Came here from out of town, and this was some of the best key lime pie I have ever had!! The texture, flavor, crust, EVERYTHING was perfect. They also have a variety of other desserts that looked amazing. They sell a whole key lime pie, but also slices for anyone who just wants one slice. The cashier was also very helpful and recommended some restaurants for us to try in the area. 10/10 recommend this place!
Carolyn Thibault Wheel
+5
This little pie shop is tucked away but should not be passed by. Went here because I heard they made the best Key Lime pie in the area. They did not disappoint! What a delicious pie with smooth filling and wonderful flavor. I usually prefer a regular pie crust to graham cracker, but I was content with theirs. They use a whipped cream topping, which I prefer over meringue. The pie will set you back $25, but my husband and I agreed it was the best in the area and it brought us back to our trip to Key West many years ago. If Key Lime pie isn’t your thing, they have many other pies flavors available!
Key lime pie fanatic here! This place makes the best key lime pie I've ever had, period. Whenever we have guests that need to true FL key lime pie experience, this is where we go to get it.
The pecan pie is also very good, but I would not recommend the passion fruit pie (not much passion fruit flavor and just overpowered with richness).
They also have very cute souvenirs and little gifts that you can buy here. Definitely worth stopping by and checking it out.
Was the best Keylime pie Ive ever had. My friend brought one to me in Texas and I wasnt sure what to expect, but it lived up to the reviews I saw online.
She asked what place I wanted to try and picked this one based on multiple articles and reviews..
Everything about the pie was great. The crust, the filling & the topping. Wasnt too tart or sweet..
The Honeybell Orange cake is incredible and doesn’t have dairy (just eggs). Unique tropical cakes like guava cake. Various scones and breads, I got the Tropical Banana Coconut Bread ($6). Freshly made. Nice, quaint, Old Florida aesthetic. Very kind staff. Known for their orange cake and key lime pie.
I am a HUGE Key Lime pie person. When I tell you I’ve had it all I truly have. Floribbean Flo’s Key Like Pie is hands down THE BEST I’ve ever had. It was amazing! I will absolutely be a forever customer. I love the owners story and I’m so glad she decided to open her own business. Excellent job!
I purchased Key Lime and Lemon Beach pies there for Friendsgiving. They were a huge hit.! They were soft and creamy, light yet decadent. Well worth the trip to South Sarasota. The store itself is bright with a touch of Old Florida charm, all the goodies and yummies colorfully displayed. Very inviting indeed. Friendly knowledgeable staff. After multiple visits, I have never been disappointed. A real treat for myself , family and friends.
I LOVE Floribbean Flo’s — the place and the pie! It’s total throwback Florida, full of kitschy souvenir items and the best Key Lime Pie you’ll ever eat. If you’d rather have chocolate peanut butter or coconut cream or bananas foster or passion fruit or scones, cake or quiche, they have all that and more. Ongoing (never-ending!) construction on The Tamiami Trail makes it a wee bit more challenging to get to the tucked-away shop, but it’s definitely worth a trip.
Excellent service here. Big fan of the peanut butter pie. Key lime is great too.
The BEST key lime pie, and you have to try the passion fruit pie! Quiche is great to grab and have on hand for beach breakfast. Cute gifts, too, and the owners are so sweet. I recommend Flo’s to all friends visiting the Sarasota/Venice area (we’ve even driven down from Ft. Myers) and they all rave about it. Don’t bother ordering key lime pie in a restaurant, get this one!!!
Stopped by on our girls trip due to the high ratings. The Key Lime Pie was absolutely amazing. Best Ive ever had. Highly recommend!
Fabulous Key Lime pie. Had a party ,bought 5 pies. They flew away in popularity. Will buy more next time.
Crust very good and excellent thickness.
Key lime very balanced and creamy.
I had read all of the reviews about how incredible the key lime pie from this place was so I picked one up today and had a slice as soon as I got home. I'm not sure if it's the absolute best I have ever tasted, but if not it is not very far off!
The most important thing to me, what makes a key lime pie great vs just good is the crust, and Flo's has an excellent one. I still maintain that the best crust I have ever had on a key lime pie was when they used to have it at Longhorn Steakhouse.
Unfortunately they removed it from their menu and I have not found any crust like that since, so in the absence of Longhorn's which is no longer offered, I can definitely rate this one as the best key lime pie ever. And even though I liked the crust better from LH, Flos actual pie, the texture and flavor is far superior! Do yourself a favor and it out...you will be glad that you did!
Wonderful surprise in Indiana. A friend flew back from Florida gifted your key lime pie. Absolutely delicious!! My waistline is glad you are in Florida and not around the corner! 😋
We love Key Lime pie and after a quick Google search, we found Florribean Flo's with many touting it as the best ever. They were a little difficult to find but I'm glad we stuck with the search. We decided to get an entire Key Lime pie and we were not disappointed. We have tried many Key Lime pies over the years and this was definitely one of the best (if not THE best) we have ever tried. We also tried the Passion Fruit which was also very delicious and I also saw the Chocolate Peanut Butter pie which is on the list for next time! I would highly recommend and will definitely be back when we visit again!
Key lime pie is out of this world. Must try!
After searching for the best Key Lime Pie and finding this place (being the most highly rated) I had to give it a shot. Not the easiest to find, but certainly we’ll worth it! The key lime pie was excellent as was the customer service. In hindsight I would recommend buying the entire pie as it was less than if you purchased 3 slices. Will definitely return
Our quest to find the best Key Lime Pie in Sarasota and Siesta Key was accomplished. The Passion Fruit Pie was delicious too. Not to be passed up if I’m the area, and worth the drive from Siesta Key. Friendly owners/bakers.
All that came to my mind when I took the first bite of the chocolate covered key lime pie on a stick was WOW! It was perfect: not frozen on the inside, wonderful ratio of crust, key lime, whipped cream, and chocolate, and didn’t fall off my stick. Our cashier was so sweet she made the experience all the better. The place was a little hard to find but it’s 100 percent worth the hunt because this place is a treasure!! Would love to see it in the village of siesta key, more people deserve to taste the delectables from Flo’s.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes