Gaetano's - Port Orange - Photo album

Amazing. I get something different every time I come and it's always the best thing I've ever had. The owner Sherin is from Manhattan and the pizza tastes just like in NYC. I recommend the Buffalo chicken pizza or anything that comes with the homemade meatballs.

One star because you can't leave less. We arrive Sign with name is off/dark but large "open" neon sign on and front door is held open on closer inspection. See no one inside, guest or employee. Walk in immediately to left large sign says "Menu".. the menu confused us immediately as it's from Luigi

We had many reviews, both negative and positive. This was a PHENOMENAL experience!!!! The meatball sub was EXCELLENT and the antipasti salad was beyond DELICIOUS and the garlic knots....OMG!!!!! We could have eaten them all night!!! ALL of the Staff were kind, helpful, and very attentive. As my

My wife and I ordered food from while on our anniversary trip. We ordered 2 orders of the tiramisu and unfortunately both had mold on them. I unfortunately did not notice this and now I will wait and see if i get sick. My wife called the restaurant and they didn't seem to care. Definitely would

We love Tommy. He is so personable. If you don't like it.. he'll make it right. Wonderful pizza. So tasty we ordered a full one to go home. This may be NY style pizza.. i'm sold.! The store is sadly hidden to the back of a small plaza that can't be seen from the road. I'd like to see it eithe

This restaurant now has new management. The pizza is really on point: NY style thin crust, with terrific sauce and fresh ingredients. My wife loves their baked ziti, and their portions are huge. I think this pizza restaurant is one of the best around in the area. Recommend highly!

So I ordered a cheese pizza, chicken parmesan, lasagna, and two orders of wings. First the chicken parmesan was burnt. The sauce was dried up. (Thick and clumpy). It did not taste good at all. Second is the lasagna. The sauce was the same way. Like it had been setting there for awhile. I was there

Really good pizza joint. Friendly owners and staff. We like thincrust and they do it just right. Wings are meaty and just the right amount of sauce. They're getting busier so plan on 30 minutes for pickup most nights.