The best Cheesesteak in Southampton | Sluurpy updated in June

Longhitano's Pizza

85/100 (405 ratings)

Restaurants

Vegetarian Friendly

Pizza

Italian

Pizza

Italian

Vegetarian Friendly

Dinner

Lunch

Shrimp

Meatball Sub

Personal Pizza

Italian Hoagie

Cheesesteak

Buffalo Wings

Calzone

Pizza Pie

Pepperoni Pizza

Cheesesteak Eggrolls

Pepperoni and Meatball Pizzas

Medium Meatball Pizza

Large Half Sausage Pizza

Sit down

Pizza

Italian

Takeout

Wheelchair Accessible

Delivery

Dinner

Lunch

Cheap Eats

"This place is the BEST! The greatest pizza in the area and the other items on the menu are equally as good. The parking could be better but the pizza..."

Sean Dwyer

"The pizza and stromboli are some of the best I've ever had in my life. And I eat pizza frequently all across the U.S. I think this type of pizza is..."

Tom Reichner

"The best pizza hands down. No other pizza like it. Mouth watering. A distinctive sauce that blends very well with the cheese that they use. Loved..."

John Q Customer

"I'm not really sure how, but Longhitanos has the best pizza. Best anywhere. It's crazy, lol... I've been eating there occasionally for over 20 years..."

David M

"The place inside is nothing special, but that doesn't matter it's usually those types of places you want to try, especially for some pizza!..."

John W

"I live in North Carolina but am from the area. Growing up I had never eaten Longitano's pizza. How unfortunate for me because it is delicious. ..."

Scott G

"Always a highlite of my trip back home going here. Excellent pizza, cheesesteaks and Stromboli. The only problem is I always want yo order all three..."

Scott Markloff

"Tues special takeout 2 pies. Added a salad and roll and butter. Delivered hot. Great old school taste. Remember the Ardsley location when I was in..."

maureen mcglade

"Great, respectful staff. We came with a large group unexpectedly and they were quick to accommodate. Pies came out fast, and taste great. Recommend..."

Rohun Sendhey

"Listen up, pizza enthusiasts! Allow me to share with you my thoughts on Longhitano's Pizza, a local establishment that has stood the test of..."

Debbi Kalstein

"Had my first slice of "LONGHI'S" pie when I was 7. I have set the inner pie standard on their mark back in the early days of my life - around 1968. ..."

Tom Johnson-Medland

"My favorite East Coast pizza! Eat-in for the best flavor in a very reasonably priced informal, low key little venue. Consistent flavor and quality..."

Ed Heebner

"This is a "Real deal" old school pizza shop. You know what it's gonna be like. You come in, the girl's gonna tell you to sit where you like, even..."

Jeff Rees

"Ordered here for the first time. Really impressed with the pizza nice sauce. Good prices during these..."

Brett Martin

"Had dinner here with friends and the food was great. Everyone enjoyed their..."

tony jagielski

"Been going here for years. They turn over their orders fairly quick. Always hot and ready to go! Friendly staff and their Pizza is unique and..."

Tom Hibbs

"Our favorite pizza place that we visit every time we’re in the area. My dad says it’s been this great since it..."

Henry The Collector

"Not sure if all your plain pies are like that but I got a personal pie at work was closest and best slice and sauce I ever had definitely top 5 ever..."

Reset

There are 3 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Cheesesteak in Southampton

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Jim “The Cheesesteak Guy” Pappas

Daniel Chen

Randi Pachella

Chelsea Lam

Nitro Gaming

Sean Dwyer

Tom Reichner

John Q Customer

David M

John W

Scott G

Scott Markloff

maureen mcglade

Rohun Sendhey

Debbi Kalstein

Tom Johnson-Medland

Ed Heebner

Jeff Rees

Brett Martin

tony jagielski

Tom Hibbs

Henry The Collector

CASH haynes

Anika Bacchus

Megan Gallagher

Ronald Dierkes

alice de sanctis

keith buntz

Jenna Zebrowski

Alicia Radick

The Local Guide

Neil Levinson

Hoppy's it's all bullshit

Sluurpy

Useful links