Sluurpy
Reset

There are 4 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Mexican cuisine: the best places to taste it in Sag Harbor

There are 4 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Estia's Little Kitchen
85/100 (754 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegan Options
Mexican
Vegetarian Friendly
Contemporary
Contemporary
Mexican
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Brunch
Drinks
Fish Taco
Tacos
Burger
Burrito
Tortillas
Breakfast Burrito
Pancakes
Omelette
Fish
Salad
Tapas
Sit down
Contemporary
Mexican
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Lunch
Drinks
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Mid-range
"As a foodie, I always appreciate a good delicatessen, and Cove Delicatessen definitely delivers. The wide variety of dishes, from sandwiches and..."
Michael Lessard
"It is a good place for comfort food and has a nice outdoor seating area but the breakfast prices were a little much for what I got. The breakfast..."
Jordan Paredes
"Delicious breakfast, we had cochinita pibil tacos with eggs, peach pancakes (some of the best pancakes I’ve had) and breakfast burrito. Juices were..."
Ursula V
"Wonderful quaint joint with beautiful food and service. Definitely the best Mexican cuisine in the..."
Jason Papatryfon
"On the side of a road about 5 minutes outside of Sag Harbor town is this small Mexican-influenced restaurant dishing up some amazing brunch and..."
Sydney Connolly
"Visited Southampton for the weekend with my girlfriends and decided to check this place out before we headed back home. Interior and Exterior of this..."
Hiromi Tateishi
"I feel better just sitting in Estia's back yard... Eating turtles (wonderful veggie wrap) and sipping an Arnold Palmer. Best chocolate pudding..."
Heather Hyde Jennings
"We loved our breakfast at this quaint, full service establishment. Our eggs were excellent, prepared exactly as we asked for. The coffee was so good...."
Lwb Lwb
"Absolutely one of our..."
Paul inzerillo
"Nice and comfy spot with authentic food. We had the breakfast burrito and the fish tacos both amazing! Can't forget to mention the hot sauce was..."
Colbert Saint-Laurent
"We absolutely love this place! Amazing food & very friendly staff!!! Highly recommend..."
James Rivera
"5 stars all around. Great vibe, excellent food, and the service was wonderful. Today was our first time and we sat at the bar. Lovely gem in the..."
Ashley Makes
"My daughter and I had a great lunch experience at the lovely outdoor garden. The service was pretty fast given the Sunday lunch crowd. The Tacos and..."
Rajiv Krishnamurthy
Jimmy Jims Deli
85/100 (151 ratings)
Restaurants
Mexican
Deli
Deli
Mexican
Lunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Fast food
Mexican
Deli
Breakfast
Lunch
"In Sag Harbor, I usually like to go here if I want a bagel sandwich. They give you simple, solid food, that really doesn't have anything mind..."
Enzo Esteruelas
"Not my favorite but I like this..."
Hilario Alvarez
"Quality sandwich every single time. At other south fork delis you might get that motivated employee who does good, or you might get a ball of..."
Joshua Tyte
"Very good sandwiches. Diverse and interesting menu. Everything we ordered was excellent and prepared quickly. Prices are quite reasonable as well...."
Tony Badalamenti
"The bacon,egg and cheese sandwich on a roll with a hot coffee is the perfect way to start you day! Also please try the smoothies! I would have a..."
Wil Lyles
"Smoothies & açaí bowls are fresh made on the go !!..."
Gabe Geovanny
"Legit best sandwich in the Hamptons - #36 w Bacon. Not your average..."
Will Shapiro
"Best Acai Bowls I’ve ever..."
Michael Arocho
"I come to the hamptons every summer and Jimmy Jims is by far one of my favorite spots. Great food, greats service and friendly..."
John Moran
"Delicious food, quick and efficient service and friendly staff :) Inexpensive prices..."
E. M.
"This is my new go to place for food and drinks. Wing night is..."
Jason Volini
"Best Acai Bowls around. Our office gets them daily. truly the..."
Cynthia Capalbo
"Food is good and prices are fair. Will stop in more..."
Kevin Lucas
"Nice small deli with good coffee and great home baked..."
John Edvardsen
"Great food...original...sweet cream bear claws are..."
NY 360 East
"Love the steak Burrito Bowls my..."
Luke Rogers
La Superica
74/100 (48 ratings)
Restaurants
Mexican
Dinner
"Best perfect margarita on the planet! Their food is always awesome accompanied by their gourmet black bean soup. The VIBE is always mellow for anyone..."
Thomas Williamson
"All the employees are straight shooters. You will find no empty compliments here. If you want a typical Hamptons restaurant with no personality and..."
Michael Pintauro
"Great: chips, salsa, chicken enchilada, chicken burrito, black beans, salad, and service. Extra chips, salsa, and & guac came without us having to..."
Tom Carroll
"I have never one time had a bad experience in this staple of sag harbor. Service=class and bartenders=classier. It's a no brainer to get a perfect..."
Dan Reiser
"Frozen Margaritas, guacamole, salsa and chips say no more! Pop into Superica, right across form the wharf the bar gets crowded and people jam in for..."
The Corcoran Group
"A small, very authentic mexican style restaurant. HUGE..."
Meg
"Try the perfect margarita and the shrimp enchilada. Beautiful..."
Anna Dunworth
"Best Mexican restaurant in the..."
Andrew Hellman
"Great Mexican food with gigantic..."
Derek Hyde
"Drinks, food, and good people makes this place..."
Alex Gonzalez
"Great..."
George Lynagh
""
Joseph Yurkewitch
""
Gordon Sommer
""
Christian Haerter
""
Vin Montaldo
Cilantro's
70/100 (244 ratings)
Restaurants
Mexican
Mexican
Dinner
Lunch
Any Burrito
Cilantro´S Healthy Salad
Black Beans and Veggie Tostada
Shrimp Tacos
Guacamole
Pico de Gallo
Tortilla Chip
Veggie Fajitas
Taco
Veggie Burrito
Sit down
Mexican
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Accepts Discover
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Digital Payments
Free Wifi
Delivery
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Picked up some chicken tacos and a chicken burrito while visiting Sag Harbor and enjoyed them at a picnic table in the park. Best deal in town and..."
Rebecca Leser
"Their food is so fresh ,and so good. We always start off with the nachos grande ,Ryan the cilantro salad with avocados, yummmmy. I did order the..."
leslie cafiso
"Not a bad veggie burrito. Nice little place, they give you lots of chips in the chip bag when you order that. Good avocado and sour cream. I’ll be..."
Peter Henny
"I'm not a fan of the Burritos (Ive tried a variety of them). Carne Asada is excellent and I would also recommend steak quesadilla. No Seating so..."
Ken h
"Excellent chicken fajitas! Guac was great..."
Julie Sparkman
"Come in here all the time for the burritos, great price for how much you get and how great they..."
George Mann (GMann)
"Really delicious tacos and the waiting time wasn’t long at..."
Tam Petersen
"The best veggie burrito and cheese quesadilla, especially if you want a fast but “real” tasting option. Made fresh for us and..."
Roxane Debaty
"Simple place, with great food. Small "market" area with drinks and other Mexican..."
Jorge D
"Terrific, fresh food. Friendly service. And affordable for the ever-increasing insanity of the Hamptons, which Sag Harbor unfortunately has very much..."
Richard
"Been coming to cilantros ever since I was in highschool, never been disappointed. Great people, great food, great selection of sodas and snacks. The..."
Jacob Benbenek
"I've been coming here for years. The food is healthy and the ingredients are excellent. The lettuce is fresh and tastes local, tomatoes are red and..."
Hal Aycock-Rizzo
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use