The Chicago deep dish is very good. Try to get one whenever I'm in town. Asked for a pilsner style beer and the dining room server looked at my beer menu to see if there was one available (he had no idea). In his defense, he talked to the beertender and returned with 3 different samples for free...one of which pleasantly filled my request.
The bottom line...sit in the bar, enjoy a great beer selection and their awesome pizza! P.S. - All of their food is great, too!
Finn & Filo Downunder
+4.5
THE pan pizza!. Dont eat anything before you'll have a dinner :) Pizza is so good... buffalo wings pizza was just superb. I ordered a medium pizza (6 slices) and was able to eat 3 ! :) Small is 4 and large is 8!
Nice ambience with brick walls etc.. excellent service.
Gluten Free Pizza. Good gluten free pizza. Not much else on the menu GF.
The server brought out a salad with croutons, after I ordered without. Her response " Can't you take them off?" No you moron, I can't. I have Celiacs disease.
Service is usually very slow. We waited an hour for our pizza the last time we ate in the restaurant. They do have a game area for the kids if you have tons of quarters to waste.
Best bet: Do the take out service, you'll get you pizza sooner.
BJ's Cousin. If you like BJ Pizza, you will like Selma's.
Great pizza and friendly service.
Much better food then their neighbor phillys best.
Great pizza. Ask for kristin, great server!
Selma's has been around since 2003, and one of its founders, Mike Phillips Jr., is the son of one of the creators of BJ's, Mike Phillips Sr. This place definitely has a BJ's feel to it.
First time here. I saw the sign off Santa Margarita for years. Just never stopped here.
I had a few free moments in the area so I decided to give it a try. I love pizza.
The place was pretty quite as it was after lunch. Staff was super attentive.
I ordered a Da'Vinny personal lunch special. Deep dish Pizza and a salad. The salad was quite generous and delicious. The blue cheese was nice and strong if you know what I mean.
The crust of the pizza was perfect. Crispy. But not too hard. The pepperoni, Italian sausage, and marinara sauce were a perfect balance.
Definitely will come back. And recommended
$4 beer, $4 soup and a $14 Calzone with 2 toppings. I really liked the Honey Blonde House Brew and the soup was very good - with the exception that it should be served with some type of bread. The bar tender asked me right away if I wanted a dinner roll and after the first was done I asked for another which was not an issue. Overall the place has a great atmosphere, low playing current and past rock music from various time periods. The tables are clean, the people are friendly, the waiters, servers and hosts are on point and I will be back. Unless my Calzone fails, they earned 4 stars. They lost 1 point because I was asked to wait for the manager to place my order at the restaurant and they never came. When I walked over to the bar, they gave me service right away.
Had a minor issue with a take out order that was mostly (all) my fault. The manager made it right without question, one doesn't find service like that in many places. Thank you!
The Chicago style pizza was excellent, just what I was looking for and tasted great!
Fantastic selection of delicious pizzas, pastas, salads, sandwiches and wings! I’ve never been disappointed by the food or large selection of rotating craft beers. It’s been a favorite spot of mine for years!
Been coming to Selmas for a very long time now( i still miss the boneless wings from the mid 2000s) and this place never disappoints! Best O Pesto pasta is so good and the Pedal to the Medal pizza is delicious!
Very chill low key spot. Was not over loaded or crowded even at 1p...decent selection of beer on tap, good tasting food, chill crew
Delicious Chicago-style deep dish pizza and a huge selection of craft beers on tap. Always a family favorite dinner spot.
Phoned in an order for a Chicago-style pizza, fried raviolis, potato wedges, and garlic bread, and even after arriving and paying I still had to wait an hour for my food to be ready. Everything was delicious, but because of the wait I knocked them down a star. I would love to knock more off than that, but their food was actually really good.
Best pizza I’ve ever had. Hands down . That Chicago Pizza Pie was insane! Highly recommended to any pizza lovers
This place is awesome. Tried their pizza on a whim and it did not disappoint. Staff is very friendly too, They went out of their way to make me a cherry coke, even though they didnt have it. :D
Great customer service , this is coming from someone that holds customer service to a high standards, food was also great tried some custom wings (traditional- medium - lemon pepper ) that were amazing, and 2 pan pizzas well done man 👏
I appreciate you guys and gals.
Great selection of pizza, pasta, and salad. We had great service from our waitress, Whitney, and our order came out extremely quickly.
Service was awesome, and the food was out of this world delicious. The restaurant is delightful. The dining area and restrooms were clean and well stocked, and I love that the kitchen is clean and tidy, We had the lunch special today, 1/2 sandwich, seasoned fries, and soup. Everything was delightful.
Went there for lunch with some coworkers food was pretty good but the Chicago pizza was not Chicagoing(im from the midwest)...it was missing alot of cheese but my panini was on point along with the service...I won't return only because I don't live out that way and it's a million other restaurants I need to try before I leave the earth....
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes