Such a great spot. The Winton/Atlantic location is so nice after the remodel too. Besides the pizza (which is awesome and one of the must-try's in Rochester) the other food is great too. A great spot to grab lunch in the North Winton Village too, never too busy to get in and out. A great atmosphere. Love it.
Kathy Criscuolo Amberge
+5
Grew up on this pizza, best in Rochester!
bay goodman pizza has been around forever it seem's when growing up pa would stop and get one or two on the way home.when I got older went there the quality has always been great hey every now and then your taste buds are off and you blame the pizza not from here it's you. get the pizza BAY GOODMAN
Jaime Stewart Melendez
+5
Amber .s. makes the best wings and subs very good service when I have been there
Best pizza in town and they have a great staff. ( Winton Rd.)
Candice Ross Schneggenburger
+5
Best pizza in Rochester! I had a great experience and the service was fast and friendly!
Top 5 pizza places in Rochester, great pizza they load on the toppings, great subs too I like the buffalo chicken sub with a grilled roll, great people fast service
The best pizza in Rochester. I love this place!
Great Local Pizza. Not quite NYC style but damn good. The pepperoni is awesome.
I was pleasantly surprised when the meal was served at my table. It's the first time I come here to try this plate. I found it so pretty that I took a picture of it! It was as delicious as it looked! I'm going to tell my oldest son about it, and bring my husband! The service was great!
They are THE BEST. They treat customers like family. Every employee here is super kind. The food is delicious and the prices are super fair. I can always trust in the Bay & Goodman Pizza team to deliver promptly and treat me with utter respect. Other places (that shall not be named… but rhyme with Terrys Tizza and Hinos Pizza) will either refuse to deliver to me or come up with an excuse to not deliver to me. Since covid hit some places are being weird. But never Bay & Goodman. They’ve always had my back when it comes to my favorite food: Pizza!
Got two slices of pizza.The guy serving it was pleasent and handsome.very professional and polite. The music was great in the background. The pizza slices were as big as the paper plates with nice Ozzy delicious cheese. Filled me up quick. I will be comming back with friends 😁
Awesome wings. Always freindly staff and food done on time. Order from them often. Garbage plate blew me away, must have weighed 4 pounds. Still ate it in one sitting because it was so good.
This place is AWESOME! Staff is always friendly and efficient. Good is freaking BOMB! And let's be real. $6.48 for two (Huge, like Rochester Huge) pizza slices and a drink so the best deal in the whole world! Thank you for existing!
Had a sausage and pep sheet pizza with buffalo mild wings. The pizza and wings smelled so good I could hardly wait to make it home. Lol. They tasted even better. Next time I'll try a supreme pizza.
The food is pretty damn good! Although, I've never actually tried their pizza. I feel compelled to mention how good their proprietary oil dressing is. Very flavorful! It may seem like a silly thing to mention, but it's the best oil dressing I've ever had on a sub. Now for some slight negatives... when taking orders over the phone, some of their employees really struggle to take your order and often complain about having computer problems. And unfortunately, my order has been wrong numerous times when I got it home(like missing bacon from a burger or wrong/missing toppings on a sub, for example) But this doesn't stop me from coming back regularly, and it doesn't stop me from recommending this place to you!
I go to Bay Goodman Pizza for lunch at least 3 days a week. The staff is always friendly and the food is always great. I get a slice of veggie white pizza, a slice of pepperoni and sausage and a drink for a little over 8 bucks.
The food here has always been great, the service is always on point, and the staff is always friendly. If your craving some pizza thats not your whole life savings for a medium pie, than this is your place. Seriously if you haven't checked them then what are you waiting for, ya missing out!
![5]( "Recensione")
Bay Goodman is hands down the best pizza place in Rochester. The quality of the ingredients is definitely at the top--the crust is soft and the sauce is delicious and flavorful. In addition to having mouthwatering pizza, Bay Goodman also has tasty wraps, paninis, subs, garlic knots, etc. I also love the wings and the various sauces they offer--I recommend getting the hot sauce and the garlic parmesan sauce, as I like to mix the two flavors together...Delicious!
The Winton Rd Bay Goodman was recently renovated and looks incredible, especially the dining area, with high top seating and several tables to sit down at. The cafe-like style of the dining area really gives the store a great ambiance, and makes it the perfect spot to grab lunch on my work breaks.
I'd also like to add that the service is great every time I've been to the store. I have never gotten a delivery, but I would expect that it would be a good experience judging by the excellent in-store service.
In conclusion, Bay Goodman is an exceptional pizza restaurant, and I would highly recommend it to anyone, even the non-pizzalovers! I would give it more than five stars if I could. Keep up the good work!
2 points for the little char Pepperoni's though the pizza was a bit light on cheese. Was cooked well and sauce was pretty good but could use more garlic. Wings came with sauce on side not much heat for medium but it was tasty.
Bay and goodman is one of the best pizzas in town. Delicious crust, not too dry or flour-ey. The give a lot of toppings. We recently branched out and got the boneless wings which were equally delicious. You might think it's easy to make good wings but I can assure you, as a wing aficionado, not a lot of places do it right.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes