While staying in the hospital I decided to order from a pizzeria nearby. I was researching for really good slices and this restaurant had great reviews for it! Unfortunately my food came cold but good thing the nurse was able to warm up my food for me. I never eat cold pizza but I decided to not warm up the pizza cause microwave pizza is gross and wow! I was blown away by how good the slice was and it wasn’t even hot! The wings were good but I definitely thought to myself on how I should have 3 slices lol!
I am only rating the pizza. I give the round cheese slice a 9/10. Consistently good. Good dough, good sauce and good cheese. Only 3 ingredients and yet so many mess it up. I’ve had the slasher. Very good square very good also but the round is my go to at this place.
First time here and it did not disappoint! We got two slices of the buffalo chicken and two slices of pepperoni and both were delicious!
I grew up in Manhasset in the 90s, and there was a lot of good pizza around. But I’ll always remember Carlo’s as having the absolute all-time best anywhere in the area. Whenever I come back to town, I definitely try to make it there for a slice or two🍕
I took my grandson to Carlo’s for dinner. I had also taken him to a different pizza place for lunch. He declared Carlo’s slice of cheese pizza to be excellent and superior. He asked me to tell the owner and I did. My grandson also asked me to post a great review. My grandson and I will make Carlo’s our go-to place for pizza. He is a small eater but he ate two slices. I highly recommend Carlo’s pizza.
Possibly the best regular NY Style pizza on Long Island and beyond. The slices are thin, and full of flavor. The crust is crisp, the sauce is excellent, and the cheese is perfect. If I were to rate it in a scale of 1 - 10, I’d give it a 9.3, and I have yet to have better. Definitely my favorite go to spot for a slice or pie. Consistently delicious!
Thought I was going to miss getting my traditiobal carlos slice during my port washington visit and was heartbroken. Decided to pick up a personal pie before my flight and carried it on. Of course I received multiple compliments from hungry strangers but the best one was at 2am at the hotel the airline booked after cancelling a 4 hour delay departure. The front desk in Chicago was shocked I found a pizza at this hour, life hack unlocked: carry on a pie.
Been eating here for almost 40 years and really good pizza. I think they're the longest running pizza joint on main Street which says a lot.
Hands down the best pizza on Long Island and PW. Don’t let the inside fool you, the food here is delicious. Prices are cheap and wait times a short.
All about good pizza.
Many orders paced here, ALL OF THEM were very good.
Hard working people, want you to be happy.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes