Sluurpy
Reset

There are 2 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Carbonara in Punta Gorda

There are 2 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Carmelo's Italian Ristorante
86/100 (7304 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Southern-Italian
Sicilian
Italian
Tuscan
Vegan Options
Central-Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Mediterranean
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Meatballs
Pasta
Lasagne
Salad
Cannoli
Scallops
Clams
Carbonara
Calamari
Osso Buco
Mussels
Saltimbocca
Calamares
Prosciutto
Salmon
Arancini
Bruschette
Pesto
Fish
Shrimp
Pork
Beef
Ossobuco
Alfredo
Tiramisu
Lobster
Eggplant
Sit down
Central-Italian
Southern-Italian
Sicilian
Tuscan
Italian
Takeout
Private Dining
Live Music
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Reservations
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"An absolute jewel in downtown Punta Gorda. Their food is the best Italian, this side of Italy, that I’ve ever had. It is as if walking through..."
Allen May
"Went to dinner tonight with my parents and my sister. Made a reservation and was seated right away! Our server was misty I believe and she was..."
Kerri Treubert
"We celebrated our daughter’s wedding last wkd and Carmelo’s catered our meal. The food was outstanding! Our guests raved how delicious it was! ..."
Carmen Blake
"Searched for Italian restaurant in Punta Gorda & Carmelo’s popped up. Perfect. Service & food was excellent. Atmosphere is wonderful. Calamari was..."
Marlene Tury Hegener Dingman
"This is by far the best Italian food I have ever eaten. The atmosphere is wonderful, the service is excellent and they give amazing recommendations...."
Chelsea O'Shea
"Superb. Had the Zuppa de Pesce. Never seen such huge scallops. Delicious. Would definitely recommend this charming little restaurant. Best to book a..."
Gillian Sole
"I believe this is the best, upscale, restaurant in Punta Gorda. The food is fabulous. The staff and owners are attentive and engaging. Prices are..."
Michael Main
"Absolutely wonderful Italian food. Sitting outside under the stars, a glass of wine, and excellent food. What a great..."
Judith Diane Scolaro
"The restaurant and our waitress Linda scored a perfect ten! This place is a..."
Mark Swanson
"A Big Thank you to Carmelo’s for making my daughters Baby Shower a Success !!! We catered from Carmelo’s they did an Amazing job !!! Everything..."
Barbara Doktor
"This restaurant is one of the best in Punta Gorda. Each dish is made personaly to order by the chef. If you want extra sausage or cheese it is not..."
Donna Allison Jones
"Food and service was great...awesome courtyard! Best chicken marsala I have had in a long time! Hope the new place has a courtyard ..."
Nancy Sorace Ross
"Food is absolutely incredible. Atmosphere is amazing especially outside (they have space heaters). Service could not be better. Ive been here a..."
Brad Boyer
"Thank you Carmelo’s for the delicious food that was served at my husband‘s 80th birthday party. I found your catering service to be very..."
Sonja Rozier
"Are you looking for a restaurant with a great atmosphere? Then, head to Carmelo’s in Punta Gorda, FL. You will feel like you are in Italy. Plus,..."
Lisa Blanchette
"We came for our anniversary, and we were so impressed! Best dinner I’ve ever had, exceptional service, everything was perfect! Compliments to..."
erin guard
"All I can say is wow! Shrimp Alfredo is one of the entrees I probably have had most going out and wow, this really was the best I’ve ever had. Had..."
Matt Rohde
"This was our first time here, and a few friends highly recommended it; The place was nice and looked like a home from the outside; they have an..."
Fig
"What an amazing night! My husband surprised me with dinner to celebrate my 50th birthday. From the moment we arrived to the leaving, the staff, food..."
Janet Ciccone
"Enjoyed an amazing dinner for 2, our server Sutton was very accommodating & knowledgeable. The calamari is a must have appetizer & the wedding soup..."
Levi Schebel
"As soon as you entered the restaurant the smell was intoxicating and the team in reception were friendly and welcoming. We were escorted to our table..."
Arthur Lewis
"Wow....Just wow. This place was worth all the hype I heard. Highly recommend calling for a reservation. Get the Bada Bing, ribeye....just order it..."
D P
Italia At River City
85/100 (1087 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Bolognese
Salad
Lasagne
Scallops
Carbonara
Clams
Calamari
Chicken Parmesan
Risotto
Bruschette
Mussels
Pesto
Calamares
Pork
Salmon
Ragu
Shrimp
Ribs
Beef
Tiramisu
Eggplant
Meatballs
Pasta
Sit down
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Reservations
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Seating
Private Dining
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Every time we visit Florida we stop here for dinner! The food is phenomenal and the service is fantastic! I highly recommend Kristan as a server! She..."
Vanessa Blanda
"Awesome experience server was great (Danielle)food was amazing and the manager Bill was on point will defiantly be..."
Dwon Stellwag Sr
"Absolutely wow... impressed. The Calamari Balsamico was light and truly delicious with the balsamic reduction drizzled as the sauce it was a..."
Gail Giannini Schwebel
"Very enjoyable restaurant and bar. Special compliments go out to our bartender Kenzie. We all loved our meals. The Chicken Parmigiana was the best I..."
Donna Onofri Szymanski
"Dinner here was absolutely amazing! Comfortable atmosphere, great food and some of the best tiramisu..."
Clayton A Frazier
"Went Saturday for the first time to celebrate my birthday, didn't have reservations so sat at the bar. (Were very busy, make reservations) Heard..."
Sandee Packard Stone
"Excellent, the BEST pizza on the west coast of Florida, Doug the owner makes you feel like family , I highly recommend Italia ,..."
David Carlo
"We all had fantastic dinners and the service was excellent. Nice place to go for a nice..."
Sheila St Pierre Hokanson
"2nd time here...love the salad n the food..great atmosphere n wonderful servers...will be..."
Darlene Andrychowski Monestero
"Great place great host. Lots of fun people. Food was great....meet some new people...thanks...Mark and thanks to Doug..."
Debbie Larus Betchner
"The food was superior. I ordered the eggplant parmigiano and hubby ordered the chicken toscano...."
Tina Kaighin
"Wonderful gluten free pizza! I also love the chicken Parmesan and Caesar salad. Excellent bar tenders make Italia a fantastic dining..."
Jeannine Orndorff
"Service and food outstanding I had the short ribs and they were amazing. This was the 18th time there and perfect every..."
Dora Dirrman
"Had a great time and experience. Staff was great food was a really good experience. Looking forward to going back and trying other options on the..."
Dizzy Nos
"Food was good. We got the Lasagna, Carbonata, Burrata, Tiramisu, and espresso. All delicious! That’s a soft atmosphere and looks like Italy..."
Cleber Vasconcelos
"Love this place. The lasagna roll is fabulous. Service is usually pretty good but the last time we went our waitress was not our usual and she was..."
Angela Demma
"Our food was amazing, please don't get rid of your wonderful crunchy bread and your dip. Everything that all four of us had was absolutely delicious..."
Donna Colburn
"My friends got me Eggplant Parmigiana to go. It arrived hot and it’s the absolute best I’ve ever had. Sorry I ate half of it before I thought to..."
Mary Rothrock
"Phenomenal cuisine. Eggplant parmesan was delicious. Quality wine selection. Busy and a bit noisy but it added to the experience. I'll definitely be..."
Wayne Crowley
"The ambiance and food was amazing!! Thank you Phil ( manager) and Erica for the fantastic service and treatment. You guys exceeded my expectations...."
Danielle Jaramillo
"Our dinners were the best Italian that we've had in Punta Gorda. Service was excellent! I had Linguine with clam sauce. Chicken parm and chicken..."
Lisa Santoro
"One of my most favorite italian restaurants in the Fort Myers vicinity. Great atmosphere, great food, great staff. Don’t be afraid of asking for..."
Robert McKay Jones
"Best Italian I have had in a while, cozy setting excellent staff and amazing cook. The food was homemade and it showed. Will definitely be back when..."
Natalie Camareno
"Great food. Menu gives good choices. Spagetti sauce was good. Love the Eggplant..."
Cecilia Festa
"Great location nice people. Great food. Very friendly staff. Salmon salad was fabulous. Linguini with clams awesome! Great..."
Missy N
"Always outstanding food and service. Did I mention the Messy Sunday for dessert! That’s worth the trip in..."
Bob Casale
"We Love Italia! It always has a great atmosphere and amazing food!! If you are visiting Punta Gorda this is a must stop for Italian..."
Dominique Shea
"We held my mother's 90th birthday party at Italia. The service was excellent, food portions were large and very tasty! 😋 Overall, this was a..."
Mary Donovan
"Loved the food and staff was so helpful and pleasant. We will be..."
Anne McCune
"We had a room in the back of the restaurant that was perfect for our family of 9 people. The atmosphere was quiet and the decor made us imagine we..."
Laurie Vesey
"Food and service were both great. We had Christina and she was a great..."
Miranda F
"Food was really good and service was great too. We had the pizza, Caesar salad, and the bolognese. All of them were really good. Definitely worth a..."
Joe Cavanaugh
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use