Sluurpy > Restaurants in Rockaway > Gencarelli Restaurant & Pizza

Gencarelli Restaurant & Pizza - Rockaway - Photo album

Just had the BEST food & service at Pizza Rustica in Rockaway Boro. Soup, salad & entrees all fresh, well prepared, generous portions, beautiful prepared by chef Carlos. Don’t let the casual pizzeria atmosphere fool you. Delicious and very reasonably priced. Italian egg drop soup; served steaming ho

I have major problems with pizza. I could eat it for every meal. Like for real. This place has the BEST Grandmas pie around. In addition their staff is excellent. I’m glad I have some Will power or I would eat it every single day and end up to be well over 400 lbs.

Stopped in for a couple slices while at work. Ordered a slice of roasted red pepper w garlic, balsamic glaze and olive oil... Maybe chicken too... Not sure don't judge me... The crust was excellent 👌 crispy flavorful and with great texture... That slice might be one of the best specialty slices I've

2020-New owners were really friendly and were more than willing to listen to feedback. Ordered a plain slice to provide a rating for the Pizza Hunters App and surprise, surprise they delivered a very good slice of pizza. I was informed that they have been working on their crust which was very good.

My absolute favorite pizza!!!! What makes it even better is the service, the professionalism, the cleanliness and their consistency!!!! Always a must when I get my nails done next door! It’s worth the 30 min drive every two weeks!

Update 12/14/23: I absolutely love this place. I came in for something that's not on the menu. Sort of a go to when the slice I love is not available. The guy who told me about it wasn't there but they called him and he came in earlier. Tell me that isn't superb customer service. If you've never b

Rustica Special Pie is awesome! This pie is loaded with such fresh and delicious toppings, yet when you pick up the slice, it holds strong without anything falling off! The staff is friendly and helpful from the phone call through the pickup process. I also found the prices reasonable for the amoun

I've been here 3 times and each time I was pleasantly surprised. It doesn't look like much from outside, but the pizza dough has some extra seasonings that give it a really nice flavor. Even the best pizza places anywhere else in Morris County has crust from time to time that tastes like old cracker

The waitress was sooo sweet and attentive! AAAND the food was DELICIOUS!!!

Our cub scout pack had a luncheon catered by Pizza Rustica. The food was great and the owner, staff and delivery person went above and beyond to accommodate us. Very friendly too. Thank you!!

We had a veal and a chicken dish. Both were outstanding. The seating area is very nice, casual and welcoming. Jake was our server who was attentive and courteous. When we were leaving every staff member thanked us for coming. We will be back to try the pizza next!