fantastic bagels, and their egg sandwiches are among the best. the place is expensive for a bagel store though.
Excellent homemade bagels, really good, decent sized egg sandwiches, and some healthy bagel varieties, such as the pumpernickel everything and the spinach everything, which are not found elsewhere in the area. They also offer tofu spreads as an alternative to cream cheese. Easily one the best bagel spots on the East End.
My favorite place to get a bagel! They also have great wraps and sandwiches if it's later in the day and you need lunch. There is very little seating inside, but if you walk across the street to Marine Park you can find benches or a picnic table (if you have a blanket make it a picnic). Staff is always friendly!!
The omelet was great. Very busy place so you know it's good. I didn't have a bagel because I can't have wheat but they looked delicious. Only a few places to sit. It's mostly take out.
This place is pretty nice, the workplace looks clean enough and the staff is friendly. I was pretty happy with my meal that I ordered, my only complaint is with the chicken cutlet I had. The chicken tasted and felt like it was already a day or two old and not fresh. Other than that everything was good.
The Bagel Buoy is a traditional bagel shop offering freshly made bagels and prepared foods and sandwiches every day. Try the fresh squeezed orange juice and a breakfast sandwich for a quick meal on the run. The shop can get incredibly crowded on summer mornings...a true sign of a tasty product!
Melissa Ann Mitchell, PhD
+5
Love the bagels at the Bagel Buoy. We love being able to order on the phone in advance, so that we don't have such a long wait time in the store. Thank you for setting up the mobile ordering system!
I love Bagel Bouy. The food and variety are great, the service is fast, of course depending on foot traffic, but they are very convenient with how early and late they're open, and the people that work there, especially the owner, are very nice! However, as convenient as their new "text in your order" thing is, I have never had them get my order right. I always order a heated up (not toasted) plain bagel w/ veggie cream cheese and maybe a half order of their cole slaw (their's is the only cole slaw I like, anywhere), but either they don't get the cole slaw, or they either don't heat up at all or toast my bagel... So it's kind of a bummer that their texting service is so convenient for us working people, but so unpredictable as to how they'll get your order wrong that day, but hope they'll get it right! Also, a tad pricey for a quick pick-up breakfast, but you pay for convenience I suppose.
This is THE spot to go for bagels in the Hamptons. Be prepared to wait a bit but well worth it. They serve bagels any way you want them and are always helpful.
A favorite in my family across generations! Amazing breakfast sandwiches (the bacon, egg, and cheese is my go-to) and bagels. The bread here just can't be beat.
Delicious Breakfast options. Very little wait time here in the off season, will be longer in the summer cause higher volume of people but still a great place to grab some morning grub
The smell of fresh baked bagels always draws a crowd. The lines in the summer are well worth the wait...everything's fresh and right out of the oven.
Rick “RickyMoe” Moessner
+5
One of the best,"chewy" bagels that I have had! Bonus! Was sitting at front window and Christie Brinkley walked by on an errand next door.(still as beautiful as ever)
Fantastic breakfast sandwiches. Can't speak to other things, because I have only tried the breakfast sandwiches, but I hear great things and everything else looks great!
Highly recommended for bagels and breakfast sandwiches. I love their different variations of everything bagels - egg everything, spinach everything, and pumpernickel everything.
Best Bagels! Always fresh. Light and airy with crisp chewy crust!
Good, inexpensive, loved my spinach everything bagel, but super crowded
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes