Sluurpy
Reset

There are 14 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Smithtown

There are 14 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Sal's Ristorante & Bar
89/100 (402 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Lasagne
Eggplant
Calamari
Calamares
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Reservations
Takeout
Television
Seating
Accepts Mastercard
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Valet Parking
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Very relaxed atmosphere. Felt like family. My food was delicious (penne ala vodka). Cappuccino and cheesecake really hit the spot the top of the..."
Debby K
"If you want the best Italian food and the best service, you must go here. Everything is as fresh as could be and and the staff welcomes you and..."
Mike Grimaldi
"Great Italian restaurant. Walked in and greeted by friendly owner and seated right away. Waiter was so nice and attentive. Delicious food, nice..."
AClayton
"Went as a last minute choice on a Saturday night. We had no reservations, but they seated right away. The staff was very friendly and courteous. We..."
Kenneth Clayton
"Our first time at Sal's. We had a very pleasant unhurried dinner with five family members. The environment is comfortable and very pleasant. We had a..."
Roy Seher
"Visited Sal's for a midweek family luncheon. Nice antipastos to share, including zucchini and sausage, calamari, and a platter. Several choices for..."
Barney Simon
"This has been me and my girlfriends “spot” for almost 2 years now and the service and food is a 10/10. I highly would recommend this place to..."
James Caggino
"The food is freaking delicious and Sal and staff are very friendly and professional. My family been going here for years and never disappointed...."
Tony Catarelli
"This was my first time at this restaurant ... The food was great. And the service was quick. It has a nice quaint feel there. I will definitely..."
Debby Deb
"I love this place! The bread Caesar salad and Cajun pasta are amazing! I live in VA but when I visit my sister I always make sure we stop..."
diane m
"Great quality enjoyable food. Service..."
Stephen Wong
"If I could give you 6 stars, I would. My daughters baby shower was held at your restaurant yesterday. You made us feel like family. You wonderful..."
Judy Yevick
"I hosted my daughters bridal shower there. Food was delicious. Service was outstanding. Wish I could rate higher than 5 stars!! I Highly recommend..."
Margaret McDonnell-Tiberio
"Our first time going. It is truly a family owned restaurant. The food is absolutely delicious. Our waiter Tom (owner son) was so attentive, fun and..."
Cecile Mason
"Food was very good. Try multiple items. Lasagna. You will not be..."
Edward Drielak
"Went tonight for a nice family meal with 8 people. Everyone was very accommodating and wonderful. Our server Grace did an excellent job. The food was..."
Cassie Boulukos
"The restaurant is amazing. Well designed establishment with great food. Cheesecake is by far the best I think I’ve ever had and I travel for a..."
Colby Butler (Cheddar)
Ralph's Famous Italian Ices Of Smithtown
86/100 (400 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Waffle
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Açaí Na Tigela
Thick Milkshakes
Rainbow Sprinkles
Sour Cherry
Signature Sundaes
Marshmallow Cereal Shake
Birthday Cake Cookie Dough
Pack Ice Cream
Creme Ices
Shaved Ice
Ice Cream
Cookies and Cream with Strawberries
Blue Hawaii
nutella
Leprechaun Shake
Strawberry Cheesecake
Ice Cream Cake
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
Café
Italian
Parking Available
Free Wifi
Outdoor Seating
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Consistently good! Staff was working hard to service the line of waiting customers. Clean and well organized. A great value as well! So much to..."
JOSEPH P.
"I love this Place. 1st the staff is the nicest you will find. You walk in and everyone is always smiling even when its chaotic and busy and packed...."
michael malik
"I’ve never tasted your ice cream (yet) but I placed an online Uber order for my husband and I just wanna say thank you for making the note so cute..."
Mariana Gutierrez
"Of all the Ralph’s I like this one the most. The owner is very pleasant and the staff are friendly and efficient. They have a great special, buy..."
Jack Falzone
"Excellent selection and absolutely delicious. You're almost guaranteed to find a flavor you like. Ask for a sample if you're unsure. I can’t wait..."
George Schappert
"Ralph's Italian ices are one of the best places to go get ices or something cold to eat or..."
Dave Masone
"My husband and I live off these during the summer. Great service and taste..."
Jason
"Best Ralphs on Long Island. Clean store, friendly staff and the freshest..."
Kimberly Costigan
"Staff is courteous. Owners are always on site so the store is run like a well oiled..."
Julie Terrana
"i have been a consistent customer for a couple years now and specially go to this location due to the wonderful staff! my best friend and i always..."
jules d16monda@optonline.net
Casa Rustica Restaurant
86/100 (628 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Clams
Calamari
Tiramisú
Risotto
Cannoli
Calamares
Bruschetta
Pork
Jumbo Shrimps
Black Sea Bass
Australian Rack of Lamb
Pesto
Veal Chop Valdostana
Branzino In Crosta Di Sale
Fish
Shrimp
Capellini Con Gamberetti
Wine
Clams & Mussels
Bread
Oysters Rockefeller
Espresso Martini
Chicken Scarpiello
Fried calamari
Lobster
Lobster Risotto
Dessert Spaghetti
Pasta
Filet of Sole Whit Coliflor Pure
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Valet Parking
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
Fine Dining
"Moved from Smithtown to Florida a few years ago. Remembered how great Casa Rustica was over the years, and wanted to celebrate my husband’s 75th..."
Deborah Roth
"I haven’t been here in years. It was a great choice! Started with the perfect Martini. Excellent meal! I had the bruschetta and it was fresh and..."
Pat B
"Benny is a great host..Lobster flambe w/ brandy is fantastic.. they take all the meat out of the shell so you don't have to struggle ...Cappellini..."
PJ Cammarata
"A very high 4 rating, things are really here Osso bucko, off the charts, everything fell apart, Drinks were well made Good affordable wine..."
Brett Bar
"Went here yesterday for a business event and the food was delicious! Probably one of the best Italian restaurants I've ever went to. The place is..."
Eric Slone
"Great little spot. Went for lunch. Had a fantastic veal chop! I don’t eat lobster but people rave about it. Meatballs are on..."
Bill M
"Always a great experience, good food, good service and worth every..."
Derek Lave
"Food and service was very good. We would go back. Adele our waiter was..."
Dawn Golan
"What an unbelievable meal we had for a friends birthday, everything was delicious. We ordered appetizers, salads, entrees and desserts, everyone..."
Lorraine Rhodes
"if you like lobster? this is the only place on long island that i know its worth going to! great services, food and..."
Gappsi Giuseppe Abbrancati
"I have been going to Casa Rustica, for over 20 years. It is my Favorite local restaurant. I've have never been disappointed. Their Lobster dish, is..."
Gini Maurici
"One of the best Italian restaurants in Smithtown and the food is always..."
Dave Masone
"Catered birthday party (Saturday 2pm) for 20 guests worked out very..."
K Palatianos
"Cozy little spot with GREAT food. I enjoy a relaxing and slow paced meal just as much as the next person, but the service was a little to slow for..."
michael
"Casa Rustica never disappoints....excellent Italian good, great service and great atmosphere. Highly..."
Drewstamatic
"Food and atmosphere great, Rob the bartender..."
Gerri Cannistra
"Lovely little restaurant. Eat here on the..."
Clyde Holland
Ciro's Pizza
85/100 (1385 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Slice of Cheese Pizza
Penne alla Vodka
Garlic Knots 6
Grandma Pie
Slice of Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
White Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Pizza
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Amazing pizza, amazing value. 10$ for 2 slices this big and a..."
Ryan wootle
"I've been coming here for longer than I can recall. Always busy, but always a smile when I come in to order. Pizza is great, so it's the Chicken..."
Just_Angel B (Jesse)
"Classic LI Pizzeria! Been in business as long as i can remember. My favorite is the Sicilian. Good heros and dishes..."
Jim T
"You want good pizza? Come here because every single time I get pizza here it’s amazing! Dine in or take out it’s always just so GOOD and..."
Kitten
"Old school pizzeria how it should be, thin crispy and delicious. Reminds me of my childhood in Queens riding my bmx for a dollar slice. Only pizza..."
M Goode
"This place had great garlic knots but what I like the most was the slices of pizza. It has great sauce enough cheese and crust was crunchy they were..."
Ed Lo
"As a Chicagon I used to think Chicaho pizza is the ultimate pizza and I always used to make fun of "only cheese pizza", like cheese pizza is not..."
