Sluurpy
Reset

There are 9 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Port Jefferson

There are 9 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Pie
87/100 (582 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Cheese
Pizza N Spaghetti
mozzarella sticks
Brounie Con Helado
Cobbler
Grilled Chicken with Penne
Gnocchi Bolognese
Medium Pie Half Rustica and Half Chicken Pesto
Vegetable Pizza
Half Verde Half Rustica Pie
Small Pizza
Barbeque Chicken Pizza
Pasta
Penne Vodka
Fried Ravioli
Baked Clams
Organic Coal Fired Chicken
Pasta
Funnel Sticks
Salad
Classic Margherita Pie
Pesto
9 Side Salad
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The staff is always friendly and attentive.My son and I frequent The Pie twice a year. We're pizza fanatics,and the pizza is so good.Our last visit I..."
Andrea M Sample-Marshall
"Took the ferry over from CT and wanted to have some pizza instead of our usual " seafood" lunch. I think the best way to judge a pie is to order..."
Kathy Dulski Dorsey
"Excellent quality food , friendly staff and pricing is at great value ...recommend it to all family , singles and overall just a great bunch of..."
Luis Vega
"Beautiful lady’s staff -Is it clean please , Beautiful pizza �, I recommend to my friends - Nassau country, queens , Great selection food , wine..."
Jaime Rojas
"The food here never fails. No matter what we order it is absolutely delicious. I must say though their pizza is on a whole other..."
Vincent Cesarino
"Nice friendly service and atmosphere. The food is delicious , especially the portabella mushroom appetizer !! I highly recommend the Pie to others..."
Deb Lev
"The restaurant is clean, the food is fresh and delicious and the staff is always friendly! I would totally recommend..."
Jessica Anziano
"The food is fantastic. I'm a huge fan of the Buffalo Pizza but it's all good. The service can be a little on the slow side but the servers..."
Tim Maroney
"Great food great service best pizza on Long Island 5..."
Lenny Musillo
"Great Pie, living in TX now I only come home a couple of times a year and this was my first time here. I'll definitely be making it one of my routine..."
Michael Vecchio
"Amazing family restaurant, great tasting food, outstanding and friendly staff , beautiful and spontaneous atmosphere, Love..."
Carl Captain Martinez
"Best brick oven pizza on Long Island ,calzones are a lot smaller than they used to be but still very..."
Anthony Savino
"My server Kerri was amazing. She was so kind and attentive! I will definitely be coming back here very soon! Thank you so much again Kerri!..."
Elijah Lewis
"The joy of a converted parking lot to an outdoor eatery continues! A nice tent-tall and spacious, some outdoor greenery...voila! The wait staff is..."
Glenn
"This place was decent. We ordered apps and entrees. Risotto rice balls - good Mozzarella en Carozza - was NOT mozzarella in carozza, but more like..."
Maggie Isaacs
"We ordered garlic aioli calamari which was just okay (lightly breaded which was good but the squid was too soft...) Which is the only reason for the..."
Alex
"Pizza is a gift from God, it's definitely has a rich flavor especially with the margaritas pie. Exceptional service and the atmosphere is beautiful..."
Joel Monserrate
"I really enjoyed this place. The Classic Margherita pizza was really good and the bread was super fresh. The service couldn’t get much better..."
David Ryan
"Large assortment of brick oven pizzas as well as other Italian specialties. Our waitress was excellent with an upbeat..."
Ray C
"Outstanding pizza. Kids chicken and broccoli is next level. Service is..."
Bill M
"I ordered off Uber eats. The food was cold but I won’t blame the pizza place, it was probably a long drive. But it was still really good, probably..."
Nikki Santorelli
"We love it here! We can go and get pizza for my family that eats gluten, and I can get the fire roasted chicken gluten free! The root beer us also..."
Chelsea Whitney
"We had our Christmas Eve party catered at The Pie. From the help I received at pickup to the delicious food, it was perfect!! Everything was great...."
james gallant
"This place is absolutely incredible. Me and my fiancé were gonna do take out but the inside is so sophisticated that I wanted to eat inside. Best..."
Jacob Brenner
"We enjoyed the brick oven pizza, salad and soup everything was..."
Anna Inverso
"Great service, great food! We came just as they were opening in the evening and were warmly greeted and taken to our booth. Our server (Jenn?)..."
Vel Natarajan
"Good place to eat lunch with friends.. server was very friendly. Pizza was very..."
Tony Chen
"Classic Margarita pizza, small. It was delicious, and I plan on going..."
Sandi Sullivan
Anthony's Pizza
86/100 (58 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
"We arrived to the ferry with just a small window of time and empty stomachs. I was thinking of just getting a few of the ready-made slices, but then..."
Geoffrey Staysniak
"I grew up on LI, went to Our Last of Wisdom (Catholic School just up the street), and went down port every couple of weeks. I've since moved to..."
Danielle Rooney
"If you’re looking for a cheap quick slice, go here. Nothing fancy. Had a regular cheese slice and pepperoni slice. Serviceable..."
Hormuz N.
"Great location, always open late, but i think its a bit over priced.. hopefully i was just over charged.. no bad vibes here.. 15 $ for 2 special..."
AJ DESIGN
"Their garlic knot crust pie is..."
Rebecca Kassay
"Not bad! Pizza better than youde expect in a little place like this, kinda like a gem in the rough. Only draw back was the lobby was tiny and theres..."
Ralph Fiore
"Good pizza, fast service; just what you would expect from a hole-in-the-wall type of place. Grab a slice and enjoy walking around town as you eat...."
Tani B
"Amazing. Great pizza. Quick service. Perfect if your in a hurry and need a quick slice or a whole pie. When all else is closed PJ Pizza will be..."
Ben Schotman
"Their pizza is really good. Their service is excellent and the employees are so friendly. Love this..."
Kathleen Gersh
"We ordered a pie and it was amazing!! So fresh and so..."
Mary Johnson Browne
"Friendly, convenient true NY style pizza. You can't go wrong stopping by this neighborhood..."
Clinical Care Solutions
"The best pizza place in town. It's the only 1 in town other than the PIE. But the only place to get just a slice of..."
Jesse Davenport
Ralphs Famous Italian Ice
84/100 (153 ratings)
Restaurants
Dessert
Italian
Italian
Ice Cream
Sit down
Italian
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"Best water ice. All real..."
William Nielsen
"Always my go to when i hit up "down port" to grab a nice meal and a great dessert..."
Richard Raynock
"The italian ices is their specialty! Completly forget about the ice cream as has no flavor and taste like cheap supermarket ice cream...so it is one..."
Wael Gouda
"Just needs to have more varieties, i.e gluten free and etc to please everyone. Other than that, nice..."
Harry D
"Ice cream was pretty good! Service was nice. Great place to get some..."
Peter
"Delicious lemon ice, but the prices are getting ridiculous! I mean it's just frozen lemon juice &..."
Phillip Caputo
"Great assortment of Italian ice, ice cream- hard & soft serve, delicious drinks and lots of yummy cold..."
Karen Lee
"Gotta love Ralph's. It's an institution in Long Island. Great assortment of Ices. Prices have gone up over the years , but still worth..."
Matthew Siegelbaum
"Almost any kind of ice cream, any way you like it. A little pricey but the quality is worth the extra couple of..."
Stella Laffey
"Excellent selection. Like ice cream shops of..."
Z. Jakl
"Who doesn't love Ralphs ice..have to get a bunch before they close for the season. If u haven't gone...u..."
Brian B
"Very good overall. But that raspberry "soft serve" was actually just..."
Emily Schiller
Vincenzo's Pizza
84/100 (461 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
"My server Kerri was amazing. She was so kind and attentive! I will definitely be coming back here very soon! Thank you so much again Kerri!..."
Elijah Lewis
"The joy of a converted parking lot to an outdoor eatery continues! A nice tent-tall and spacious, some outdoor greenery...voila! The wait staff is..."
Glenn
"This place was decent. We ordered apps and entrees. Risotto rice balls - good Mozzarella en Carozza - was NOT mozzarella in carozza, but more like..."
Maggie Isaacs
"We ordered garlic aioli calamari which was just okay (lightly breaded which was good but the squid was too soft...) Which is the only reason for the..."
Alex
"Pizza is a gift from God, it's definitely has a rich flavor especially with the margaritas pie. Exceptional service and the atmosphere is beautiful..."
Joel Monserrate
"I really enjoyed this place. The Classic Margherita pizza was really good and the bread was super fresh. The service couldn’t get much better..."
David Ryan
"Large assortment of brick oven pizzas as well as other Italian specialties. Our waitress was excellent with an upbeat..."
Ray C
"Outstanding pizza. Kids chicken and broccoli is next level. Service is..."
Bill M
"I ordered off Uber eats. The food was cold but I won’t blame the pizza place, it was probably a long drive. But it was still really good, probably..."
Nikki Santorelli
"We love it here! We can go and get pizza for my family that eats gluten, and I can get the fire roasted chicken gluten free! The root beer us also..."
Chelsea Whitney
"We had our Christmas Eve party catered at The Pie. From the help I received at pickup to the delicious food, it was perfect!! Everything was great...."
james gallant
"This place is absolutely incredible. Me and my fiancé were gonna do take out but the inside is so sophisticated that I wanted to eat inside. Best..."
Jacob Brenner
"We enjoyed the brick oven pizza, salad and soup everything was..."
Anna Inverso
"Great service, great food! We came just as they were opening in the evening and were warmly greeted and taken to our booth. Our server (Jenn?)..."
Vel Natarajan
"Good place to eat lunch with friends.. server was very friendly. Pizza was very..."
Tony Chen
"Classic Margarita pizza, small. It was delicious, and I plan on going..."
Sandi Sullivan
P.j. Harbour Club
83/100 (60 ratings)
Restaurants
Steakhouse
Seafood
Italian
Seafood
Italian
Steakhouse
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Drinks
Sit down
Italian
Steakhouse
Seafood
Waterfront
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Television
Private Dining
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Drinks
Mid-range
Pasta Pasta
82/100 (1293 ratings)
Restaurants
International
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Italian
International
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Crab
Tortelloni
Scallops
Chocolate mousse
Pesto
Clams
Fish
Calamari
Pork
Risotto
Mussels
Tuna
Calamares
Shrimp
Filet Mignon
Lobster
Pasta
Salad
Tortellini
Sit down
International
Italian
Takeout
Private Dining
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Pasta pasta has been an absolute favorite spot for me and my fiancé for years now. On the occasion when we try a new restaurant we end up..."
T G
"Very nice place to enjoy a meal. Service was great, and the prices are reasonable for the large portions served. I'm definitely making it my favorite..."
Elle Villa Senor
"Very nice staff. Delicious food. Large portions. Pretty decor. Solid wine list......However, no cocktails....liquor isn't served because of zoning..."
Paul Vetrano
"Really neat place. It's an older building that they dressed up with lights and hangings. Nice old wide board wooden floors. The pasta tastes home..."
Martin G Miller
"First off I very rarely right reviews but after last nights dining at Pasta Pasta I couldn’t let this pass. We came with a very large group. The..."
Denise Rubcewich
"We've been here several times over the past few years. The atmosphere is perfect for a date night, anniversary, or other special occasion. We..."
James Mancuso
"The fixes lunch menu is amazing…$29 per person! Appetizer~Entree~Dessert. The food, service and atmosphere amazing very quiet and cozy. The fixed..."
