Only two NY style Pizza Shops in NC that are top notch! Sergio’s is one of them! From the variations of slices to the Chicken Franchise you cant have a bad meal here! I recommend this spot to everyone! The friendly staff with a New York edge will have you coming back for seconds...
YESSSSS our first time trying Sergio's so we ordered the "Super Special" and was able to sample their pizza, meatball sub, baked ziti and garlic knots --- we decided we won't go anywhere else ever for pizza in the area!! it was absolutely delicious!! authentic NY style... meatballs on point!! Thank you for not disappointing!! :)
Sommer Tankersley Hickman
+5
Seriously the best pizza! Very friendly staff and management. Would highly recommend!
Not only the best pizza around but the manager went out of his way to help my family last night and gave us a free pizza!!! You guys rock and have always had our business �
I grew up on this type of pizza in upstate NY, and am so glad to have an authentic place to keep up the tradition. This is the only place I buy pizza from,
Best authentic NY Style Pizza in Raleigh. It's the only place I buy pizza.
This is the real NY pizza deal. Great service. Takes me back to great NY memories.
Nj native. This is the first place I ordered pizza from, absolutely the best hands down! Amazing
We love Sergios. Can't go wrong with a ham & pineapple or try their Grandma pizza. It's amazing! Never had a bad pie here. Quick delivery as well.
Good God, just go. Go and enjoy and bask in the mom and pop feel of a perfectly seasoned sauce, good cheese, excellent crust. I am stuffing myself stupid and already planning what to get next time. It is just SO good!
Awesome New York style pizza. If you are looking for a quick pizza fix, then this is definitely the place to visit. The service is quick by the slice and the prices are reasonable. I ordered the grandma slice and pepperoni mushroom. Both were delicious but I think I was partial to the grandma slice with its unique name and the sauce on top. The grandma slice is basically a margherita without tomato and the sauce is on top. I am very satisfied and will return next time I’m in the area.
Amazing pizza. Extremely light and fresh.
Only downside is the price and the wait time. Just a cheese pie would cost you 18$. I placed my order 30 min ahead of time and still had to wait 30 more min at the store.
But overall it’s kinda worth it to get an authentic NY style pizza in Raleigh
My family and I went to eat here for the first time during lunch, and the food was excellent! We got the "Game Day Special ", which included 1 Lg pizza, 12 wings, and 1L of soda. I requested the wings to be made extra crispy with half mild and half Asian. They made the wings crispy to our liking (which many wing places struggle to do!) The manager even allowed us to exchange the liter of soda for garlic knots, which were amazing! We ate their and enjoyed our time. The service and food were great! I highly recommend coming here for pizza and wings. We will have to try the calzones next time.
EXCELLENT FOOD! They catered an event at our school last night and the food was amazing! I love Italian already though! Pasta, fettuccine, caesar salad, and garlic buns. SO delicious! 😁👍👍
I pick the wrong time to get pizza from this establishment. I will have to come back again during the day and not right before they close. I had the Buffalo Chicken Pizza which was a bit stale, but the flavor is good and the dough is cooked nicely. The service was good, but I will need to come back to try them when the food is fresh. Overall it's a great pizza joint near my place. I will be coming back!
Dollar for dollar this could be the best NY-style pizza in Raleigh. Went here on a whim because Gino's was closed. We got the two large pizzas for $19.95
deal. My expectations were low based on the strip mall surroundings and the Chuck Mangione easy listening music on the phone. Notwithstanding... Wow! This place is legit! And it is as good as anything from NY/NJ area. Mamma Mia! Sergio makes a nice a pizza! Exquisite! 5 stars!!! There is a reason why it has stayed in business since the days of disco!!!
Best NY pizza in town. Better than most places I’ve been in Manhattan as a matter of fact. Best pizza by the slice selection. Their sauce is out of this world. Chicken parmesan and meat lovers are my favorite so far.
Moved to NC from NJ and have spent 3 years looking for acceptable pizza and finally found it at Sergio's. Crisp, great cheese/sauce ratio. Highly recommended.
I'm from NJ and have to say this is some of the best pizza I've had since moving down to NC last year. To be fair, I've only tried a handful of pizzerias (actual pizza joints; I wouldn't order from anywhere like Dominoes or Papa John's unless extremely desperate or intoxicated), but man this place hit the spot!
Some of the best pizza I have ever had. The garlic knot slice was a cool twist on a classic and the sicilian was perfect!
Outstanding pizza with a friendly staff! I know people like to argue that nowhere in the south has pizza as good as the NYC, NJ, and CT area, because of the water or something, but this is one of the best spots in the area for a slice that's comparable. They have a wide array of individual slices and pies. Highly recommended!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes