Loved my first experience here.
They recommended a " Horn". Delicious and so fresh and light. Their variety is extensive and flavorful. Clean, organized, and very helpful and attentive.
I will edit my review after enjoying all the items I purchased.
Had to try a bourbon ball, yummiest before driving away. A "must go" while in Sarasota folks!
Outstanding selection and inventory! The Key lime tart is so good. The lobster roll is other-worldly! My notoriously fickle 13 year old devoured his giant swiss roll. The prices are very reasonable too. Great service and clean, easy 5 stars....
The BEST bakery with the most delicious black and white cookies.
So good that my toddler snuck a few nibbles...
One of the best bakery I’ve ever seen. I decently felt Italian style and love of owner who found this bakery
it is exquisite 👌 😋 congratulations
your attention is excellent 🙌✨️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
8 years ago when I was in Venezuela I ate these sweets, in a pastry shop in my city Caracas.
8 years later I find them here in Sarasota in this bakery, lobster tails stuffed with cream, delicious 🤤🤤
What a little gem this bakery is. Very authentically made, fresh Italian goodies. Everything from the cookies to the cakes and pies was moist and delicious. The workers are very patient and helpful as we browsed and made our choices. I’ll be going back while In town on vacation.
Jennifer was amazing and helped us pick out what we wanted. She was very friendly. The pizza sauce tasted amazing. The pizza was pretty heavy though and made you feel full after one slice. The pastries were to sweet and not fresh. But I give credit to the Rhode Island style food! Over all the food was good but be ready for a food coma!😂
Best customers in town even when crowded everyone is polite and respectful. What a fantastic selection. Well worth the trip. What a find, old school service and pastries. Delicious and soooo yummy.
Authentic, delicious spinach pies, eggplants and pastries, that brought back memories of my childhood growing up in Rhode Island. Purchased as much as I could get in my luggage, heading to the middle of the country where this type of pastry is nonexistent. Stop and treat yourself and you won’t regret it.
It was Christmas Eve day and we were visiting family. I could not find good Italian bread for our feast. My daughter in law suggested Paisanos. I pull up and the line was down the “block”. I knew I found the real deal. Lined up and found the holy grail of Italian Bread. It was beautiful loaf of bread and tasted delicious! I shall return to try all of the Italian pastries! Buon Natale!
honestly one of the best bakeries i've ever been to. the workers are all so sweet and charismatic and make you feel at home. the variety in baked goods is almost overwhelming, but that just gives you a reason to come back and try something new. i think about their lobster tails every day.
Mystic Quantum Alchemist
+5
This is my spot!!!! 🤤🙌🔥 Legit my kryptonite 😂 I go here at least once a week lol & I always get 1-2 cannolis (they prepare them on the spot 😌 bc they know what they’re doing 👏😁); I loved the cheesecake brownie, red velvet cupcake was delicious & the blueberry muffins are to die for!!!!!! 💯 Going to try the cannoli cake next, get a couple rainbow cookies and who knows what else 😂😍 everything here is authentic top quality Italian 🇮🇹 !!! & the customer service is the cherry on top! Professional, kind and make you feel like family 🙏
A wonderful & delicious bakery…a must stop when in the Sarasota area! Shopping at Paisano’s is now a family tradition for us on our trips to the Florida Gulf Region. Welcoming staff, outstanding customer service & pastries/Italian food items that are amazing! Can’t wait to go back!
Just go here.
No pics because the food is too good. The best food doesn't last long enough for pics.
I can say more but not really. Italian Bakery, you need to go, if you want anything from an Italian bakery go.
You probably should just go, even if you don't want anything.
If you are reading a review on this place, you should just go.
Been in the Bradenton area for about 10 months now and only just found this place. Man I wish I was closer to it but I will be back! I'm from the Philly area and I KNOW BAKERIES!!! This is a bakery! If your from here you think Publix is one. Oh heck no. I've been dreaming of the day I found a bakery and oh baby that day has come. Give them a try
An Italian friend introduced me to this Italian bakery in Sarasota. If you have frequented REAL Italian bakeries in New England, you will immediately feel at home. Your only problem may be what to choose!! Their selection is gorgeous; the store is immaculate; you can even get a cuppa delicious fresh made coffee upon request.
Surprise your family, friends, or just treat yourself. You'll be so glad you did!
Best Italian Bakery outside of Brooklyn New York. Try the ricotta cake, Cream Puffs. JUST TRY EVERYTHING! - Rocky
I visit 1-2 times a year from out of state and this is always my first and last stop. Black and white cookies are AMAZING!!! They also do military discount which is wonderful.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes