Sluurpy > Restaurants in Shelter Island > Maria's Kitchen

Maria's Kitchen - Shelter Island - Photo album

This should be on Diners, Drive ins and Dives. They grow their own herbs out back. The grilled fish burrito is amazing. Rice and beans are top notch. Maria is a sweetheart.

Baja shrimp taco is immaculate. So much shrimp in one taco. just amazing. Chicken taco is super yummy and not too salty! Nachos is pico de gallo was *chefs kiss* but the nachos were very clumped up together- still very good.

My friends and I were biking in the area and stumbled upon this place based on a recommendation from the ferry operator. The food was incredible! The portions were massive and the ingredients tasted so fresh. The people working were kind, the patio in the back was very pleasant to eat in, and the fo

Excellent!!! a great Mexican place in the Island, the tacos were just perfect, I have to go back to try the fish burrito! We accompanied the tacos with Agua de Jamaica and beer from their neighbors the Shelter Island Craft Brewery. It was great stop before heading back to the ferry.

Friendly welcoming staff, lovely garden in the back, good food. A wee bit pricey but isn’t everything these days. Definitely worth a visit!

Awesome food and big portions. Worth every penny. Staff was super friendly as well! Will be back next time I’m on the island

Was on Shelter Island for an event. Went to Maria’s Kitchen with a group of 20 right at closing and they served us all wonderful food. The dorados were amazing, the burritos are huge and the guacamole was great! Thanks for a great visit - we’ll be back again!

Some of the best burritos we’ve ever had! Maria’s Kitchen has delicious food, great service, and a beautiful atmosphere. Highly recommend!

Fish tacos were huge and delicious! Other tacos were also generous, but the pork and chicken were a bit dry. Will definitely be back!

My wife and I stopped here last year on a whim making our way back to MA. The food is delicious and portions are truly unbelievable. The prices are a little higher than what we are used to but I imagine location has to do with it. Maria is very friendly along with the rest of her staff. I highly