Liam Amiri
"Yes. Their sicilian is the best I have ever had. Sweet sauce, real cheese and a crust that is..."
Rob
"The absolute best NY Pizza on Long Island. I've been a loyal customer for over 35 years The Sicilian is the best I have ever eaten...anywhere. The..."
Tony LaVecchia
"I've lived in this area for over a decade now and I'm just trying Ciro's Pizza for the first time. Wow! When I walked into Ciro's there was a line..."
Dion Rupa
"By far, CONSISTENTLY, the best pizza on Long Island. Friendly staff and there is the convenience of home delivery also. LOVE..."
Marie Fristachi
"Outstanding old school pizza! For those of u gluten-free they have a good colliflower crusted..."
James Manikas
"Excellent grandma pizza! Found this place last minute fairly late at the night, and lucked out. Great..."
Amanda Kirkpatrick
"Excellent pizza. Great staff and..."
Rosario Panepinto
"I came all the way from Wyoming to eat Ciro's Pizza and I was not let down! It was the most amazing pizza I have ever had in my life. Cowboy hats off..."
Dusty Walker
La Famiglia
85/100 (948 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Calamares
Pesto
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Calamari
Sit down
Italian
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Food delicious. Atmosphere excellent. The staff a wee bit too much a$$ kissing for my liking. Giovanni, a true gentleman. Will definitely be going..."
ed
"Tonight I took my family out to dinner and we decided on trying La Famiglia and so glad we did. We just moved into the area and have tried a lot of..."
David Lopez
"Amazing! I came here for my birthday dinner today and everything was perfect! Danielle was our waitress and she was great! The food was delicious and..."
Lauren
"Was just here on Sunday and what an experience. I've nothing but good things about this place so we decided to try it. I can't say enough about the..."
Joao S
"One of my favorite restaurants! The food is always top-notch, the service is always spot on, they are clean and friendly. The owner John and manager..."
Nicole Rotondi
"Food was delicious, portions are huge ! Real authentic Italian restaurant Service was excellent!! Waitress was very pleasant and the owner was down..."
jose salguero
"We went here last night for dinner food was excellent. We had one problem we think he was the manager he came over to us and said hello and then said..."
Jennie Jorgensen
"We had an amazing dinner party for 18. The food was Exceptional, as was the service! My guests were so impressed! They put a lot of love into making..."
Rosemarie Pogoloff
"Large servings of tasty food were served! Real, traditional Italian eatery The service was outstanding! The owner was incredibly friendly and made..."
Athena Shaul
"Always the best food! Italian salad is my favorite thing on any menu! I could eat that salad everyday and never tire of it! It's that good! Owners/..."
Jerilyn Leonard
Butera's Restaurant Of Smithtown
84/100 (399 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Salad
Clams
Calamari
Risotto
Calamares
Hummus
Meatballs
Shrimp
Lasagne
Eggplant
Pasta
"We have been here quite a few times, it is always very good. They start you with a big bowl of great great and garlic knots, as well as delicious..."
Erin Grey
"Great Italian food awesome service and..."
Pete P.
"Went here for a bereavement dinner and the waiter was right. Food definitely helps during times of sorrow. Food was great, wait staff attentive and..."
C. F.
"The food here was excellent and came in large portions. You could easily share some dishes between two people. The wait staff were also some of the..."
Kovic Lansted
"Nothing bad to say about Butera's. Great Italian food at very reasonable prices - every dish I've ever had was really tasty. Bonus tip: you can..."
Matt Kaell
"Coming here is such a treat. The restaurant is beautiful inside, with a nice bar and ambient lighting. More importantly, the food is really good! My..."
Chelsea Brierton
"Some of the best tasting and well made food I have had on Long Island. Staff is friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable about their food as well as..."
Angelo M
"the food is always good, service is top notch too. it can get a bit noisy if there is a crowd. family style servings are generous but go with more..."
gary woods
"We had our rehearsal dinner at Butera's and it was such a wonderful event. Our room in the back was beautiful, the food, as always, was delicious,..."
Rachel Lupinacci
"Been to Butera's Smithtown 3 times. All 3 times were nothing less than phenomenal. The service was fast and efficient. Has a very family oriented..."