Stacey Kavanagh
"We recently catered from Pasta Pasta for a family gathering. The food was so delicious and plentiful, and the presentation was lovely. Debbie, the..."
Veronica Colchamiro
"Having just returned from Italy, I recommend some Italian music! We had to ask for bread as we were seated 10 minutes. Not crazy about the scents at..."
Bobbie Seelin
"My family and I came over to Port Jeff by ferry from Connecticut. Pasta Pasta was recommended to us by a colleague of mine and I must say the..."
Mainy Bravo
Duebaci Restaurant
81/100 (38 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Italian
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
"I can't even begin to explain my experience here. I have been to a LOT of places that friends have sworn to me are real deal Italian. This, hands..."
Nicole Edmonds
"7 of us went out for a birthday dinner. We had reservations and our table was waiting for us. The place isn't too large, the decor was nice, simple,..."
Jennifer Pelosi
"Delicious new entry Down Port. Great Italian food, sauce was tasty and a bit spicy, which I love. Drinks were made fresh and good. Great happy hour,..."
Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino
"We tried DueBaci tonight in Port Jeff village and was thoroughly impressed. We used the valet parking and the staff was excellent. We had a..."
Norman Querido
"Just hung with friends at the bar. We had many different dishes and was very pleased with all of them. Service was great. The place is beautiful. I..."
Mark Buonagura
"First time eating here but certainly not the last. The owner came to the table to chat as well as the manager Stacy. They were very interested in our..."
barbara karaftis
"Restaurant and decor is beautiful and inviting. We tried Cantera Negra tequila which I've only seen here and it was super smooth. Food was good but..."
Alexander George
"10/11/2019 we have been here a few times before and enjoyed everything we had. Fresh food, nicely presented, and wonderful staff. Pleasent, ..."
mitchell rakita
"Loved it so much ordered it twice in the same week when visting my mother. Comfort food, perfect portions, breed good, everything was fast and the..."
Hunter Cole
"Went to celebrate my parents 50th anniversary!! Food was excellent! The owner and staff were amazing. This is now our new place...."
John Scalamandre
"Outstanding food! service is even better!!!! I use to go to Mario's in east seatauket but now I'll be coming..."
anthony marino
"Wonderful farm to table food. Gracious owner and excellent wait staff. Beautiful..."
Carrie Mitchell
"Consistently great food and service, wish it was less noisy but always enjoy dinner..."
Briana
"Wonderful Harborside restaurant! Amazing service, drinks & food. Love the..."
Diane Larsen
"Great food, drinks ...but wait... prices are good..."
Ehrfried Bohnhorst
"Delicious food and super nice staff! Really knowledgeable and..."
Chris Tucker
"Food was good. Waitress was a little..."
Victoria J
Ruvo Restaurant East
81/100 (4170 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
American
Italian
Italian
American
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Pesto
Lobster
Fish
Crab Cake
Eggplant
Cheesecake
Pasta
Ribs
Salad
Crab
Scallops
Bass
Clams
Meatballs
Duck
Sandwiches
Cheesecakes
Calamari
Burger
Bolognese
Risotto
Ice Cream
Mussels
Shrimp
Gelato
Tuna
Beef
Calamares
Salmon
Cakes
Sit down
Italian
American
Takeout
Television
Live Music
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Brunch
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Mid-range
"This place is perfect for restaurant week! I highly recommend it for any celebration. The service is quick and friendly, the atmosphere is cozy, and..."
Natalia Ilina
"Ruvo is the perfect restaurant for Southern Italian food! Not on the busy main street, parking right outside the door, beautiful building... but the..."
thrillcats
"It’s a yummy experience. The ambiance is very welcoming and charming. Amazing martinis, food and service. Staff is attentive and make great..."
Danielle Gilberto
"We had a fantastic birthday dinner at Ruvo. The food was incredible and the service was friendly and professional. Their price fixe menu has so many..."
George L.
"Amazing place for dinner. Had the duck and calamari. Both were..."
Kevin Armato
"Good restaurant. Service was decent, quiet and efficient. Atmosphere was good as well for a Sunday lunch. Cocktail were not exceptional but good. We..."
Ludovic MASSON
"Wonderful service, great food, made reservations same day for 530. The scallops and shrimp were amazing. We had calamari as appetizer and it was very..."
Katherine
"So pretty! Excellent food and service. Came for brunch. Will return to check out dinner. Husband and I very..."
Holly Ferruso
"I came here for my birthday dinner, there were 4 adults (plus my niece who orders off the adult menu), and 3 additional kids. Our waitress was..."
Danielle Porrazzo
"A well curated menu and delicious experience from beginning to end. We left feeling satisfied without feeling like we ate too much. Both sauces I..."
Courtney Thompson
"Excellent food, especially their brunch menu. The service was adequate but nothing to write home about. A well decorated and heated venue with..."
Peter Devlin
"Always Fabulous, I get served at the bar great food!! I love the scallops,duck ,veal chop when they have it ,I always order from the specials..."
Deena Giardina
"Excellent Sunday Brunch! Normally I enjoy a Sunday Brunch buffet but if you are looking for a great sit down Sunday Brunch, you must try Ruvo! The..."
Christopher De Francis
"Excellent food and service. We thoroughly enjoyed everything we ordered. Our server Josh was outstanding. First time there, and we will be definitely..."
Stamatis Koutouzis
"If you’re looking for a nice sit down restaurant I highly recommend Ruvu East . The food was delicious. My guests and I did the dinner special and..."
Tstarr Crafts
"Lovely Italian recommended by owner of local b&b. Baked clams were excellent as was the gnochi, crab cakes and fish special. Staff were prompt and..."
Michael
Due Baci
71/100 (50 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
"I can't even begin to explain my experience here. I have been to a LOT of places that friends have sworn to me are real deal Italian. This, hands..."
Nicole Edmonds
"7 of us went out for a birthday dinner. We had reservations and our table was waiting for us. The place isn't too large, the decor was nice, simple,..."
Jennifer Pelosi
"Delicious new entry Down Port. Great Italian food, sauce was tasty and a bit spicy, which I love. Drinks were made fresh and good. Great happy hour,..."
Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino
"We tried DueBaci tonight in Port Jeff village and was thoroughly impressed. We used the valet parking and the staff was excellent. We had a..."
Norman Querido
"Just hung with friends at the bar. We had many different dishes and was very pleased with all of them. Service was great. The place is beautiful. I..."
Mark Buonagura
"First time eating here but certainly not the last. The owner came to the table to chat as well as the manager Stacy. They were very interested in our..."
barbara karaftis
"Restaurant and decor is beautiful and inviting. We tried Cantera Negra tequila which I've only seen here and it was super smooth. Food was good but..."
Alexander George
"10/11/2019 we have been here a few times before and enjoyed everything we had. Fresh food, nicely presented, and wonderful staff. Pleasent, ..."
mitchell rakita
"Loved it so much ordered it twice in the same week when visting my mother. Comfort food, perfect portions, breed good, everything was fast and the..."
Hunter Cole
"Went to celebrate my parents 50th anniversary!! Food was excellent! The owner and staff were amazing. This is now our new place...."
John Scalamandre
"Outstanding food! service is even better!!!! I use to go to Mario's in east seatauket but now I'll be coming..."
anthony marino
"Wonderful farm to table food. Gracious owner and excellent wait staff. Beautiful..."
Carrie Mitchell
"Consistently great food and service, wish it was less noisy but always enjoy dinner..."
Briana
"Wonderful Harborside restaurant! Amazing service, drinks & food. Love the..."
Diane Larsen
"Great food, drinks ...but wait... prices are good..."
Ehrfried Bohnhorst
"Delicious food and super nice staff! Really knowledgeable and..."
Chris Tucker
"Food was good. Waitress was a little..."
Victoria J
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use