This is a wonderful establishment all-around. They have amazing ice cream, featuring some delicious flavors you won't find anywhere else. They also have sorbet, custard, frozen yogurt, and even paninis! The staff here is super friendly, informative, and helpful. Joey does a great job running the place. The atmosphere is really fun and unique; it's a really cool place to sit down with your friends and family to enjoy a superb treat. I have nothing bad to say about it. I would recommend this place to anyone who makes it out to Sanibel.
The best ice cream on Sanibel island & the friendliest staff!!! Definitely worth the visit!!
So many flavors, so little time! Great atmosphere, friendly staff and cool treats to die for. Kahlua, Espresso Chip, Salted Caramel are my favs. A gem we will be sure to return to everytime we visit Sanibel.
After a bad experience with unfriendly staff somewhere else on the island, we decided to give this place a try. We were very pleasantly surprised. Friendly girl greeted us with a smile. Great service and cozy, welcoming atmosphere. The ice cream wasn't bad, either. We went back today for coffee. Met the owner. "Best coffee on the island", he said. He wasn't lying.
Had the pleasure of finally getting out to Joeys with the family today. I have to say it was an awesome experience starting with the great atmosphere and the food was amazing! Of course we had to get dessert �� which was awesome as well.
This place is a must stop when you’re on Sanibel and can’t wait for next visit!!
Wide selection of ice creams, custards and sorbets with an endless variety of ways to eat them! Staff were super friendly and patient as everyone came in and spent forever looking at the menu boards before making a choice. Highly recommended
Karen Davino Schneidermeyer
+5
The soft serve ice cream is delicious! Nice size serving and awesome toppings. The staff was very friendly and they were open late (at least for the island). The seating area is really nice (inside and out). Enjoyed going there for lunch too (great sandwiches). Nice couches to sit and have coffee too. Coffee was fantastic!
Local Army Veteran, family owned, Nice guy! We met Joey while on vacation. What a really great guy! They have delicious ice cream! My favorite was Salted Caramel Praline! Tables with games inside, nice outdoor seating too. Great location at Baileys plaza! We highly recommend this place!
Came from North Fort Myers tonight because we saw the peanut butter waffle post in the SWFL Foodies Group. Needless to say it was well worth the drive and we can’t wait to come back! Super friendly owner gave some great suggestions.
Fun place for family time eating ice cream and playing games. Love everything about this place!
The custard was great, but the place itself was even better. Can't believe we'd never stumbled in before. Comfy places to sit, activities to keep the kids busy and interesting items on the wall. Being a Western New Yorker by birth, I especially enjoyed the Jim Kelly jersey and the Buffalo News clippings. Highly recommended.
The best dairy free ice cream! There’s something for everyone!
What took me so long to eat here?!?!Joey’s is my new favorite spot for a quick bite. Everyone needs to come grab a panini and follow it up with a scoop of Working Cow ice cream. I am so happy to support this locally owned island cafe...way to go Joey.
Not only is the custard and ice cream sooooo good, Joey & the other staff are very friendly and provide the best customer service. Went there 3 out of the 7 days we were on Sanibel. Will be back next year as well.
After a wonderful day at the beach. My friend and I stopped for some ice cream. Super delicious. Great spot. Sat and enjoyed our ice cream on their porch with plenty of seating. A must if you’re in Sanibel 🏖
This ice cream was delicious!!
Definitely tasted homemade and fresh!
I got a very interesting flavor- pistachio ice cream with chunks of crunchy peanut butter- pounded weird BUT SUCH a good combo!
Love the unique ice cream flavor names!
The little porch set up was adorable and felt very safe- one group of customers in the store at a time- so be patient but it is worth the wait!!
Convientlyy located next to Sanibel Lighthouse Cafe- perfect spot post-Beach / Lighthouse exploring!
Convenient location at the Southern end of Sanibel near the lighthouse park area. The young man working was very pleasant. They have a wide variety of delicious flavours and the prices are what one might expect to pay on the (tourist) resort driven island. A cute little shop to have good ice cream. We would stop again for sure.
Thebestpublicadjuster Thebestpublicadjuster
+5
On our way to the Sanibel lighthouse District weI must stop at Sanibel’s Best Homemade Ice Cream!! Amazing flavors Their stuff is super nice and friendly the kids love them 😊 ❤️ they have a great shops in this plaza the lighthouse café ,Emotion clothing store and Tuttle's Seahorse Shells shop are our favorite
Need ice cream in your life...then pay a visit to this little treasure on Sanibel Island especially if you just came from the beach after shelling or sunbathing or from Lighthouse Point you'll definitely be glad you did. It's without a doubt an Island favorite to beat the heat...
If you get one of the waffle cones, make sure you grab plenty of napkins.
Best Homemade Ice Cream is not a lie! This place has truly fantastic ice cream. I got Dolphin Tracks, which money is donated to support water filtration to make the water cleaner for dolphins with every scoop you buy! It included marshmallow chunks, chocolate chips and sprinkles. A picture is included below. I also got one called the Sandpiper, which was the creamiest caramel ice cream I’ve ever had!
Very tasty homemade ice creams place near the Sanibel Lighthouse Beach. We loved their outside sitting area and it also open till late 10pm-ish - unlike other restaurants & shops on Sanibel Island which close at 8pm.
Loved this cute and yummy ice cream shop! My family came here and got the Blue Giraffe and Purple Cow. Great flavor without being over the top sweet. Recommend!
Our visit to Sanibel is not complete unless we have a scoop (or 2 or 3) from Sanibel’s Best Homemade Ice Cream!! The ice cream really is homemade and so delicious! Plus all the fun/local flavor names! My kids love it! We have been coming here for years our annual trip from Cincinnati and recommend it to any new or repeat Sanibel visit! Come support this local
Business and enjoy this island treat! And don’t forget the morning for delicious coffee and pastry too! Thank you for such a wonderful experience! It’s worth the wait!
This has got to be one of the best ice cream I’ve ever had. I always check to see if it has re-opened but sadly it has not. I hope they can restore the place and are back in business soon. Miss you guys!
Formerly called 'Pinocchio's', family has been coming here for years. Ice cream is delicious... a wonderful treat for youngsters -- and 'oldsters'! Will be on Sanibel in Oct (2020) and looking forward to visiting 'Sanibel's Best Ice Cream' once again.
Really good ice-cream and the best banana split ever! Staff is always nice and friendly. One of the best places to go for desert on the island
The shops name is so true. Best ice cream my family and I have had. The portions are amazing for a one scope. The owner gave us a little info about how they make it, witch is cool of her. If your able to stop do so.
This place was great! They allow only 1 group or customer inside at a time. Great selection of ice cream, sorbet and gelato. They also have great coffee drinks.
A must stop after visiting the lighthouse. If you spend some time at the beach near the lighthouse and your heat exhausted, stop here! The ice cream there is the absolute best. The staff is as sweet as the treats! Thank you to the staff! Keep the smiles going. Its tops the ice cream off better than sprinkles!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes