American cuisine: the best places to taste it in Southold

"We had the new England chowder and the special of the day- Lobster BLT. All freshly made with delicious seafood, and good quality beer. Great spot..."

isamar M. H.

Ifrah Crystal

"Cozy place with friendly, professional staff. Good coffee. Plenty of parking...."

moshix

"AMAZING coffee is to be found here. The cafe section is cozy, cute and quirky. The barista was very friendly and helpful. I think this is a great..."

Simon Tsang

"Best coffee in town. Hands down. Incredible service too. The most friendly staff but the coffee they serve is out of this world. They do have some..."

Phil P.

"The best coffee in the area. The baristas are friendly and professional. There is some seating inside but a lot more seating outside. It can get..."

Dan McNamara

"Delicious coffee, love The Bee Sting. Friendly service and nice outdoor seating. Pet..."

Ursula V

"Best coffee in the greater Hamptons area! And very cute garden/outdoor seating situation. Great pastries..."

Jennifer Ramirez

"The coffee is irresistible. When I take it to go the aroma fills my call with coffee Joy 😋 If you love coffee you’ll want to stop..."

George Andrinopoulos

Main Street Grill

"Wonderful, friendly and attentive service. The restaurant must have been renovated since many of the photos posted on Google were taken. It now looks..."

Simon Tsang

"Dropped in for a Sunday lunch, needing a handicap-accessible facility. Service was pleasant and efficient. I had the best Reuben I have ever eaten..."

Andrea Fernandes

"Perfectly poached eggs ( a rarity, I find), delicious real corned beef hash (try it here if all you've ever had was that stuff from a can), out..."

MD

"Always an excellent meal! Good home cooked food with fresh ingredients and awesome staff. We love it there and have been going for breakfast and..."

Theodore Schulz

"Typically food here is pretty good for what it is. Basically a breakfast and lunch place. I went there one Sunday and ordered a simple..."

yankeebean2000

"I often have clients meet with me on the weekends to look at vacation homes throughout the North Fork. My customers love to stop into Main Street..."

Jerry Cibulski

"Come here for a hearty breakfast or brunch. Service is friendly and quick, food is tasty and fairly priced. For these reasons I come back..."

Errol Arevalo

"Our go to breakfast place. We also caught their pop up dinner . Salads, steak and chicken dishes were delicious. Awesome staff..."

Chris Manfredi

"My favorite place to eat on the North Fork. Always pleasant staff, fantastic home cooked food, and great..."

Phyllis Montgomery

"Delicious .... went for dinner when there was a pop up dinner event and everything was just perfect ... just a bit of a wait but well worth..."

tim & vickie abrams

"We love it at this down-home place. The food is good; people are..."

J Ullman

"Great service, very good food, bringing the extra taste to dinner fare..."

Matthew T.

"Very good breakfast but closes early i think juat after..."

Chris Bany

"Always great, good food, terrific staff, always a..."

Larry Mannino

"Jenis is one of my favorite spots on the North Fork. A hidden..."

Rose Wallace

"Great service, great food I love this..."

Tony Goldense

"Friendly staff and delicious home style..."

Benjamin Hawkins

Erik's Breakfast & Lunch

Wheelchair Accessible

"I'm sure that many of you know about this place, but to me.....Erik's is a find on the North fork! A cute and cozy bistro style restaurant serving..."

Steven Tringali

"The food is incredible, I ordered the sweet potato veggie burger over greens. So delicious. The staff was very friendly and had great communication...."

Mary Montoya

"Busy summer Saturday morning, quick service, sat outside, great meal and very..."

Theodore Schulz

"Excellent breakfast. Unique offerings. Very friendly staff. Highly..."

Kittrick Danzeisen

"We had quite a variety of food. From the homemade soups to the amazing lunches. Everything was prepared with care and , as always, tasted ..."

Judy A

"Food was great. Portions were big,. Good stop during s bike..."

Troy Sessions

"My Favorite place to eat on the North Road. Excellent Food and Coffee. We've been going there since it..."

Joe Cusumano

"Just a great no frills place to grab breakfast or lunch. Portions are perfect and the food, while being deli fare, isn’t overly salty or processed...."

