Reviews Goodfella's Pizza

I once rated this place a little lower. Last year I tried it out and over all I liked it. I made a statement about how it's not as good as NY pizza but is the best around here. I got a reply that I95 would take me back north haha which was truly hilarious. I'm now back in the area and have eaten here several times. I can honestly say they deserve 5 stars. It is by far my new favorite place. The pies they have laid out to choose from are Excellent. A great variety and always fresh. The young lady working behind the counter is right on point getting things done and very pleasant. I love this place. No more NY needed for me.

This was mine and my Son Brandon's first time here. After running errands all day and still having to go to Publix we opted to try this Pizza place for a quick bite since it was in the same plaza as Publix. Wow, what a find! They have a special, 2 - Cheese Slices and a drink for $6.45! So, we asked if 1 of the Slices could be a Meat Slice? And Yes, but for a small up charge which is still an amazing deal! We also decided to order 6 garlic knots for I believe $2.95 and we both agreed that these were some of the BEST garlic knots we've ever had! The knots are served with wonderful chunks of real garlic swimming in butter and then a side of red sauce. I didn't even need or want the sauce because of how good they were all on thier own but my Son said how delicious that was so I gave it a try. You could tell the red sauce was homemade and it had this awesome sweetness to it, I couldn't decide if I wanted with or without, lol! As we were throughly enjoying our knots out came our slices which were bigger than our heads!! We couldn't believe the size of these slices and it had that nice thin and crispy crust, with the cheese that was stringy when I tried to cut this enormous slice and the flavor of thier pizza sauce and cheese was truly delicious! Needless to say I couldn't even finish my slice after eating those 3 delicious garlic knots! Also, that special does come with a fountain drink with unlimited refills (All Pepsi products) my Fav! This unplanned trip to just get a slice of pizza, turned into the best pizza and garlic knots we've had in some time! Now, there are several Goodfella's locations all around (look at the photos I took to find a location near you) plus, they DELIVER! The delivery area has a mileage restriction! Unfortunately, we are just out of thier delivery area but we will certainly drive there for a carry out!