![5]( "Recensione")
We were in Sag Harbor on a moderately cold March afternoon and walked by this place which was yet to open at around 3 pm. After getting a drink from a near by bar, we showed up again at 3:45 and their team was kind enough to get seating in a wonderfully setup outdoor area.
They noticed we were all cold, and so was our 2 year old, and their super helpful and friendly staff put 4 outdoor heaters in 4 corners for us so we could enjoy our time here. And what a fabulous experience we had. Their entire team is absolutely amazing and they mixed some powerful and tasty cocktails for our group.
We had just come back from lunch, so weren't that hungry, but everytime we passed the kitchen the aroma from food was just making us a but hungry which made us order their Risotto ($35) and Tortelli ($34) which our server suggested.
Now, in my opinion, Indian's are the biggest critiques of Italian food and often times find it bland, thanks to our "sometimes" overpowering, yet flavorful spices, so the expectation was quite low - but were we surprised when presented with one of the most flavorful and delicious Italian food we've ever had!
We were running late for a dinner reservation, which we couldn't cancel at the last minute, else this was an absolute perfect place to wine and dine! This place is bookmarked as one of our favorites and special thanks to the super friendly team at Tutto for a wonderful evening filled with excellent ambiance, food, and service.
Will definitely visit again!
My favorite restaurant in all of the Hamptons. Excellent restaurant all around. The food is incredible especially the spaghetti “scarpariello”. Wine is terrific and the ambiance is romantic and homey at the same time. Highly recommend. And it’s open all year round for us locals.
Rosario S. Cassata (Batman)
+4
Great Italian Restaurant in Sag Harbor.. Tutto il Giorno offers indoor and outdoor dining. The restaurant has a nautical theme. and a boutique. We have been here several times and it doesn't disappoint.
There is no other restaurant in the Hamptons as reliable and consistent as Tutto Il Giorno, Sag Harbor. From the food, to the wine, to the service, it’s simply perfect every time. If you’re dining here in the winter, don’t miss the Tortelli.
It is a wonderful dining space, with knowledgeable affable staff. The food was on time and perfectly prepared. The Cioppino was very good but the veal chop was perfect. Notable. Great cut, perfectly prepared. The Budino and Cappucino were awesome. I’ll be back. 👊🏼👍🏼
Best restaurant in Sag Harbor. The chef Agostino is just amazing! Fresh tasteful ingredients prepared to perfection are the key.
Thank you for an absolutely magical experience again! Amazing all around, and we were a party of 8, on a gorgeous Saturday night....service was great, food was exceptional, and the ambience was perfect...can't wait to come back again, and again, and again!
What a wonderful place to dine. Each room and area is impeccably decorated. The staff are efficientl and pleasant. Can't wait to return.
Are you really in the Hamptons if you don't get Tutto il Giorno?! Definitely the spot to go if you want a delicious filling meal. I honestly had this about 5-6 times last summer. It's still on my mind. I cannot wait to go back
Most delicious food from Naples is not far away, chef Agostino and the tutto il giorno team will take you there with an unparalleled hospitality! Tutto il giorno at Sag Harbor spot is the best restaurant in everything New York State has to offer. Congrats to all! Thank you for an amazing experience….In attesa di vedere presto...👍
This was easily the best pasta we’ve had in the Hamptons (and maybe ever!). We got the mushroom/spinach fettuccine special and the rigatoni. It’s highly impressive that we got it to go and traveled with it for nearly 30 minutes, yet it was just as amazing. We wanted to write this review also for the amazing customer service. I originally thought something was supposed to be on the pasta so we had brought it back to check and for the inconvenience they immediately offered us dessert. This was so kind and highly appreciated as we were definitely not dressed the part (we had just stopped in after a busy day), yet were treated with equal respect. We can’t wait to eat here again & highly recommended. Yum!
I’ll start with the positives: the food is spectacular- the tricolore, rigatoni and bolognese are a must
Moving on to the negatives: the cocktails take a very long time - after appetizers, and unfortunately they were very disappointing. We started with a bottle of still and after they poured the four of us a glass another bottle was placed on our table which went untouched. They didn’t ask if we wanted another bottle and I found it rude to just add it to the bill when we never requested it.
I give it four stars because I’ll be back for the delicious food.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes