. In the meantime, I highly suggest trying this place for good, and subtly, specially, different pizza. Enjoy!

Been coming here regularly for a while. They have great thin crust pizza if you like that. Big buff chicken and BBQ guy and 99% of the time they are 10 out of 10. But I have to be honest, last 2 times I've been in there the pizza in the window has looked old. If it looks that way next time this will go down to 3 and I won't be back. If it's back to normal I'll happily bump this up to a 5 star rating the pizza is worth it.

Nice dining room, very good food, excellent and professional staff.

We had a great experience at Amici last Saturday night before seeing a show at Paramount Hudson Theater. The food and service was excellent. The fireplace gave the space special charm. It was clean and decorated nicely. We enjoyed the beer and wine and atmosphere. Excellent prices. Owner checked on us often. We highly recommend and will be back.