Every visit has been wonderful, but the New Year's Eve party blew us away! It was incredible! The decorations were great, the atmosphere felt very intimate, and the food was phenomenal. Andy, Angela and the entire staff did a superb job getting food out, and everyone was so happy and friendly. We're hoping it was the start of a long standing island tradition for us. Thanks for an outstanding time!
We found our new favorite place to eat on the island!! Try the shrimp tacos!! The service was also great!! If you are ever on the Island you will know that is rare.
Tonya Christine Good-Heuring
+5
The food was excellent!! We had a table of 6. Everyone was very pleased. Shrimp tacos, perch tacos, mussels, nachos, deep fried pickles... beer was cold😊
There is something about the Reel Burger that makes the trip to Put In Bay worth it! The food is excellent:)
Best burger I’ve had in years. Great waiter, and atmosphere.
Brittany Lougheed Warren
+5
One of my favorite places to hang out on the island. The fish tacos are delicious, the beer selection is great, service is always friendly. The Ray Fogg show is a must see. I hope Travis wins Lake Erie Idol!
Love the place !! Great food and exceptional staff !! Reel Bar is the Reel Deal for PIB entertainment !!
This is a great place with great food & the best service!!!
Shrimp tacos were AMAZING! The best I’ve ever had, 2 wasn’t enough :)
Best bar on the island!!!! Awesome food, friendly staff!!!! Can't wait to go back!!!! 25 Blow Jobs and they didn't blink twice!
Great Place, Great Entertainment, Great Food and an amazing staff.
Great people.food and entertainment.....Highly recommend
We always stop in when we visit PIB. The food and drinks are delicious!
10/10 Best burgers in the island. Personally the best choice is the Fire-In-The-Hole burger but we did try the Sweet Bourbon, Black Bean and the kids Cheeseburger. The staff are friendly and professional with knowledge of the menu. The place is worth a visit again and again. Definitely, I got my money's worth.
Cassandra Mercedes Broadwater
+5
Really great find and drinks! The pickle shot was so fun! The server was really knowledgeable about gluten allergies as well!
Great food great service. Bria was superb wonderful. Anytime I'm in town will come back.
YUM! Definitely stop in to Reel Bar! You won't regret it! We are so glad we stopped and tried it! The nachos were loaded... Delicious! & The burger was great! Don't skip this place up if you get the chance to visit Put in Bay! 🍔☀️
Little over priced, but the service was amazing! The fries were fantastic.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes