Hands down !! The best Italian food in sarasota. Quaint small place. Must have reservations. I had the best gnocchis in town that came places in bread bowl. To die for. I would eat here every night. Amazing. Will not disappoint.
Seriously one of the best Italian meals in Florida! A real hidden gem. Small restaurant so not great for larger groups but intimate setting with great food & wine selection.
We lucked out with the street food of the day being Arrancini Bolognese which were delicious! Loved everything from their bread starter to their fresh al denti pasta.
Exceptional dining experience!
Superb food that is plated beautifully, extremely pleasant and professional staff. Owner is present and adds to the dining experience. The wine list is outstanding.
Andrea's is a great find and we'll be going back. The pasta was cooked to perfection and the short ribs had superb flavor. The wine list is extensive. When you go, don't hold back... mangia e divertiti!
Our dinner last night was amazing. The food got huge raves from our group. The ravioli was sublime and the fish was delicious. The service was impeccable ! The waiter and busboy worked in tandem beautifully- despite a very busy Monday night crowd. Kudos to the servers and the chefs who went above and beyond to give us an amazing culinary experience. We will return often!
This was a truly exceptional dining experience. The ambiance, the wine, the food, and the service combined to make this the best Italian dining experience I've enjoyed in the Sarasota area. Could not have been more pleased and we will be back!
Far and away, the best, most authentic, and freshest Italian in the area. I recommend all dishes, but the Ravioli Carbonara are my personal favorite
So my experience here was part of a larger group of people and both the service and food was impeccable. I had the octopus and it was grilled to perfection. Like no place I have had it before. The eggplant appetizer was so good I could have eaten it for a meal.
I have read some of the comments on cocktail napkins being needed, with nice tablecloths to absorb any condensation from my ice tea I liked them not wasting the paper napkin so many others do under the drink.
Andrea’s is a hidden gem in Sarasota. The owner/chef is amazing. We have eaten here 20 times and each time it’s great. From the appetizers to dessert. Everything on the menu is delicious. He recently opened a pizza place wine bar right next door. He has some of the best wine selections in town. The pizza crust and sauce is also THE BEST IN SARASOTA! No question. Feel free to come give me a bad review if both of Andrea’s places aren’t super.
We were walking past Andrea's restaurant and we suddenly we smelled Italy, right in Sarasota! We had to go in to try it and have been regulars ever since!
This is the most authentic incredible Italian food that money can buy in this town. With a fabulous wine selection unrivaled in quality, a creative delicious menu, and kind generous service, Andrea's is a dining experience not to be missed! Treat yourself!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes