Sluurpy > Restaurants in Southold > Original Michelangelo Pizzeria & Restaurant

Original Michelangelo Pizzeria & Restaurant - Southold - Photo album

A pleasant dining room makes it a cut above the average pizzeria/restaurant. Generous portions from the menu.

Great Italian food restaurant worth visiting if you're heading out to eastern Long Island. Food and atmosphere are great, and never have any complaints about the dishes. Sometimes gets very busy so service can be a bit delayed, but if you're looking to relax and have a nice meal, this is the place.

The restaurant section is gorgeous! I had a little birthday dinner here to meet with my family and ordered a few pies. The white pie is delicious, along with the garlic knots! Definitely worth a stop, to-stay or to-go.

The interior of the building was nice. The waitress took a little long to get our orders. The calamari was really tender and the marinara sauces were perfectly made. The chicken parmesan was really good to. They also made extremely delicious bread rolls. The portion sizes are also exactly what I wan

I like this place a lot. The people there are friendly and actually very creative with their slices. Upside down Sicilian is really good. I didn't take a picture of that but should have! I've never eaten in the restaurant side. It does look very nice as well though so rest assured you would be comfo

Good clean pizza. Crust is nicely made never burned. Pasta was nicely sauced and flavorful. Friendly local fixture for consistent food. Prices are reasonable enough for locals to be regulars.

Stopped here for pizza and it was great. Lots of tasty options. Looks fancy from outside - because it is - but you can run in and grab slices like a regular pizza joint.

We have dine in this beautiful pizzeria. With a wide variety of vegetarian options to choose from. Must try coffee!!

Excellent, authentic NY pizza. The staff are regularly accommodating and the atmosphere is well designed.

Adorable little pizza place and restaurant! They have outdoor seating with a canopy and lights and inside is a pretty restaurant where you can order Italian food. We tried the pizza which was good, friendly service and a great selection of different pizza slices.