MK L.

"Always 5 Stars! I have never had a bad meal at Eriks. Always delicious. Iced tea is amazing. Fried clam strips are amazing. Sweet potato fries are..."

Joyce Grigionis

"Been by often but never stopped in. Have heard complimentary remarks from others. 5 stars because it is totally my kind of place. Very relaxed,..."

Clinton Terry

"Great food! Best breakfast I've had in a very very long time. Plus a very friendly chicken..."

Jonathan Garcia

"Food is delicious! Fried flounder sandwich was amazing. Fried mac & cheese nuggets so fun. Staff is extremely helpful and attentive. Really great...."

Matthew McDowell

"Erik's is an excellent upscale breakfast and lunch joint run by the always friendly and enthusiastic owner who inexplicably, seems to always be there..."

Mike K

"Found this place by accident while I was riding my motorcycle. Really friendly staff, fantastic food, and the prices are great !!!! Cafe type..."

Steven

"My favorite place to go for breakfast when heading out to Orient Beach. The hours during the summer are difficult to meet- they open at 11, and I'm..."

SHE ROW

"Super friendly staff! The owner is usually at the register and always has a smile on! Very comfortable atmosphere! Delicious burgers and meatloaf..."

Brittany Anne

"Love coming here for lunch and breakfast when out in wine country. Good place to mix with be the locals, generous portions and won't break the..."

Errol Arevalo

"Went here twice for breakfast, while staying in Greenport. Such an adorable little spot to have breakfast. Many options to choose from, generous..."

Pauline Esposito

"We came out East for the day and googled a nice spot for lunch, and thanks to other fellow raters we ended up at Erik's. Service: The man behind the..."

W Jae

Country Corner Cafe

New England Clam Chowder in a Bread Bowl

Egg White Omelet with Home Fries and Toast

Croissant French Toast with Berries

Grilled Cheese & Fries

Country Corner Omelet

Pancakes

Avocado and Chicken Salad over Greens

Free off-street parking

Non-smoking restaurants

Accepts American Express

Table Service

Wheelchair Accessible

"Fantastic food at great prices! Wide menu variety with cute, cozy atmosphere and fast service. The corned beef hash was especially noteworthy. Great..."

Sarah W

"Cute little place in the heart of Southold. Food was delicious and service was top notch. Only complaint that I have is the booths are just a little..."

Nick Renna

"So.... we went to breakfast the two days we stayed and it was so amazing. The service.. the atmosphere and the food. I had the best home fries..."

Shavon Anderson

"Excellent and I mean EXCELLENT ice cream and their shakes are unbeatable! I usually get two hot dogs with kraut and fries. I wish they made homemade..."

chris surdow

"Lovely atmosphere. Service was fast and the waitress was kind. Well priced items. The “All-American Panini” was delicious. So was the Roast Beef..."

steven georgiadis

"Really nice restaurant, the food is really delicious, and very attentive service. I will definitely go..."

Rodolfo Nunez

"We came upon this delightful spot on our way back from visiting Orient point. The food was great, service was impeccable, we think the servers were..."

Jai Rayan

"Awesome place... Food came out fast, correct and hot! My son had the BBQ bacon Burger and said it was the best he's ever had!!! Great spot to eat!..."

ken johnson

"We absolutely loved this restaurant! The atmosphere, the food and service was wonderful. Our food was cooked exactly as requested and was hot, fresh..."

amanda eagleston

"Come here all the time when I’m back home with the fam. Have never had a bad experience. Food is great, coffee is even better, and real small town..."

Ian

"On vacations from France in the North Fork, we had lunch today at this very pleasant restaurant : although it was full, the staff managed to seat us..."

Matthieu CHATIN

"Challah French Toast with a side of corned beef hash was an amazing breakfast. Order selection is great..."

Donald George

"Excellent would highly recommend. Excellent service staff so nice. Atmosphere so comfortable. Food 5 ***** Immaculate! Love the decor so pretty. ..."

Margaret Hooks

"Had a wonderful lunch here today. Family loved it as well. Friendly staff. Quick service. Excellent food. What else can you ask..."

