Reitano's Pizza - Pickerington - Photo album

We came in on Feb. 15th to try the pizza. It tasted so delicious and freshly homemade. The atmosphere was very warm and the staff were all very friendly and attentive. The manager was walking around checking on everyone which made it nice that they all were so attentive to the quality of our meal an

Pizza came out hot and fresh. Super delicious!

Newly remodeled, good food (pizza) good service family atmosphere; been there 5 times and will continue to go back!! Good thing it’s not closer because I’d be there at least twice a week! Would recommend it to anyone. (Secret) ribs are coming soon 👍👍👍

Have been wanting to try Reitano's since our bad experience at Taranto's. Not enough cheese on the sub and sub was smaller but still good. Pizza was better than Taranto's. (Better pepperoni and crust!) Employee's were very friendly when sub, salad and pizza was brought to our table. Steve was very w

Great food from a small town pizza place. It's clear that the new ownership is taking pride in not only in the quality of the food, but also the environment. The place hasn't looked this good in years and management/staff are always nice to deal with.

There was great food and a really nice atmosphere. I had the Italian sub and it was amazing. The pizza had the perfect amount of cheese, sauce, and toppings.

We have given Reitanos tries on 3 different occasions, we usually order pepperoni. Twice we have picked up and once had delivery and all on a week night. The two times we have picked up by the time we get home, 5 minute drive the crust is floppy. The time we had delivered the pizza wasnt even cooked

Pizza was very greasy and service (check out) was extremely slow. Wouldn't recommend this place for pizza. Despite all of this, Reitano's had a large, clean, and family friendly area for dining it.