Chris Connor
"We had the special for dinner. The plate was huge and delicious. The waiter was very proactive. It was nice since we were there with 2 toddlers. Food..."
Val C
"Seemed a little pricy, but the food was..."
Casey Minter
"I meet friends I worked with before we all retired about 3 times/year. We go early(before 6:00pm during the week) to take advantage of their special..."
Sheila Mehanna
"Amazing food and service. The entire staff was accomadating to my parties allergy concerns and ensured we had a great dining experience. Highly..."
Steve Esposito
"Out favorite go to place! Delicious food, generous portions and friendly service. Never disappointed..."
Maria Colombo
Carrabba's Italian Grill
83/100 (1840 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Mussels
Salmon
Mama Mandola's Sicilian Chicken Soup
New Bread and Dipping Sauce Trio
Lasagne
Tomato Caprese with Fresh Burrata
Pesto
Fried Calamari with Marinara Sauce
Margarita
Four-Cheese & Sausage Stuffed Mushrooms
caesar salad
Blackberry Sangria
mozzarella sticks
Lobster ravioli
House Salad
Carrabba's Italian Classics
Espresso Shot
Tuscan-Grilled Sirloin
Shrimp & Scallop Linguine Alla Vodka
Shrimp
Chicken Marsala
Salmone Alla Griglia
Veal Marsala
Parmesan Truffle Fries
Pasta
Chicken Parmesan
Salad
Scallops
Sit down
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Eileen was a great server. Very on point and informative. She knew the menu well and was sooo friendly from the time we sat down. She made our visit..."
julien Braithaite
"Maylee was my server tonight and she was very sweet and helpful with our order.I was having a mother and daughter night and my daughter who is a..."
Jennifer Selletti
"I had taken my mother here for her birthday and had a great time. Staff was great and professional, great atmosphere, and great recommendations by..."
Jay Ososo
"Wonderful experience at this location. I know it's a chain but at this Long Island location, it's really more intimate and comfortable. The staff..."
John H
"If you're expecting an Italian restaurant with that Old school Italian feel this isn't the place. And not because it's lacking it, because I enjoyed..."
steven mattocks
"Alex was an excellent waiter. Had great knowledge of the menu and answered all of our questions and was quick with service and any requests we had...."
Edward Leto
"We had a great dinner. Great service, our server Marvin was very attentive and very knowledgeable about the menu and all the..."
Tyler Schneider
"We had Carleen and Abby as our servers! Absolutely great servers. I forgot to make a modification to my entree when they took our initial order and..."
K D
"My friend and I had a great dinner at Carrabba’s. Our waitress Amber was great, she checked on us to make sure we had what we needed and had really..."
Katiana
"Amazing service. Our waiter Derrek H was great, paced our apps, salad, meal. Very friendly and out going . Extremely pleased with the service. Food..."
Christina Hernandez
Three Bambinos
80/100 (131 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Great pizza crust, sauce and cheese. I have ordered once and it was delivered hot and fast. I really enjoyed..."
Tommaso Luca Sanna
"Dang good. I am never, ever, disappointed when having food from 3B's. My company often has their events catered by 3B's. Whether it's the pizzas,..."
Dennis Michael
"Fresh food, great selection of delicious stuff - indoor and outdoor seating, been here many times always..."
Pete Smits
"The pizza is absolutely delicious! Try the white..."
Zachary H
"Amazing food! Seriously, best pizza wings and subs..."
KoA Shorts
"Moved off Long Island and can’t get good pizza anywhere. Always go to bambino’s when back..."
Louisa Brennan
"OK Pizza but man is it thin !! Two slices of there pizza is equal to one real slice. And they charge 2.50 for this thin slice,, the most thin pizza I..."
David
"hands down best gluten free pizza around. Most places I am better off making a frozen one but this place delivers. They are incredibly helpful with..."
D M
"Friendly staff. I ate a white slice that was delicious also really liked the sesame seads they add all over the crust. Basic pizza place look and..."
Gabrielle Famighette
"Just ordered the hot wings, 2 greek salad wraps with chicken and the pasta with sun dried tomato and shrimp. Everything was excellent!! So good!..."
Lee Dallaglio
"Great service and conveniently located next to my daughters dance school. My wife places the order and let them know when you want to pick it up and..."
Danny Tom
"Great pizza! My personal favorite is the chicken cesar pie, it is the best salad pizza in the area. I also love the peperoni rolls. You can't go..."
James D
"My husband had food catered from here for my 30th and everything was delicious! I come from an Italian family and they were all impressed and had..."
Angela P
"Food is always great. I stopped in for ravioli and penne with chicken and broccoli. Both were excellent and delicious. They are always friendly and..."
Michael Gendron
"Love Three Bambino’s.. this is our favorite local pizza spot. There wings are amazing with so many flavors to choose from. I cater from them for..."
FearLess Gaming
"The food is absolutely delicious!! Patrick & the staff are very courteous & helpful. They always go above & beyond, thank you! We highly recommend..."
Joanne
Montes Pizzeria
79/100 (181 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
"Stopped in while visiting family on the island, in my old stomping grounds. Ordered a few Sicilian slices for a late night craving. Sicilian is my..."
Camaron Amarusso
"Monte’s catered a pre wedding dinner for me at a local hotel. I couldn’t have asked for a better experience. They were so easy to work with. The..."
Susan Wenner
"Great neighborhood local pizza place. Live close by and love the convenience. Food is good and prices you can't complain. Girls at the front counter..."
Jason
"Our go to for pizza delivery. Love their chicken..."
Fred Hamilton
"The pizza is excellent and the catering food was amazing. Thank you..."
Thomas Youllar
"What can I say? I went in on a Sunday to try the food since I am having a Big Party in July and can't say enough. First let me be the first to say..."
Jennifer Bruno
"Ordered pizza delivery and they were quick and great..."
Alissa Tocco
"We chose Montes to provide the food for our wedding celebration. The pricing was very reasonable and the food was absolutely amazing!!!! Everyone..."
Heather Troiano
"I used to work at equity next door to montes and when I tell you I ordered the feta salad with crispy chicken& basil balsamic dressing atleast once a..."
ashleyeverafter
"I had a coupon for montes, decided to use it. First and Best deep dish pizza I've ever had! Crispy crusty, with cheese and butter, perfect ..."
justin majeed
"I ordered a little of everything & it all was fantastic! My mother, the "pickiest eater ever" loved everything!!! I already knew Monte's cooks up..."
Christine Pisani
"Total home run! Good people that treat you right with good food that treats you better! If you have family and want to have a blast ask for the make..."
DANNY MATUZA
"I love Montes because it’s local and especially because they deliver to my job but the last experience I had there was less than desirable. My..."
amy c
"Excellent Quality food. Their personal pizzas are outstanding!!! One of the better pizzerias in Smithtown. Very unique pies..."
Frank DiMarco
"Just moved to the area and decided to stop in since I was starving and its right down the road, the girl at the counter was very nice and the food..."
Craig Evan
"I love coming here. The food is good. My only disappointment is as I am sitting here it is not busy(I am the only one here). 2 dine in customers left..."
Sandy Rasmussen
Don Jono's Pizzeria Restaurant
78/100 (1060 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Reservations
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Awesome staff and even better..."
C. Almond
"Don Jono's is my favorite pizza spot on the Island quality food and service. Always a great..."
Vladimir Salomon
"I order and they have it ready on time. The food is delicious and that chicken wrap/calzone thing is delicious..."
mary finchum
"Absolutely amazing food! Best pizza on Long..."
Colleen Costabile
"Never cease to fail.. I moved to Hauppauge from KP and I still refuse to go anywhere else. Authentic taste, TLC in every ingredient, and generous..."
Liz G
"All the pizza including the specialty slices are great. My favorite is grandma and chicken bacon ranch. The kitchen food, including heroes and..."
Frank Dominick
"Definitely your typical Long Island Pizza place with a very friendly staff...."
gold 818
"Great pizza with lots of..."
Joanne Agruso
"Great pizza and lovely, friendly staff that sometimes makes their own new creation (everything bagel crust deep dish 😍). Parking is super easy,..."
Mackenzie Rothschild
"I just received my order. I am so excited to say this will be my new go to pizzeria. Delivered hot crispy not drenched in oil. 9.2..."
Jonathan Ebel
"Great rice balls! I no longer work in the area but will definitely be taking a ride back for the rice..."
Christine Pisani
"I went there for the first time this week. Excellent pizza and garlic knots! Very friendly staff. I would definitely..."
Ryan
"Best pizza on Long Island hands down!!! Found this place by accident and I will now be a lifetime customer… the crust was perfectly crispy sauce..."
Kelly Muller
"First time ever going to this pizza place and I have nothing but positive things to say about it! Food was amazing and the customer service was..."
Jennifer Lippolis
"My favorite pizzeria! Delicious food and friendly employees. The BEST Buffalo Chicken Pizza..."
pam immendorfer
"They make a decent pie here, crust is good sauce is fine, they just don't understand what it means when you ask them for well-done. Well done is..."
john c
Bonappetito Pizzeria And Ristorante
78/100 (363 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Delivery
Takeout
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"First place I will always stop when I come to long Island.. so so yummy..I miss this pizza.. you should open one up in Florida..."
Lee anzelmo
"Food is very good, served fast and hot. The first time we ate here, there was only one server for a full house, and she seemed overwhelmed. My..."
Lewis Wasserman
"My go-to place for pizza! Friendly staff and pies are made fresh. Awesome specialty slices. My favorite is their BBQ chicken. Food from the kitchen..."
Lauren
"We needed a place for a Saturday night dinner for 41. It was for a family dinner the day before my son's wedding. Anthony worked out the details with..."
Michael Wofford
"This is our go to place for the best grilled chicken and broccoli rabe..."
Michael Petagna
"Now that's what i call a slice of pizza! Taste great and inexpensive too, can't wait to come back and try something..."
Anthony Alagona
"Came in to have dinner for my son's birthday. We had pizza. Food is always good here. Never a bad dish. We will be..."
Arlene Curcio
"Great pizza. Love Wednesday special. Dining in is excellent. The menu offers a nice variety. They are always accepting substitutions due to..."
Evelyn Martin
"Nice family place. Great service. Meals are large enough that you may have some to take home. Not overly crowded. Good house wine selection. ..."
Edward Drielak
"Nice place good food not really great for large..."
Davida Karabin
"I had a very nice lunch there with friends yesterday I think I've been there once many years ago . Very enjoyable .the salad was the best salad I..."
Lisa Biancospino
"I don’t know why this place doesn’t get more love as one of the best pizzas in the area. Great food at some of the best prices too. Great pizza,..."
Michael Corrado
"very close buy I used to work there years ago when it was Giordano's and had great pizza...1 bite everyone knows the rules! Lol and made great..."
Rob Robilotta
"Pizza is always good here. They have different varieties, some you never saw before. They are imaginative and it is usually very tasty. They are..."
Michael Gendron
Mannino Pizzeria
76/100 (1207 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pesto
Wine
Zambale
Chicken parmigiana
moscow mule
Cauliflower Oregenata
spinach
Octopus Salad
Shell Steak with Pittsburg Rub
Slice of Pizza
Mixed Greens Grilled Shrimp
Veal Marsala
Pasta Sample
Mozzarella Caprese
Garden Salad
Apple Cobbler
Filet Mignon
Corvina
Pasta
Pan Seared Red Snapper
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Salad
Mussels Bianco
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Television
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"LOVE THIS PLACE! best pizza, professional staff, exceptional service, great atmosphere, 20 year..."
Gunner Tierno
"And absolute Top Notch Italian dining experience. Great for lunch for dinner or anytime. The food portions are more than generous and absolutely..."
George Joseph - Photos by Josef
"Great pizza. The owner, Joe Mannino, is friendly, attentive, and focused on providing a great experience for everyone who walks in the door. The..."
Cameron Sipes
"Celebrated my son in laws 40th birthday here with my husband, kids and grandkids. First time there, but won't be our last. The baked clams were..."
Lilly Baird
"Staff was nice. Food was decent and chocolate lava cake dessert was delicious. Staff really attentive making sure you have a drink at all times. Also..."
Ryan Samuel
"Terrific slice. Just yummy. If you really wanna know how great the food is in a particular restaurant, ask for your main course sans salt. That's the..."
Debbie
"YUM!!!!! I think the best out of all their Manninos restaurants. Owner is real Nice a must stop when I head too Smithtown. His Oakdale food was good..."
Humpty Dumpty
"This is an excellent restaurant. A combination pizzeria and sit down restaurant with elements of fine dining. The food is excellent, and the..."
STEPHAN TCHORBAJIAN
"Great pizza for sure. Haven't had dinner here yet, but if the food is as good as the pizza, I'm betting on a great meal. Servers were great and..."
Theresa Mcleod
"Never had a chicken Parm pizza. Not..."
Christopher Chin
"Always a great time here. Service is phenomenal, food is fantastic A+ definitely a Must go to..."
David Lopez
"Reasonable price. Great slice. Great service. Also does vertical Stromboli slices wich is very interesting and..."
edmond kazella (EK7952)
"Excellent pizza in service,they have a huge selection of wine and a great menu for the restaurant. Definitely high-class pizzeria..."
Joel Monserrate
"Amazing food! Sauce is PERFECT!!! This business is not only offering delicious food but also friendly service. The owner generously donated to our..."
Kathy Sanacore
Buona Sera
73/100 (1113 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Pesto
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Solid traditional pie cooked well done as requested. Slightly grumpy counter service but no issues..."
Jason Nabel
"The cuisine is consistently excellent! There is a wide variety of options, so you can't go wrong. The wait staff is friendly and attentive and..."
Antonio Curry
"There is a wide selection on the menu, so you really can't go wrong. The wait staff is always kind and attentive, and the service is..."
Rosa Rose
"Come on out 2 Buona Sera out in Smithtown Long Island, am not a Long Island resident but have been here with a friend y we have very much enjoyed..."
Dan Stahl
"Outstanding meal. I've been many times for specialty pizzas which are delicious, but when I finally had a pasta dish I was extremely satisfied. I had..."
Jackson Bloomston
"Had delicious pizza and a rice ball. The rice ball was creamy and cooked well. Tasted great. I also had butternut squash soup. The flavor was..."
Dean Monitto
"There seems to be a lot of mixed reviews about this place. What I would suggest is definitely having a slice of pizza 😋 if your looking for..."
jayzin15 jayzin15
"We have been eating at Buona Sera for many years and the food is always delicious! The menu is extensive and you can’t go wrong with whatever you..."
Susan Star
"I've been ordering food from Buona Sera for the better part of a decade now and have always enjoyed their food. The over the counter food (pizza,..."
Dion Rupa
"HAS ANYONE HEARD THE MUSIC THEY PLAY OUTSIDE ON THE CEILING SPEAKERS?! I swear it sounded like the Italiam Beatles and got me stuck for a good five..."
Cornelius Castiglione
"Our favorite place for lunch. Great..."
Yari Ort
"Hadn't been here in a while since ownership changed several years back, and didn't even realize until the man behind the counter told me while I was..."
Michael Kahn
"Been here twice. Once just for pizza: enjoyed the Chicken Pesto & regular. Tonight we had dinner & I brought my appetite. Sicilian slice, buffalo..."
Joe Solimeno
Party Shoppe Gourmet Italian Ices
73/100 (55 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
"Creatively designed little 50s/60s shop set up for little birthday parties. With kids getting a chance to dance and make their own ice-cream..."
Onika Deane
"We recently had our daughter's birthday party at the Ice Cream Party Shoppe. Everything was handled perfectly! Alicia and the staff were all..."
Brian Cohen
"I can’t say enough good things about this amazing children’s party venue. The hostesses were AMAZING, they were enthusiastic, kind and took care..."
Courtney Kane
"They are awesome. Very accommodating and they did a great job, the..."
marie bellanca
"Attended a delightful Birthday Party for my Granddaughter. The associates are excellent and smoothly move the children from one activity to another..."
Roy Seher
"Cute place! The kids had a blast decorating their cupcakes and..."
Kim Hughes
"Our daughter had her 8th birthday party here and had a blast! Awesome staff and..."
Liam Davenport
"Parties are small and cute. Everything goes super quick though but we have been to two parties and both times the kids were happy at the end and said..."
Jacqueline Rowe
"We had an amazing time for my daughter's 4th bday. The games were appropriate for their age, and the hosts were on top of everything all the time. I..."
Val C
"We had my daughters 3 year old b-day party there and it was a big hit. Nothing crazy, no chaos. Nice for a change. The kids had a dance party..."
Alex Salkind
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use