Eric Kisel

"What a gem on the North Fork. Great food and the waitress we had , Danielle was outstanding as were the young man..."

Joan Huber

"Great sandwiches. Fun luncheonette environment. Cheerful staff. Good selection of Hershey's Ice Cream. Serves breakfast. So..."

Tom Reese

Sophie's Rest

"Was there today for a Bridal shower. First time there. Everyone that was working there was very friendly and nice.. The food was excellent. Would..."

Carol Niewadomski

"Love this place! The garlic parm chicken wings are awesome! My new..."

Karen Szczotka

"Love the stuffies and thin crust pizza. Would highly recommend the stop when in the..."

Brian J. Becker

"I love Sophies....especially prime rib Tuesdays. Our waitress was awesome last..."

Jennifer Moore Giovanniello-Becker

"Welcoming atmosphere, fantastic staff, great..."

Martha Brandt

"Great people and the appetizers I had were really..."

Carol Price

"Great place to eat and have fun... delicious food.. the people are..."

Mel Roman

"Love this place ! Down home fun and staff is great ! Esp Billy the bartender . Food is always fresh and beers so cold..."

Carylanne Bodo Bais

"Dinner tonight at Sophie's, hubby had a great pizza and I had a delicious Thai Chili Cheeseburger...yummy! And the staff was friendly and..."

Anne Doherty Bialeski

"Best place in town. Only pool tables around which is a definite..."

Lucas Natali

"Me & 2 of my friends went to Sophie's to eat for the 1st time Aug 12th after hearing how great the prime rib dinner was. It was Excellent!!!!!! The..."

Mary Zurek Manwaring

"Loved the pizza! Like the bar, everyone is really..."

Joanne Gould

"Awesome food great staff and prices are very..."

Kimberly Charity Tortorella

"My friend and I came for dinner to catch up, we had a table on the front porch, it was a quiet atmosphere. Not too loud like some restaurants can be...."

JR Arceri

"Very tasty food. Shared the scallop quesadilla, which was very good, and then we grabbed a burger, which was also tasty. Would def return. The place..."

SurfratNY

"Attended a private event here. This is my parents’ favorite place. Very friendly and great..."

Kristin Torkelsen

"One of the best LOCAL bars on the North Fork. Leave your South Fork attitude at the door. Food and staff are the..."

Breton Gross

"Nice comfort food. Packed with locals. Comfortable and..."

Stephen Wong

"Sophie's is great. Seafood Stuffies are our favorite appetizer. Other dishes are great too. The fish is always..."

Steve Amiaga

"Nice lively place, had the pizza it was..."

Sandra Lee Geitz

"15/10 best place on the east..."

Aaron Donner

"See my review of Boutique Barber shop, which was meant to review Sophie's. Can't figure out how it happened or how to correct..."

Sayward Mazur

"Went to Sophie's today for lunch. First time there, but it definitely won't be the last. We started with an app special (shrimp spring rolls) which..."

Sarah Preston Britto

O'mally's

"It was a nice Irish spot. Nice staff and nice decor. Really good quality food. It was a bit empty for a Saturday night but it was still good to visit..."

Will Johns

"Nice meals, hefty portions, nice service, unfortunately the inside dining capacity is limited, so calling ahead to see how many people are waiting..."

Steve Amiaga

"A nice eatery with a variety of burgers, pasta, fish, ribs, etc. The service was good, food was fresh and the prices are..."

S7

"One of my favorite places for food out east. Hands down the best burgers on the north fork. (And I'll admit there are other excellent burgers in..."

Jim Gabriel

"My family and I enjoyed a Sunday lunch at O'Mallys. The steak I had was excellent along with sides of veggies. Good value for the price. Nice..."

Eric Kisel

"Great food. Hearty servings. Friendly staff. Very reasonable prices. Stumbled across this place after coming back on the 5 pm ferry from Connecticut...."

Vincent Ventura

"Definitely one of the best burgers I've had. The decor was nice and calming, a very clean establishment. The wait staff was very courteous and..."

Karim Bandealy

"Quiet little place to grab some food. The restaurant is clean and well decorated. When we were there the staff was not busy so they were cleaning..."

Jenni Bandealy

"Ok, so I didn't like the changeover, and wasn't happy when the Tiffany style lamps were replaced with a cooler, more modern, decor, but the staff is..."

Don Blydenburgh

"Great burgers and pretty huge portions. The service was really good. This place has been here a long time. You can enter the parking lot from east or..."

Steven DAmico

"Great food! Great service! Great atmosphere! Reasonable..."

Richard Tom

"Good food, moderately priced, a burgers and stakes place, kind of out in the middle of nowhere. Family atmosphere, quiet, but I've only gone during..."

Lew Bly

"Very solid spot. Don't be fooled by the name. Although they offer lots of American cuisine including a killer burger selection, Greek owner Steve..."

Bart Badalucco

Rotisserie Smokehouse

Wheelchair Accessible

"Good food and very reasonably..."

Michael Singles

"This is the best Mexican Steak in the North Fork - it is done with taste and you get the authentic feel. A Flavorful Delight at Rotisserie Smokehouse..."

Pedro Rodriguez

"This place is ran by my 4 uncles! Best food for a rotisserie, since they are of Mexican descent, on holidays and sometimes on rare occasions my aunts..."

José Azrael

"Had the half chicken and ribs combo with mashed potatoes and cream of spinach plenty for two people absolutely delicious all of it very economically..."

Mark Osmer

"Excellent food and service. Right on time, warm, well done, and..."

Miguel Angel

"I have been eating at the Rotisserie for nearly ten years. BEST burritos. The comfort food is also delicious. A family favorite. Great staff. I eat..."

William Rue.

"Awesome food, a super friendly staff, and affordable prices. One of my favorite places to sit down and eat or take out. Love..."

Eric C. Tonyes

"This place is the best! Great Mexican food. Super friendly and great service! We have lunch at least 2 times a week..."

Lisa Schoenstein

"Lovely the food!! The staff is dynamite!! They know what I want as soon as I walk in! They're chicken is unmatched. I always order the chicken with..."

Carlene Hardnett

"Great service &..."

Kyle Schwartz

"Food us amazing its great taste good for your bottom dollar highly..."

Angelo's Taxi never a dull moment

"Great food, huge portions, staff was super friendly, horchata is delicious and the prices cannot be..."

Crys

"My favorite Mexican/chicken restaurant! Been eating here for over 15 years and the only disappointment is not ordering..."

Colin McCarthy

"The food is delicious and the employees are super..."

Kevin M

"Great food. Great for take..."

Seymour Brooks

"Everyone there was super friendly and the food was and still is..."

Varen756

"Good food, reasonable prices. Nice..."

David Hill

"Great fresh tacos and chicken!!! Staff is always..."

Sheila Morreale

"Staff is friendly, all food is..."

Ben Fake

Wednesday's Table

Wheelchair Accessible

"Very delicious food and they serve gluten free! I ordered a gluten free grilled cheese with goat cheese, bacon and dates. My boyfriend said the banh..."

Emily Schiller

"Wednesday’s Table has, hands down, some of the best tasting food in the North Fork. You can’t go wrong with anything on the menu. It’s all..."

Trista Sordillo

"Nice little sandwich shop. Their Bahn Mi hero was pretty good. Supposedly their largest seller. Roasted pork with Daikon radish and a siracha sauce..."

M Scotto

"Stumbled upon this place and was pleasantly surprised. We had the Banh Mi and the falafel, both of which are excellent. The seating area leaves..."

Laura Beech

"I don't give 5 stars easily. My perfect sandwich has a balance of nutrition ingredients locally sourced, and flavor ingredients on thin, good fresh..."

Captain Dancypants

"Best sandwiches youve never had! Very creative! Coffee is fantastic! (Try the Peru). Staff is so sweet and helpful. Chef (yes, chef) knows her craft..."

Don Blydenburgh

"I love Wednesday’s Table! Excellent quality whether you’re coming for breakfast or lunch, and their coffee is amazing too! Such a welcoming..."

Katie G

"Our burgers and fries were very good, and the girls at the counter were nice too. Selection isn't huge but the food was good. The dining area also..."

Danny Levy

"Food was delicious and they have Brooklyn Roasting coffee as well as gluten free..."

Philip Traversa

"The most delicious food on North Fork. Breakfast and lunch sandwiches are fantastic as are the soups. Super friendly and professional. Highly..."

William Rue.

"One of the best Bahn mi anywhere! The rest of the food coming out looked great as well. Looking forward to trying..."

John Consoli

"Baja fish tacos are amazing! Fresh fish, tortillas, pickle onion, crazy fresh homemade salsa and a very friendly staff all add up to an amazing..."

chris surdow

"Such a happy place! Great atmosphere with a super tasty menu of items to take to the beaches, boating or Southold Town hiking trails. Perfectly..."

Jerry Cibulski

"This place is absolutely delicious. I don't often give 5 stars but this place certainly desrves it. Everything on the menu is done with perfection...."

Michael Z

"We absolutely LOVE Wednesday's Table! Lin and her staff are attentive and professional. The food is simply delicious! We keep telling people about WT..."

Jeannie Malone

"Very delicious, got the eggplant caprese sandwich, it was amazing! Will be back for..."

Liz Ashby

"This place has really different and creative dishes. They take traditional comfort food like peanut butter and jelly and grilled cheese and put these..."

Grant 1555

Founders Tavern

"The food is delicious. The menu is varied. They accommodate my vegan diet. The service rates 5 star most of the time. Great value. In season we try..."

Lynn Zinn

"This is our go to whenever we come to Southold for the season and even during the fall/winter. The food doesn’t disappoint, the cocktails are..."

Geo P

"Came in for drinks and to watch the Belmont stakes. Great bartender & friendly crowd. Didn't have food, but dining room was full and everything we..."

Robert Conway

"LOVE this place. the staff is so attentive and friendly. the food is always fresh and delicious and great selection of local..."

Jessica Gelbwaks

"Cozy little place for dinner with the family. Kids and such welcome. Bar separated from dinning area. Service get a little..."

Matthew Carragher

"Don't let the name fool you. This is GOOD food, not bar food. Our mostly church group of 10+ came together for first time in long while to break..."

Emanuel Psaltakis (Manny)

"😘😘😘😘😘😘Just try it !!!! I am in ❤️L❤️O❤️V❤️E❤️ Oooooohhhhh this Ice cream makesme..."

Alina McNelson

"I heard the food is excellent I didn't have time. I will definitely stop in again for a nice lunch. The daytime bartender..."

Scott Nietupski

"I started with boneless wings and to be quite honest, they shouldn't even be on the menu. Picture having chicken nuggets with buffalo sauce on them..."

Mark Norton

"Great food - tavern mixed with family dining atmosphere. Filet mignon steak tips with horseradish are a favorite, but everything on the menu is..."

Sean ELIK

"The onion rings were delicious, as was the BBQ pulled pork sandwich I had. I was there with a party of seven and we all really enjoyed our meals and..."

Emily C-G

"Excellent consistent dining experience. Our server Sharmane was very professional and attentive to our table of 8. What makes this place so special..."

Harvey Passes

"Enjoyed this restaurant had a fireplace going and food was very good. Atmosphere warm and friendly will definitely go back when I..."

Ruby Gambers

"Excellent food and service. very friendly staff. I go there every time I'm in the..."

Michael OMalley

"Bartender Mike was great! He was VERY busy yet still got everybody what they needed! He suggested we try the seafood special which was awesome and we..."

Candace Howell

"Food was pretty good. It can get crowded at times. If you dont want to wait make sure to make a reservation. Unfortunately our appetizers came out..."

Andrew F

Elbow East

Wheelchair Accessible

"Went here for the first time for my fiance's birthday...Everything was soooo yummy 😋 I would definitely recommend and I will be going back soon..."

Shauna Innamorata

"We were in the area to visit wineries and stay o er night. Many places closed early b/c of Covid but we found this little spot, perfect for the..."

Brette Grice

"Judy our waitress is fabulous! We get her most times that we come here. Food is all ways delicious! Clams casino was..."

Candace Howell

"Excellent! We had the prime rib special. Marinade was delicious. My wife had it without Marinade and it was also delicious. Cooked perfectly. The ..."

Warren Jensen

"I have been to the Elbow room many times. My most recent visit I ordered the Porter house, marinated. The steak was cooked to perfection. It's quite..."

Jim Capelluto

"Great service and amazingly tasty food. Haven't had a good seafood meal in awhile. The surf n turf and broiled seafood platters were beyond..."

Annie Portente

"We visit this place (coming from Nassau county) at least once a year. The decor is nothing fancy, just comfortable, like your grandmothers house. The..."

Jaclyn Rauchfuss

"Everything about this evenings meal was superb! Filet mignon cooked perfectly as asked, lobster tail tender and moist, and the homemade dessert..."

Ricki Herman

"One of my favorite East End establishments. A celebrated escape from the newer, trendy eateries springing up across the North Fork. Old-fashioned in..."

Chas Carlson

"We never have had a bad meal or service. We enjoy changing it up, burgers are good, onion rings, lobster dinner or the filled. We love the steak..."

Jim B

"Elbow East offers a great local North Fork dining experience. Great steakhouse/pub style menu with seafood specials sure to please everyone. It's off..."

Judy McCleery

"Had a fantastic scallop special tonight. Always happy to sit at the bar on Friday and catch up with Heather. She is not only a great bartender she is..."

Ali Behr

Dunkin'

Chocolate Coconut Donut

Wheelchair Accessible

Cheap Eats

"This Dunkin is always clean. I’d say they are very fast too. Some employees aren’t as fast as others and still the rush hour times but they move..."

C. F.

"Our favorite fast breakfast to go on the way to the Orient point ferry. The best coffee..."

Jerry Harrison

"Great staff here! Always nice and accommodating. Consistent service always delivered with a Hello and a..."

Hillary Hulteen

"Best service of my life, the manager was absolutely AMAZING. I believe his name is Ashok. I didn't go to Dunkin a lot before but now I will go..."

Virat Kohli

"The service wasn't that good, the kid seems tired, but our coffees were..."

Nancy Duke

"That’s good to see something familiar so far from everything . Good authentic interior and exterior. Recommend! P.s. They still serve the pumpkin..."

Sasha Larchenko

"Clean store and fast..."

Mike Tin

"Good customer service. Helps that the guy speaks English and Spanish for some of the people that cant communucate in the language all the..."

Damian Benitez

"I love it everyone is always friendly even the manager fast service very..."

rose Mencos

"Small but..."

patrick healy

"Very nice and clean I like the..."

Ashok Prajapati

"Friendly service.Stands out as the best Dunkin', that I've ever..."

Jeremy Medalie

"Great donuts, good coffee, fine..."

Reset

There are 16 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

American cuisine: the best places to taste it in Southold

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Elliot Hoare

M Scotto

Arthur Glauberman

Valentino B Borrelli Jr.

Lauren Beale

Theo Heinz

steven georgiadis

Udo Wahn

Mike Weiner

Liz D

Millie Kwan

Matt Beriloff

Christen Schade

Peconic Boat Rental Koch

Howard Gould

Ahmad Ali

Eric Ganko

Michele Pacheco

Brett Sherman

Donna Weinstein

Zachary Dennett

Matthew Mendell

William Gambling

Kristina Farmer

Henry “Henry” L

sara leone

Ron Breuer

Danny Levy

Jane Marlowe

Len Van Vliet

Rob&Kim Clark

Chris Manfredi

Oscar Velazquez

Mike Kettenbeil

Phyllis Montgomery

Tennis Lover

Diane Peterson

Janet Bellezza

Wayne Laedke

Laurel Sisson

Richard Flannery

Charlie Bournis

Tony Goldense

Kate Terry

monte hersh

harold house

Daniel Sperling

Noah Levine

A Lam

Kyle R

D BC

Michael Rosenthal

Loreta Moser

Robin Yeldell

Kathy Pasquale

Dr. Patricia Kolodnicki

Carly Weil

Erica

Emanuel Psaltakis (Manny)

Bret Berglund

Tom M

Tracie Thomson

Katrina

Thorin Teak

Arthur Glauberman

Margo Zoromski

Simon Tsang

Holly Lavender