Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Rye

7 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Sunrise Pizzeria
Sunrise Pizzeria
92/100 (454 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"I ordered the arugula salad pizza, chicken cutlet with lettuce tomato wedge and grandpa pizza. What a knockout! The food was fabulous. The young lady..."
Ro Ma
"Delicious pizza - loved the quality of the specials. Busy neighborhood spot with a bunch of..."
Eric Jin Cheng
"Consistently good pizza. Nice grandma, and variety of different pizza toppings to accommodate your taste. Love the mushroom, chicken, bacon, ranch,..."
sarah scampoli
"They always have great pizza, I am never disappointed...."
Thomas Roberts-Realtor
"My family lived in Rye since my ancestors moved here from other countries. They have been an icon in the town and their food tells it all. We..."
Debbie Smith
"Been going here since Middle/High School back in the 90’s. Always great service, the pies haven’t changed whatsoever in all that time. By far,..."
Marcello Scolari
"Wow.The Best Meatball Parmigiana I had so far.The Meatballs and cheese combo where Delicious.I can't wait to try other..."
Kenneth Blanco
"Everything was good just not my favorite compared to a couple of other. I'm a Sicilian pizza fan. Their version isn't really doughy or chewy but..."
Peter goldey
"Pizza is very good, I love the Pasta Fagioli. Better than my..."
Eugene Cabornero
"There is a lot of passion in everything they make. They enjoy, you enjoying your food as much as you're gonna love it...."
Jimi Ital Network Music Co.
"Had a really excellent experience ordering and picking up my pizzas. The owner, Alex, was very kind and helpful. The pizza is excellent and we will..."
Morgan Barron
"If your in the mood for great ITALIAN food in Rye, don’t drive by. Park your car and and enjoy a great meal at..."
ASAP LINEN
"First time here. Had the penne with probably the best tasting sausage I've had in a..."
kevin mccourt
"Chicken Marsala pizza is amazing! Some of the Staff isn’t always the..."
Robert Porto
Aldente Pizzeria
Aldente Pizzeria
89/100 (1661 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Penne Pasta
Cheese Calzone
Calamari Marinara
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
Italian Combo
Cold Antipasto
Grilled Salmon with Sauteed Spinach
Pizza
Tortellini with Spinach Grilled Chicken and Sun-Dried Tomatoes in a Light Tomato Sauce
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
"Got penne alla vodka with grilled chicken breast to go-- it was well packaged and tasty. It's a bit low-sodium (if that's your preference) but pasta..."
Joyce Elizabeth
"Excellent pizza!!!!! Toppings to die for and they are not stingy on their Toppings or slice size, be warned they are a bit pricey..."
Maddie
"You want to check out their food. They know what they are doing and add their touch to the dishes. 5 stars and a to-go..."
Melanie Richards
"Simply my favorite pizzeria, parmigiana is amazing the staff is spot on... If I was portnoy would rate 8.9 monster..."
Tom Vlahos
"Love the food. The best pizza around hands down. Really fresh and well made. The service is always top notch…can’t go wrong with Al..."
Heather Sydney
"Nice crispy crust and little on the thick side, which is good. Had a slice of the bbq..."
Anthony Lalli
"Pizza was really good.Service was fast staff was..."
E
"A great spot for some delicious Italian food! The staff was friendly as well and our food came out great. 4 stars though because of the pricing..."
Paul G
"Employees were great! Food was..."
ron morey
"This small cozy pizza polar is filled with excellence. Their pizza is made with perfection, and served with warmth and kindness. Truly a hidden..."
Jus_a1 000
"Friendly staff. Great..."
Jim Gordon
"Really good pizza. Teriyaki one is our family favorite!! And customer service is simply awesome. There was an issue with our delivery (one of the..."
Julio dJV
"Really good pizza , very big portion..."
Briana Santomauro-Housman
"Great food. Amazing..."
Helen Calero
"This is one of the if not best pizzerias in westchester. The salads, pizza, pasta and wings are great. The food is always well seasoned and hot. The..."
Shanique Shackleford
"Great food!!! By far my family's favorite vodka sauce (try the vodka margherita slice when they have it)!! Excellent pizza, salad, sandwiches, really..."
Pamela Villeneuve
Belluscio's
Belluscio's
85/100 (299 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Food was amazing. Oh so sooo good. The chef suggested several food plates. I told him to surprise me. He made me this plate that if i remember..."
Sandro Huizar
"Delicious...really Delicious Food and excellent service in Beautiful Rye New..."
Dolce Nina
"What a wonderful family restaurant that dates back 50 years. Home-cooked delicious food, amazing personable service, and great location. Highly..."
Melisa Vlasaty
"I've been coming to this family establishment for 20 years now, with a good friend from here, never had a bad meal. The staff is super friendly, and..."
Gene Casciari
"Classic, fresh, felt like Grandma's Italian dinner . Delightful, delicious, friendly staff. Owner Frank treats customers as family. Chef George makes..."
Raven
"I love this place. Went with my bf who has been going there for 50+ years. The staff, Nancy, Frank are so welcoming. Food is amazing, I had the..."
Mala Rosner
"This past Friday my family & I wanted to reaquaint ourselves, hadn't been to Bellucios in many years. Was pleasantly surprised at how different the..."
Sandra Pears
"Family-run Italian restaurant. Great, authentic food. Wonderful staff. Local gathering place for more than 60 years. Very real sense of the..."
m beary
"My husband and I love this local, family friendly, restaurant. The owner and his crew are all so friendly and willing to please. It’s one of the..."
Jane Valentine
"Delicious food, superb prices. Feels like..."
Charlenne Adao
Aurora
Aurora
84/100 (500 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Eggplant Parmesan
Sea Scallops
White wine
Eggplant
Pasta
Burrata Cheese
Tiramisú
Salad
Tarte Tatin
Calamari
Pappardelle Alla Bolognese
Salmon
Fried Calamari Appetizer
P E I Mussels
Spicy Lobster Spaghetti
Linguine Fini
Linguine with White Clam Sauce
Halibut
HOB Nob Pinot Noir
Brussel Sprout Appetizer
Entree Salad with Branzino
Pesto
Fish
Pisco Sour
Beef
Potato Gnocchi
cheese pizza
Pistachio Gelato
Doughnuts
Sit down
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I had a birthday dinner here with my family and I had such a blast. All the food was super delicious, my favorite is the Spicy Lobster Spaghetti. The..."
Tara Andujar
"recently dined here for a birthday celebration and could not be happier with the decision. the food was delicious, ambiance great sitting outdoors..."
Arthur Chin
"V good. Overall is nice. I order the saggy beef ravioli. In my opinion, the beef was grounded too thin. The bread can be served more..."
KusionLion
"Fantastic food and service. Had the cacio e peppe special and out table split four appetizers which were all fabulous. The service was..."
Dawn Henderson
"If I could give this place 10 stars, I would. The location is perfect, the service is incredible, yoi can feel everyone's smile through the mask. The..."
Roseanne Carlo
"On a Saturday night we were able to walk up and get a table on the street which was nice to be honest. Wife ordered zoodles with eggplant (non-meat)..."
Dean Pomeroy
"Beef carpaccio was really good! But personally I didn’t like the celery sauce that accompanied the scallops; it detracts from its flavors in my..."
Kevin Kong
"Very nice restaurant, very friendly and excellent cuisine! Will definitely come back if we go by..."
Marie van caillie
"Ordered take out from Aurora tonight based on the wonderful welcome and food/drinks they gave us for Taste of Rye on Saturday, really appreciate them..."
L Thomas
"My friend and I went for dinner on a week evening. The restaurant was a little bit pricey and the food was ok. We felt like they were rushing us to..."
Havi Pesso
Anna Maria Wine Bar
83/100 (24 ratings)
Restaurants
Wine Bar
Italian
Wine Bar
Italian
Dinner
Italian
Wine Bar
Dinner
Mid-range
The Office Lounge
The Office Lounge
80/100 (228 ratings)
Dessert
Asian
Italian
Korean
Asian
Italian
Korean
Korean
Italian
Asian
Rafele
Rafele
79/100 (555 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Cheesecake
Cheesecakes
Pesto
Pasta
Salad
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Delicious food and great service. All Plating was photo..."
Infoodwetrustny Anthony M
"We had a fantastic time at Rafele tonight. The food is absolutely delicious. The staff is warm and welcoming. The interior is hip and fun and the..."
Andrea Braunstein
"Michelin sticker out front. 2022 as well. Enough said, but……Great lunch in town visiting with my sister, brother in law, niece, and nephew pre..."
Erny Bonistall
"First time here…loved it! Our server she was amazing and very friendly….spoke about being from Bologna originally…excellent service - started w..."
Lynn Carbino
"First time in Rye. First time trying Rafele. Very cute decor of the restaurant. The service was fantastic. The food was delicious. I had a..."
Un Lee
"Unfortunately, nowadays it is a rare thing to go out and everything is perfect within a restaurant, from my experience something is always wrong or..."
Enrique Vargas
"I am only sorry that I didn't take more pictures. Part of it had to do with the fact that everything was so tasty and it barely lasted longer than a..."
Gina Lepore
"Very busy, good food but we chose a fish special which was not to or liking. Everything else was very good though. Bit of a local bar scene. ..."
Steven Roe
"Loved this Italian restaurant. I completely recommend. Had an amazing date, people were great, service amazing. The food and the ambiance was super..."
Christopher
"Would totally go back to try more things on the menu, but the service was very slow on a Sunday night. Seems understaffed? We waited so long to get..."
Roslyn Wertheimer
"I went Friday night with my husband and it was amazing! The food is delicious, the atmosphere is wonderful and the service is spectacular! I can't..."
Allison Karlson
"Fabulous, creative Italian. Terrific pasta, and an indescribable Italian cheesecake. Really..."
Bill Schule