Sluurpy
Reset

There are 11 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Shirley

There are 11 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Combo Pizza
89/100 (140 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Sit down
Pizza
"I had an amazing interaction with a server named Allen. He recommended all the great foods to eat, and made sure I had an excellent visit. I truly..."
Mostafa Jalal
"This place is amazing! The only reason why i gave it a 4 star and not 5 was because this stud asian with an elbow brace made me feel to excited so my..."
Bobby Bung
"So, we recently moved to Shirley, didn't want to cook new years eve, placed my order by Phone, sent my husband to pick it up,(they deliver fyi) he..."
Laura Quan
"As long as I can remember my family has been going here and have never had a bad experience. Lovely family owned place and was the first food my..."
Dylan Von Brook
"Honestly there is nothing much to say about it. The vibes are immaculate. Loved the place and food was spectacular. Service was the best and workers..."
Ethan M
"Honestly I’ve been running around the Tri-Hamlet area looking for a good and consistent chinese spot, and Chun Bo was the perfect destination. The..."
Kevin Coleman
"This is my all time favorite chinese spot in long island. The food here is amazing and the service is efficient. Owner is very friendly and I would..."
Hester Liu
"Best Chinese place ever. You walk in and you’re immediately greeted with a stud. Like if you’re into kpop or any Asian style things like anime..."
Jaekim564
"Felix says Great food.. I finally found a Chinese place that makes the food the same way every time.. A taste from back in the day when it was made..."
FELIX TROCHE
"We ordered two items from here today. Both items were very good. Delivery was also very quick. We'll be ordering from them again and recommend..."
Steve Dimarco
"Been going here for years always good food! Back in town for a visit and stopped in for a take out dinner and it was just as I never left......"
Angela Melville
"i’m telling you this is the best chinese food i’ve ever tasted my whole life i almost cried ever since 3 weeks ago i have been coming here daily..."
Chelsea Ni
"The chicken broccoli was delectable. This is a nice family owned business and will definitely be coming back again..."
angela li
"Super clean, and delicious delivery guy. Everything is so good. The kid Allen is always super smelly, I mean..."
Katherine Borrayo
"Classic Chineese American food cooked perfectly at fair prices. I picked this place because of one scathing review online that said horrible things..."
Bethany Emmerson
Village Pizza
85/100 (250 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Lunch
Dinner
"Went there because was house sitting in Shirley. I have to say the food was fresh and amazing and staff was friendly. For a Sub Shop seafood was..."
Steven N
"This place has an amazing menu and awesome food! And very friendly service. I ordered a gyro platter and I have to say out of every place I've been..."
Carmel Gangi
"Eat or order from here every time I'm in the area, great food, generous servings, good prices, and friendly..."
Melissa Snow
"This spot is good! Good pricing, considerable dishes and the staff are consistently very..."
Jonas Boone
"Really..."
Anthony lopez
"Absolutely one of the best restraunts in town, I eat here every time I'm in Shirley, I actually look forward to it. I have never left disappointed,..."
Joseph Dawson
"Fresh..made to order, big salad and fast! Mucho garcias..."
Calypso Cremé
Savanora's Pizzeria
84/100 (160 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Lunch
Dinner
"Everyone is super nice and pizza is always fast and fresh. They even take special requests like a heart shaped pizza with a garlic bread crust for..."
Chinh Chinh
"BEST pizza in town by far..Best crust...best tomato sauce!! FRESH food every day. This is a casual place, small, well lit and clean, friendly staff,..."
Maria Isabel Maldonado
"Great food. Never had a..."
Andy Logan
"Brought home 2 pies tonight. Very good. Pepperoni and..."
Mary R
"My younger son and I love the penne ala vodka slice, and my older son loves the Buffalo chicken pizza. We all love the regular slices, and I also..."
Valerie Taylor
"They’ve historically been amazing and consistent. Staff / management has fallen off though and it’s not quite the same although you can still go..."
Sean Forestal
"Superb deep dish Pepperoni, the only pizza I’ve liked as much as Costco pizza. And they have wonderful garlic knots and pasta. Definitely..."
Diego Alvarez
"Ok first time ordering from here it was pizza half mushrooms and half cheese and it was great so I will be going here from now..."
ricky bouchard
"Great pizza. Always good food. And a amazing assortment of delicious food ready behind the glass for a quick grab and..."
john bosman
"Amazing pizza and chicken Rolls. Truly recommend any slice of..."
Vittorio DiBenedetto
"Good pizza but it tastes much better when you eat there it does not warm up well lately it seems they are putting less cheese on the pizza I was not..."
Mary Ellen
"5 stars from me. Food was delicious, hot, and fresh. Restaurant was clean, and service was great. Will definitely be going there again. Very fair..."
Bob Ryan
"Best deep dish pizza...the crust is the perfect caramelized top and chewy delicious center it melts in your mouth!!!!! The sauce!!!! I don't know..."
Barbara Helene
"Great food and awesome service as always. Been going there for 14 years now. Best pizza in..."
Terry Havens
"Very good pizza. Home delivery is slow. Better to either order ahead of time you want to eat or pick..."
Ellen Richardson
Roux's Pizza
82/100 (239 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Sit down
Pizza
"One of my main spots to eat. very good location, clean, and good service. Highly..."
Toby L
"Would absolutely recommend trying this spot. Exceptional atmosphere, yummy dishes, good customer service. They never..."
T Ali
"I love food..."
IMC QUALITY CLEANING
"This place is listed as a pizza restaurant, but that's only half of the store... The other half is a convenience store filled with snacks, candy,..."
Simon Handford
Piccolino's Restaurant
81/100 (489 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Bar
Pizza
Pub
Italian
Pizza
American
American
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Surf and Turf
Chowder
Pizza
Affogato
Chicken Fingers
Cheesy Bacon Fries
Pastrami
Bacon Cheeseburger and Waffle Fries
Patty Melt
Clam Chowder Soup
Chef's Salad
Steak Tips Sweet Potato Fries Mixed Veggies
Fish N' Chips
The Cowboy Burger
Clam Roll Do You See the Roll
Crème Brulee Cheesecake
BBQ Pulled Pork Waffle Fries and Wings
Chicken Teriyaki Rice
Warm Bavarian Pretzel Sticks
Veal Parmesan
Carrot Cake
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Pizza
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Our waitress was awesome! I had the best salad I have had in a long time. French fries were awesome too! Perfect neighborhood restaurant. Very clean..."
Crissy Flaherty
"Pretty good food, quality service and smoke free. Overall, worth going to. No off street parking, but wasn't an..."
Google Account
"I absolutely LOVE this place!!! It completely REMINDS ME OF THE PLACE in the MOVIE: WHAT A WONDERFUL LIFE!!! I FEEL SO BLESSED TO HAVE FOUND THIS..."
Elle Cunha
"Great selection. Try the Texas Hawg Wings!!! WOW......."
Jim Morrison
"I've had 3 incredible meals at Piccolino's Restaurant, the food is the best tasting, fresh, excellent quality and quantity. I'll be eating there..."
Matthew Gaudet
"Great food! Great staff! A good hometown..."
Kim Casto
"The customer service is regularly efficient, great vibes, very welcoming staff members. Will come back again when I get in..."
Asa Hayes
"Great service food was..."
Thomas Geyer
Carlo's Pizza
80/100 (964 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken parmigiana
Hawaiian Pizza
White Pizza
BBQ Pizza
Grilled Chicken Panini
Ravioli Parmesan
Penne Ala Vodka
Stuffed Garlic Knots
Chicken Parm Pizza
Vodka Slice
Shroompizza
Stuffed Pizza Large
Chicken Soup Pint
Bakery
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Spaghetti
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Just wanted to make sure everyone knows this place makes the best garlic knots on the island. And the staff is super friendly and helpful. Not with..."
Ana Valentin
"I have been coming to Carlo's for years and their pizza is always the best! At other places the pizza is inconsistent but at Carlos it is always..."
Mark Dollas
"Come here every once in a while to pick up pizza and pasta and I’ve always had a decent..."
Jennifer Garcia
"So many of us loyal carlos fans know the quality was slipping . I was just in for a slice after being out if town for a few months and wow the cheese..."
Sal Verdi
"Familial restaurant with quality food at good value. High traffic of orders for pick-up. Drinks by fountain sodas and bottled beers/sodas. Staff..."
Daniel Donnelly
"Friendly service, great prices, delicious food. Had sausage and peppers parmesan dinner. Very tasty. Good cheesecake. Very nice young people working..."
Steve Burns
"I’ve had better chicken Parm heroes at other places, but their pizza is really..."
Colleen Hervan
"Definitely our families new pizza place! 10/10 would..."
Onascia Douglas
"Omg so good the Philly steak slice and pie..its so big and full of meat and the crust is amazing and buttery my wife and I love it so do the kids..."
Dan Stark (Awesome topics)
"The food is amazing, the staff is friendly and welcoming. Frank the boss is awesome. Best pizza in the..."
Amanda Trangucci
"Always good! Friendly staff. Prices are good..."
Edward Windle
"Amazing food, kind staff. Will be going back. Again and again..."
Shaggy’s Parts & Signs
"This place is great, family owned, always busy so you know there pizza is good! It’s always fresh and made to order which I love. So many options..."
Allie C
"The food is amazing and the staff is great. Every once in a while someone will mess up an order, completely wrong item, and they'll have to re-make..."
Liam Russell
Pizza Hut
70/100 (597 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Fast food
Pizza
Lunch
Dinner
"Customer service was awesome and very friendly that's just the start. I ordered a $12.99 dinner box but I swear it felt like it was a $99.99 dinner..."
Emad A
"Had a great experience. Food was hot and ready like they said it was. Family enjoyed it as well. Good..."
Gregory Fleisher
"excellent food, took my order in 2 minutes and fast..."
ali darwich
"Pleasant crew, fast..."
George covetskie
"The service is too slow but i would say the food is pretty good..."
Julianna Fuzessery
"The Barbecue chicken Pizza was great I have to buy it more..."
Jeffrey Lewis
"My food is always on time and they have never messed up my..."
Lilibeth Zúñiga
"Always ready when I get there. Great employees. Smiling faces. Store is clean. Grandkids love your pizza and BBQ..."
BettyAnn Masillo
"Every delivery i choose the option for CONTACT DELIVERY. They never listen. They stay at the door ringing and knocking till I finally have to answer..."
Robert Clougher
"I personally have a favorite workers which is, sosheel and sandra they have really good customer service there pizza freshly made specially for long..."
ʚOceanshxrageɞ
"Sometime it appears the HUT is better then our local traditional Italian Pizza places, and that says a..."
John F. Lomaga
"I love this pizza, their employees here bring you a good service and pay atention yo everything what you want! I recommend this establishment to..."
Nagumi Mestizo
Vincent's Pizza
70/100 (381 ratings)
Restaurants
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Italian
Fast food
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Went to grab some food after the beach, he didn’t have any Chicken Rolls so he made me one fresh! He was super friendly and quick to help! It was..."
Deborah Mahony
"Ordered delivery from the website. The pizzeria actually called me afterwards verifying what I wanted (since I had added extra notes to my order) and..."
Krystina S
"New owner is SO nice!! I didn’t realize what time it was and called to order a pie, he said he was closing but would make it for me anyway. I..."
Christina Olivieri
"Bubble tea: The bubble tea was amazing and the person serving us was very nice. We had medium Taro milk teas with bubbles. They have my different..."
Devin Manning
"Finally we have an amazing pizzeria with perfect sauce!! Also try there amazing Bubble tea! It’s night and day from the last owner of the place...."
Stephanie LaGrasta
"Pizza was well done like I prefer and the chicken wings were mind-blowing. Matched a coupon I had with no..."
Anthony Flecha
"This is the best pizza I have ever eaten.You must come here anytime you want..."
HappyButterfly 92
"They are a different owner now! Tony! And I ordered the Sicilian slice and three cannolis to be delivered I called at 8:30 and they still delivered..."
Tara Verdugo
"We just picked up some pizza and some seafood. It was absolutely delicious. Will be back..."
Carmine Cortese
"NEW management has done it well! I purchased a Buffalo chicken slice as well as a plain, best of both worlds to give the new ownership a shot and I..."
Kevin Wilson
"I always ate at Vincent's since Vincent opened and the food was amazingly great! After sold 2 or 3xs it was bought by a drunk who I seen myself..."
x.Mr.FuLL.E BakEd.x
"i ordered a pizza and meatballs from here and it was absolutely delish!!!! best meatballs..."
Tiffani Palmer
"The store changed boss. They add bubble tea..."
高昊天
"Great pizza, and I love the flavor of the sauce. I know the ownership has had trouble with finding help of late, so sometimes orders might be a..."
Vivimort
Shirley Sub Shoppe
70/100 (265 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Café
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
Vesta
70/100 ( ratings)
Restaurants
Fast Food
Pizza
Tonino's Pizza
70/100 (105 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
"So sorry. When it was Totterino's the food was delicious. Just tried Romano's pizza and I just didn't like it. The sauce had little flavor. The pie..."
Kathleen Peterson
"5 Stars for the pizza, I've been here a few times, gotten few different slices of pizza watch time and it's always been good. The slices are huge, a..."
Justin Britton
"Beatiful pizza every time. The crust is fabulous, and, they give you an 18" pie as a large. Used to be the old Leaning Tower of Pizza many years ago...."
Guy Cusimano
"Best pizzeria in the Mastic/Shirley area!! They’re always so courteous and understanding with our order by making sure they change their gloves and..."
Beenish S
"Great pizza. Great service. Great prices, could be better but definitely fair, and friendly staff. Good selection as..."
D.J. Zaba
"Best pizza in town ...hands down. Good price...sweet guys! Romanos is our favorite...even my family from NYC..."
Vida Garcia
"Formerly Toninos Pizza ,still great pizza, I prefer the calzones there made fresh and the way you like it ,not like some other pizza places who..."
Petra “Peach” Johnson
"Delicous food, great prices and friendly atmosphere. We have places closer to us but we'd rather go a little further to eat here, it's worth..."
Ang C.
"Excellent meatballs great pizza and very reasonable prices try it i gaurentee you won't be..."
Sylvia Ost
"I order a baked ziti dish and it was very good . It was a big portion and had enough for the next day . Would recommend this place..."
vinny P
"Good prices, amazing pizza. Uses fresh mushrooms. (Some places use..."
David Romero
"Haven't had pizza this good since Vito's left back in the..."
James Szakmary
"It was great service and pizza was awesome and I had to bring some..."
Kevin Cuzco
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use