We began coming here about a year ago after many endorsements from the fine folks at Suffolk Theater. Since then we manage to come 2- 3 times per month. All we can say is "terrific", from the service, the ambiance, and of course the terrific food and the reasonable prices. My wife and I come in from Holtsville as to us, this is one of the best hidden gems in Suffolk County. The portion sizes are more than generous, the quality of the food is terrific, and that staff is always so warm and welcoming no matter how busy they are, each and everyone ensures that the dining experience is spot-on. Keep up the fine work.
Best pizza we’ve had in a long time. Delicious sauce, perfect amount of cheese! Highly recommend 👍🏻
![4]( "Recensione")
Great pizza and great dinner. Started dinner with just a plain cheese pie. Very impressed with the quality of the pizza. Not too oily. Fresh tasting a sauce and perfect snappiness and crunch to the pie.
Wait staff was very accommodating for a party of 8 and 2 strollers. Service was excellent
Ordered spaghetti and meatballs which came with a small Italian salad. The salad was nice and fresh and colorful. Peroni beer was an excellent choice to pair with the pizza.
Meatballs were good albeit not fresh tasting. Spaghetti was decent but certainly not freshly homemade.
Also ordered a large grilled chicken salad. Very tasty. Just bigger version of the small Italian.
Ordered a chicken parmigiana hero. Very good. Crispy bread. Perfect amount of sauce and generous portion of chicken.
The French fries. Yes the French fries were amazing! Get them. I know Italian place but try it. Perfectly fresh and super crispy.
Would certainly come back again. Great go to for reasonably priced food in the center of riverhead
Pizza was great! Honestly better than a lot of places in Manhattan.
Lobster ravioli was delicious.
Nice restaurant to dine in or for take out.
The Best Italian food in town! I love it 😍 also great delivery guys , very professional service all together, Thank You , Jill Seus
Everything we had here was absolutely wonderful. Even the croutons on the salad. The service was great and the staff was kind and helpful!
We are from Texas and wish there was a place like this back home! Highly recommend them!
This is my 3rd time eating at Cucina 25. I thought that I left a review but I didn't, so here it is.
Sean the owner at Cucina 25 is busy behind the counter working the pizza ovens. He always greets you with a big hello. Today we sat ourselves and ordered a half pepperoni pie.
The pizza was huge and loaded up with pepperoni, served nice and hot! The sauce was delicious, not spicy and the cheese nice and gooey!
My other visits, I ordered take out dinner. Veal Parmigiano with pasta and an eggplant parm. Both dinner were generous portions and delicious. We also got a dozen garlic knots, yummy.
We have yet to hit a so so dinner here. Their food is amazing, stop in and say hi to Sean!
Home style cooking, attentive service, and reasonable prices (the pasta nights on Monday & Tuesday are unbeatable) all make this a very pleasant dining experience. It’s definitely a local treasure.
No one here on a Tuesday evening. Service was spot on and the food was really good. Two in our group got the pasta special. We all had portions that were enough to have as lunch the next day.
Great looking place , really Italian . Very special and delicious food .
Soup Tortellini en Brodo is very good
Carbonara with Alfredo Sauce was super .
Spaghetti Meat Balls - great
One of the Best places in Riverhead , highly recommend !
I have been coming here for a long, long time. I always order the salad and it is so fresh. I have always ordered the pizza and just recently have ordered thin crust pizza OMG the best!!!!
This place doesn't skip a beat! They are always on point. They have an extensive selection of options in all of their categories. My personal favorite is their Greek Salad pizza which is a work of art and tastes so amazing! They very finely chop all of the ingredients which just makes the experience absolute perfection. I'm picky about how I like my salad and after tasting theirs I realized they are too! (Takes one to know one) No direction needed, they share in the same obsession of chopping the ingredients properly. The salty feta cheese is complemented by the sweet tomatoes and savory crust.. omg ! Just delightful... Very friendly service and fastest delivery in town. They always deliver way before the projected time which is such a nice surprise. Food is always hot and delicious. The owners care about their business and it shows in their work. I wish them continued success.
We have been coming here since they opened their doors. Whether we eat in or take out we have never been disappointed! Food is excellent and service is always friendly! Nothing else compares!
What is this magical pasta?? Usually I’m a hater who says, “Why would I pay $20+ for pasta that I can make at home?!” Most places let me down no matter how *homemade* it is. BUT THIS PLACE. They absolutely blew my mind and made me a believer 🤯
We ordered the Penne Florentine without chicken with garlic knots 😍
We went there with another couple before we went to see a show. The waitress was overwhelmed because she had a lot of tables to serve. The atmosphere was fine the food was very good just the right size portions. We would definitely go back because it is in close proximity to the Suffolk theater.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes