The best restaurants are the small, out of the way, hole in the wall places that you find in any town in the world. This is one of those places.
I have been eating here as far back as I have been eating solid food. I grew up in South River and this was the pizza of choice. Their pizza is fantastic. It has a sweeter sauce and a thinner crust that makes it unique.
The absolute best pizza they make is the "ground sausage" pie. The sausage is ground up in the sauce under the cheese. The flavor is amazing.
To my knowledge the restaurant has changed hands twice since the original owner, Mr. Coffaro, opened. The quality and taste has never changed with successive owners.
I have always thought their delivery times were a bit long, usually a 45 to 60 minutes wait, so I have always picked up. Even as I moved out of South River, I still occasionally return because there is nothing like it.
One of the best pizzas around. The sauce is amazing, a bit sweet, which is what I like. The staff is very friendly. Family owned...which I think it is great to support small mom and pop shops and family owned places over big chains.
Only downfall is the place could use updating or sprucing up. The appearance could probably bother some people, but I let the food do the talking and the food is great. Anyone who rated 2 stars or less I do not trust their judgment
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes