We got a grandma pie there for the first time after the storm as they were the only place open. We are now converts! It was DELICIOUS!!! Will definitely be going back!!
This place has one of the best bbq chicken slices and buffalo chicken slices I have ever had.
A little nicer than your average pizza joint. This place is a notch above the average pizza joints that you can find in pretty much every strip mall on Long Island. The location is in an old building (not in a strip mall, which is nice) that has apparently been recently renovated so as to give it a modern look, while still managing to preserve much of the original woodwork and tiling. The food itself is a bit above most other pizza places, and they offer an above average selection of specialty pies.
Overall: A solid "B".
We have been taking out from here for years. Best pizza in the area, rest of their food is also very good. Staff always friendly, service prompt, food ready when they say it will be. Highly recommend.
This is a great counter service/to-go Italian restaurant in the neighborhood. An expected menu with well executed dishes tops off a really great Specialty Pizza selection. This is a can't go wrong stop for a quick bite or to take home dinner for the fam. The owner's are on site and very nice.
Love the food and the great delivery time! Call before 5pm that way you beat the dinner rush and if anything put a order in ahead of time. I personally love the chicken parm slices and the hero but if you want to really enjoy yourself, go for the penne ala vodka pie it's amazing!!
I can't get enough of this place!! First off let me tell you that I am a connoisseur of Italian food and especially PIZZA! I am Very PICKY and I am willing to travel long distances just to get a quality meal. I am always quickly greeted with a friendly face and a smile. The proprietor & his staff take pride in delivering a quality, consistent product and keep a very clean restaurant. The pizza here is to die for! I highly recommend the sicilian it rivals Collisseo or Ginos of Nesconset. Whoever wrote the bad reviews are sour grapes!
Good pizza. Other menu items are better than average for this kind of pizza place. Friendly staff and delivery reliably comes when they say it will.
Used to be a great place to grab a slice and they had awesome meatballs! Looks like it was shut down due to a lease issue; Most likely a greedy property owner raising the rent. What else is new.
Great food ,great service, Best pizza in town , not to mention the wings are off the chain....if your a wing lover like me ,you'll love there wings .The Dinners are large and delicious .
Christlopher Brandimarte
+4
Excellent pizza. Excellent dinners.
Ambiance is not a strong suit, but the food is.
Best pizza in the area. The Grandma's slice is amazing.
Greatest pizza place in Setauket. Wonderful people work here!
Great im sad that it closed down because now we are stuck with station pizza and another place that burns the pizza 🍕🍕
Great food, friendly family atmosphere. I highly highly recommend!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes