I am a local and I can not recommend this place enough. The waitresses are amazing and kind, and nice to everyone! I was recently looking after a severely handicapped young woman for a week, and the staff was amazing with her and I. I felt comfortable and well taken care of. They made us both feel comfortable. I highly recommend this place!
We had lunch at Nicola Pizza while enjoying the Special Olympics POLAR Plunge weekend. We all ordered something different, they have a great selection on their menu and the food had great flavor...it was Awesome! Their staff is very friendly and attentive too!!
We have been going to Nicola’s since 1999. The service is excellent and fast. The food is consistently delicious and fresh. We especially like the winter specials three days a week - half priced pasta on Tuesday, pizza on Wednesday and Nicoboli’s on Thursday. Fun atmosphere and family owned and operated. Very friendly owners and staff go above and beyond to make sure you’re satisfied.
Have been doing the Nicola Pizza thing since I was a child... Nic-o-Bolis are my favorite food!!! And it must be an original! I have found that I don't like to mess with perfection!!! The waitresses and waiters are very good and service is very good! You cannot go wrong with anything here!!!
We drive 500 miles to come and visit family every year and Nicola Pizza is always a priority.
This place is incredible! Great food and great people!
We had a blast here. The food was great and so was the service. We ordered mozzarella sticks, salad, plain cheese pizza, and white pizza. All delicious. The salad was really fresh and an excellent sized portion for 3 of us to share. The ambiance made it a great night.
Visited Rehoboth and noticed people kept coming in this pizzeria. We gave it a try and we were definitely happy that we did. Loved their famous Nic-o-Boli. So good! Service was awesome too!
Wonderful staff and service. Great location! Conveniently located downtown. Always consistent with awesome food. Favorite is the white pizza with bacon and tomato
Nicola's always has great food every time. I got bacon Mac and cheese, amazing. I will say the wait for takeout is a little long, but the food and costumer service makes up for it.
Great spot great food awesome staff, love the look and feel of the place. Sad there moving to the highway not sure when.
We've been going to Nicolas for over 25 years. Their signature dish is the Nic-o-boli, and I have never gotten anything else there. My kids love their pizza. They currently have two locations in Rehoboth Beach, but this is changing as they're moving north to Lewes Beach in the near future. I can't wait to see the new location! This is a family run business, and the staff are very friendly, but extremely busy. Your waiter/waitress is not dedicated to your table, so any staff walking by can assist you. That makes it hard to tip based on service of one person, but we have never had trouble with our orders. If you're in the Rehoboth Beach area, definitely make this one of the places you eat. You won't be disappointed!
Awesome cheese sauce with fresh fries, perfect start lunch. Regular size pizza with the white sauce, spinach, sausage, onions, and fresh tomatoes.
It was really nice when the owner came through and said hi to every table and bar member.
Best pizza in Rehoboth Beach! They have gluten free and low carb options. No matter what you get you will enjoy it. Sadly, at the end of the season, they are moving to Lewes, DE. When we come for vacation next year, we will drive to Lewes for their pizza. Thanks for the memories Nicola!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes