JUSTIN DIETZ
Simple, easy, effortless, delicious, crispy, chewy. These are all the words I would use to describe Slice on Broadway. 2 cuts with pep. Sat upstairs and enjoyed the no gimmick pizza. The way it should be. Keep doing your thing Slice.
John Lopez
I believe that I was the last pie to be made that day and I would like to send a Big Thank You! to Slice one Broadway in Beechview. Pepperoni, Sausage, and extra Cheese, this was the BEST Pizza I have ever had from Slice. The sauce was sweet on an airy crust, the toppings were perfect. This Pizza was a 5 out of 5 stars!
Q FromJuice
Delicious Cheesesteak Hoagies, and Pizza 🍕 don't go to that overrated f word pizza shop come here for Quality recipes and they deliver here.
Sunil
Ordered using the Slice app and showed up based on the promised time. Easy parking in the back, walked in and greeted immediately by the friendly staff. My pizza was ready and was still piping hot. I should know as had to have a small slice as soon as I sat in the car.
Let me say, the pizza is very good and in my top 5 in Pittsburgh for sure. The crust when eaten alone is just like eating great bread, airy and flavorful. The ratio of sauce, cheese and toppings to the base is excellent. The sauce has a little kick and cheese blend they use is great.
Will be back for more for sure.
Stacy D
Slice on Broadway is my favorite pizza is Pittsburgh. This location has a few options by the slice as well as a dining area upstairs. Beer is also sold here. Grab a slice and a beer and watch the T roll by.
Keriayn Schmitt
Could have had 5 if they had even offered to correct the issue. But telling my mother who was very excited about ordering this pizza and doesn’t get to eat out often that “you can’t please everyone” and it’s “not burnt” when it wasn’t just the crust that was burnt but the meatballs and the banana peppers were mushy from being over cooked. She also left a 25% tip…. And was still treated like this. Absolutely unacceptable own up to your mistakes.
I have edited my review solely based off my interaction with Rico. He went above and beyond in my opinion. The entire goal was just to be heard but he took a step further for that I have changed to 4 stars.
dawn Zamorski
This was the first pizza place we visited when we moved back to Pittsburgh. The pizza and service were awesome. We have been back because it's a great neighborhood pizza place and they are so friendly!
PGH Live Admin
One of best New York pizzas you’ll find in pgh
Zach Yeet
Some of the best pizza in Pittsburgh, definitely the best New York style in the city.
Natalie Friedrich
I am so happy we finally had the chance to stop at Slice on Broadway. We absolutely loved every bite of our delicious pizza. Most places don't use gorgonzola which is one of my favorite cheese on a pizza and gives it such a unique flavor. The cook/cashier was very friendly and as you can see from the photo makes one beautiful pizza pie!!! We will be back very soon to try other menu items that sounded very good.
Steve G
I'm not a huge fan of their pizza, but that is purely personal preference and has no bearing on my review for that reason- it's all about preference, the quality of their pizza is very good if you like that New York style that they have. But the reason I rate it so high is their hoagies, salads, and rolls are the best you will get from any pizza place around, and you would have a hard time finding a better sandwich than their gonzo or a salad at any non pizza places either at that price point. Also their ranch dressing is the best ranch I have had anywhere.
Shane Miele
5/5 everything. In the area for work today and stopped by because it was close to the job site. Fast and friendly, delicious food, great price.
I’ll 100% be back next time I’m in the area. 🔥🔥🔥
Matthew Gum
Good pizza. No complaints. Fast service. Beautiful area to sit and eat. Good times!!!
Miriam Roth
Great tasting pizza! Takeout only, so ordering ahead is recommended.
Eladio Bobadilla
Delightful pizza! Some of the best NY-style I've had in a long time!
John Kendelhardt
Like most pizza joints, if you order delivery during a busy time of day then it is going to take about an hour plus to get your pizza. If you order pickup they pretty much have your order ready in 20 minutes without fail. Grew up in Jersey eating NY style pizza and personally I think this is easily the best NY style pie you can get in the burgh. Just give me a large cheese (as an 8 cut) from this place and I'm good to go.
Kayla Marie Booth
If i could put no stars I would...placed a delivery order at 8:07 pm. Called at 9:19 To see where my order was. I was told that they were running behind and that it would be here within 15 minutes hot and fresh....its currently 9:50..still no pizza... I live a 2 minute drive from there. I would have picked up if I didn't have a sleeping baby at home...i was a pretty regular customer...will not be ordering from there anymore...worst service.
Kara Stahl
Best pizza in south hills.. and Pittsburgh. Everyone that works here is so nice. Once I showed up early to pick up my pizza and they gave me a gigantic piece of delicious cheese cake for waiting! Great service!
Tim Hallahan
Great food, the only drawback, is you have to add 20 - 30 minutes to the time they say your order will be done if you place your order at the Carnegie or Beechveiw store.
Benjamin Leone
Terrible service. Ordered for a company lunch and had cold dry pizzas. We also ordered 5 Italian hoagies which came soggy and about 3 pieces of meat with old bread. Called and asked to speak with manager and he told me he would give 10% off next visit. Really next visit!? My entire office was displeased and will make sure everyone in the area knows about how bad their quality of food and customer service is.
Worst pizza in Pittsburgh.
Jacob Samuel
Literally the best pizza in town. I wish I could give more than 5 stars.
Kari Ammon Sartory
I loved it!! It was very good!! Next time we will get the ginormous pizza!! We had it half plain cheese and the other half bacon!!!! Delicious!!!!
Darren Lewis
Interesting pizzas and hoagies. Huge slices of cheesecake!
Erica Rose
My first time getting a pie from Slice was last evening-New Year's Eve. The gentleman who took my order was pleasant and ordering was quick and easy. They gave me a 20-25 minute wait time and it was an accurate estimate. When I picked up my large, specialty pizza, the guys couldn't have been friendlier or more enthusiastic. Brought the pie to a party and it was a big hit. I enjoyed it as well. A great first experience and I'll be back!
Amanda Koenig
Pizza was delivered 30 minutes longer then stated it would be and pizza cheese was so over cooked it was crunchy then I was told that's normal for white pizza. But if you look thru the photos none of the white pizzas they took pictures of look that way.
Allison Roth
The Pizza Margherita is the absolute best!! Awesome service too!
Kristen Elizabeth
This was my first time at slice on Broadway. My roommate and I went to the beechview location. We loved everything about it. The building was beautiful, all staff was friendly, and the pizza was amazing! We will be back!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes