Sluurpy
Reset

There are 12 restaurants

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Spring Lake

There are 12 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Larimar
93/100 (345 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Contemporary
Gluten Free Options
Italian
European
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Shrimp
Pasta
Salad
Scallops
Oyster
Salmon
"Very memorable lunch experience here this summer. Service was very attentive (BYOB, we brought some Prosecco) and each dish had some kind of..."
CMQ
"The best pasta I had. I was tempted to go to the kitchen and ask for the recipe. Would recommend for anyone visiting the area or a local to give this..."
J B
"My wife and I have eaten here many times and the food and service are always spectacular. I also travel for business and am fortunate to be able to..."
fred rozell
"A cut above other fine dining restaurants we've been to. The food was imaginatively prepared, beautifully plated and delicious. The service was also..."
James Caporrino
"just felt like a cheesecake - while a small slice, it was the most perfect "bite" - can't wait to try their entrees for take out. Staff was very..."
Nancy Nakovick
"My wife and I went to Larimar for the first time last night (belated Valentine's Day dinner). It was wonderful! The wait staff, ambiance and the..."
hank asher
"Excellent. Not only was the food spectacular (the Statler chicken was perfection), the service was unparalleled. Kind, proactive, and especially..."
Clara de Soto
"Had dinner with some family members last night. Food was absolutely amazing! Beef tartare appetizer, all the pastas, and the Filet Wellington were..."
Edward Henderson
"This small but elegant restaurant was wonderful. I wish we'd called for a reservation, but we were seated near the bar and chose from the full menu...."
Amy Toman
"Our first time here and we celebrated our 30th anniversary. Food was delicious! Service was great! Love that we were not rushed between courses. ..."
Rick Canonaco
Naples Pizzeria
90/100 (628 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Really great food! Their vodka sauce is out of this world and the pizza is..."
Stephanie Giardina
"I’ve lived in jersey my whole life had all the best pizza here and all the surrounding states and this is easily my favorite pizza place. Excellent..."
matt
"Great pizza. Quality ingredients and super friendly staff. Take out is always ready when they say it will be. Highly..."
Sean Duggan
"Stopped by from out of town. Enjoyed some plain slices of pizza. The taste was excellent with a nice light crunch with each bite. I will definitely..."
Mr. Green
"The pizza is good and priced fairly. But I don't go here for the pizza. I come for the Cold Subs. They use Boars Head meats and still keep the prices..."
John Smith
"Under new management and always a wonderful experience! The dinner entrees, salads, pizzas, and soups are all top quality. The prices are very..."
Mark Gechtberg
"Fantastic experience all around! Great shop with friendly service and delicious food. I tried one of the cold subs and it was one of the best subs..."
Erick Flaten
"Food was fresh and hot!!! Bread was amazing salad was crisp and clean! Only bad comment is the Alfredo was a bit bland for my personal taste nothing..."
Preppy Rocker
"Very impressed so far with everything about the new owners. Pizza is perfect. Not too thin/thick. Sauce tastes homemade. Delivery took awhile but..."
Ron Milkowski
"Pizza here is delicious and well worth the price. We ordered the chicken bacon ranch and the white pizza with spinach and both were great (and..."
Athanasius Sirilla
Spring Lake Pizzeria
88/100 (550 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sandwiches
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Highchairs Available
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Street Parking
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Came to this pizzeria for the first time today! My family and I had a wonderful experience. Staff is friendly, great atmosphere and the food was..."
Molly Lamenia
"I recently had the pleasure of visiting Spring Lake Pizzeria and I have to say that it definitely lived up to its reputation. From the moment I..."
Jack Chinery
"Came by with my husband and friends for dinner on Saturday during Fourth of July weekend - we had an amazing time. The place was packed and the..."
Kathleen O’Rourke
"today was my 4th time eating at Spring Lake Pizza and every time just gets better and better. The margarita pizza is my fave but the buffalo wings,..."
lori donnelly
"We love this pizzeria. Great service fantastic food. Every time we come to Spring Lake is a must. Usually we get pizza, but this year we try their..."
Simona Chenault
"Very pleasantly surprised. Service was quick. The girl was smiling all the time and was very polite. The food was delicious and the dessert as well...."
Elena Kostovska
"My girlfriend and I ordered a Large Half Mushroom/ Half Pepperoni pie and a small house salad to go. Before I left, I asked the workers twice(2..."
Marvin Cruz
"This place is lovely and wonderful, and the owner, Barry could not have been kinder. After a day at the beach, my wife and I and our good friends..."
Jeffrey A
"Every time we visit Spring Lake, we always come to Spring Lake Pizzeria. The pizza is crunchy and delicious, and the Buffalo wings are must have. The..."
Janice Lam
"Slow and not very attentive service, but everyone was friendly and wonderful pizza. I give them 2 stars for service, but 5 for the taste and quality..."
Lina Lazova
"To start the service by George was top notch. The owner stopped by our table to ensure the service was 100%. Also may I add my kids are very picky..."
Jason Rush
"The service is unparalleled, the food is outstanding, and the atmosphere is more than welcoming. Spring lake pizzeria is hands down one of the best..."
Christian Chinery
"We love Spring Lake Pizzeria for more than the pizza! Don't let the quaint pizzeria-look store-front deceive you, they have a full Italian menu. Favs..."
stephanie bricken
"We love the margarita pizza 🍕 It’s definitely the best with a perfect crispy , slightly sweet dough, a tasty bursting tomato sauce and the..."
jill Harary
"Don’t miss SL pizzeria if you are in/near Spring Lake! Joe the waiter was amazing- rec’d a specialty pizza w Hot honey- it was fantastic...."
Sarah Cannova
"Pizza was excellent, staff was great, even had pizza toys for the kids. What a great place. We will be..."
Joseph Welfel
Two Tonys Italian Kitchen & Wine Bar
86/100 (1051 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Alfredo
Meatballs
Lasagne
Shrimp
Osso Buco
Pesto
Ossobuco
Pasta
Salad
Scallops
Risotto
Salmon
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Accepts Visa
Serves Alcohol
Private Dining
Wine and Beer
Accepts American Express
Gift Cards Available
Accepts Discover
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Reservations
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Outdoor Seating
Seating
Takeout
Table Service
Television
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Mastercard
Dinner
Mid-range
"We booked the private room to throw my in-laws a surprise 50th anniversary party. Everything from the initial consultation to the final bill was..."
Jessica Pipe
"Our first time stopping by was last night. Food was really good. This may sound odd but I loved the house salad that came with my meal. I could have..."
Tom Frens
"Food was wonderful, veal parmigiana was fabulous! Be aware that when they tell you about their “specials” you need to ask for the price before..."
Melanie Kirkland
"I love this place. I now have to drive 17 hours to get here, but I come back for the lasagna every time I make it to Michigan. The atmosphere and..."
John VandenBerg
"Amazing food! If you want a mouth watering steak this is the place to..."
Jackie Johnson
"We had a lovely visit to celebrate our 40th birthdays! The atmosphere was cozy and relaxing. The food was amazing! Will visit again on our next..."
Nancy Heggie Kramer Withak
"This was our first time at Two Tony's and will not be our last. The food was delicious, everything from the appetizer to our main dishes. We will..."
Wanda Jackson-Kadlec
"Everything is always fresh and delicious I have never gone away hungry or disappointed my favorite western side of the state..."
Greg Lamming
"The Nashville yardbird sandwich was great. The truffle fries were a little too salty but still good. This is the best experience we’ve had here in..."
Carrie Carlson
"Great restaurant for indoor or outdoor dining. Their brussel sprouts were delicious and their pizza and chicken sandwich was on point. Kyle was our..."
R S
"Had a great experience here. All of the food I tried was delicious, and their menu had a variety of options for different palates. It’s definitely..."
Liam Jernudd
"WONDERFUL EXPERIENCE! My family recently visited the area for vacation last month. Finding tasty local restaurants is one our favorite things. We..."
Erin Bacher
"Last week was our first visit to Two Tonys, as we live out of town. Went there to celebrate a 50th anniversary and we were not disappointed. The..."
Carole Schmitt
"The food is great and looks very nice. The service is good but could be better. Food - 5 stars, Service 3 stars, atmosphere 4 stars, Total 4..."
John Russcher
"My husband and I sat at the bar. The service was great and my husband liked his food. I didn't particularly care for my bistro steak, but they made..."
Kristen Wilkinson
"Nice place for a group dinner. The restaurant is dimly lit with a few candles for ambiance. Large portions as you would expect from Italian American..."
Ashley Mo
"The meals were delicious. I had the brussel sprouts appetizer and the tortellini con pollo and while I couldn't finish my main I really wish I could..."
Marshae Sun
"Nice ambience. Great for romantic dining or group dinner. There's a nice bar if you need to wait for a table. Spaghetti Meatball & Shrimp Scampi..."
Lilian Sng
Joseph's Delicatessen
86/100 (285 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Lunch
Breakfast
Italian
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
Cheap Eats
"Had a sandwich at Joe's for the first time today, my loss (should have eaten there sooner). One of the best sandwiches I have ever eaten. Part of..."
Chris Campione
"This is by far the best Deli in NJ. When we visit family , this is the first place we go to for..."
Charlie Simons
"The..."
Bill Holt
"Best subs..."
Jennifer Moe DeConie
"Best deli in..."
Liz Louhier Martin
"best sandwiches especially made by holly shes the best sandwich maker..."
Joan Gatti
"This deli was a block from where we stayed in NJ. Great food, friendly people. Crumb cake was outstanding! Thanks for making a full pan for my..."
Sonia Carmer Ackley
"AWESOME - the #10 is a must..."
Ben Sisti
"Heerlijk eten en hele lieve..."
Sonja Schenderling
"Best Roast Beast Sammy's..."
Erin Murray Hunt
"The best deli in the area. Sandwiches are hefty with Boar Heads meat on delicious fresh baked bread. I would also recommend any of the specialty..."
Bearkaty15
"Yesterday we enjoyed a stress free Thanksgiving meal. We ordered everything from Joes Deli and it was all delicious. Turkey, gravy, dressing,..."
Kathleen Corbeels
"Ture Delicatessen. Owner is Italian and can speak it, even teaches customers words while in the place. Family owned and operated. Fresh fresh fresh!..."
Steven Stratton
"Fabulous deli. Sandwiches are awesome! Been the same for the last 25 years since I’ve been going there! Highly..."
Nancy Royer
"I have been eating here for the past 20 years. This is my all time favorite sandwich spot! The mozzarella is to die for. I don't even live in the..."
Morgan Campbell
"A+ 10/10 5 stars all around, high quality, old school jersey deli feel, great people, other places should take..."
Matt P
"Doing business with Joe and his family for years. Live in Long Branch and make the trip down to Spring Lake just for one of his sandwiches. Like..."
William Vitaliano
"NEVER had a bad sandwich been going there for decades! Great Italian products and prepared frozen dishes...u gotta go!! Fabulous..."
Margo Desantis
"My whole office ordered lunch. Some of the best sandwiches we've ever had. Great authentic Italian deli and a great family who owns..."
Kayla Hurley
"I remembered this place making an awesome sub as a kid. I stopped in today 20+ years later. My subs were amazing, we met Joe, and he made my kids..."
Eamonn Higgins
"Absolutely unequivocally the VERY BEST DELI in the Spring Lake, NJ,.area. Also, unlike 99% of other food establishments, Joseph's Deli HAS NOT..."
J. C.
"Joe’s deli is simply a great deli! One of the last old school delis. Not too common these days considering how Jersey Mike’s and Subways are..."
Kendall Brody
"Just had my third or fourth luncheon catered by Joe's and each time gets even better. The sandwiches and wraps were generous, the salads were..."
Lori DeSantis
"I love this place! Everyone is always very nice and treat you like family...even if it is your first time in! I have gotten the sandwiches many..."
Heather Roncinske
"Delicious sandwiches that we will dream about for years. What a great experience, so happy we stopped here as I took my children down memory lane..."
Jennie Trady
"The best damn deli In Spring Lake NJ! Joe Jr I think was still there after all these years. Bought My Mom a frozen dessert for her 80th birthday..."
Myung Ring
"Joseph's Deli exudes quality. The food is delicious, like home. The staff is also very familiar. I always order something from their specials, it's..."
Edward Brady
Bareli's By The Sea
86/100 (1037 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Lobster Roll
Shrimp
Pesto
Lobster
Pork
Pasta
Salad
Scallops
Clams
Oyster
Calamari
Salmon
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"My first visit and I just love love love Bareli's! The staff and manager are wonderful, so accommodating and answered all my questions. I had lunch..."
Arlene Saporito Pezzuti
"Just had an amazing dinner! My husband had " the best pork chop ever"! I had delicious black spaghetti with lobster fra diavolo, Kate our server was..."
Julia Vassalluzzo Gold
"Staff are top notch- new owners have really fixed up the place. Formerly was an eye sore to those staying at the breakers. Great wine list- chilled..."
Linda Demarest
"Great food drinks and excellent service. Sat outside on the porch. Great Martini special on Thursday nights. Definitely recommend can't wait to get..."
Greg McCluskey
"What a place!! From Liam to Jack to curly handgirl, the water girl and the 2 girls from DC, what a night! What great food!! What great atmosphere!!..."
Joyce McManamy
"We had a great experience. The food was so delicious and our server Jack was very attentive and very..."
Irene Greichel Bruh
"If I could give 100 stars I would. The atmosphere is lovely. Clean and crisp white walls with beautiful moldings. The attentiveness of the servers..."
SherryAnn Zika Moloney
"Fantastic!!! Food, staff, managers and ambience are all 5 Star. Best night out in quite a while. Didn't even look at the dessert menu, just asked..."
John Falcone
"Outstanding food and service! Great place to enjoy delicious Italian food in spring lake with ocean..."
Lee Thomas Dell'Olio
"What a Beautiful Place and great food and entertainment, What more can you ask for. Jerry played great tunes with Ocean view. Table 55 was the best..."
Pam Musgrave
"This was our first visit to Bareli’s, but we’ll be back. Aside from the food being delicious, the staff was welcoming and friendly. Our waiter..."
Jane Wallace Potoczniak
"Excellent dinner! Delicious calamari, chicken Marsala was the best I ever had! Service was..."
Lisa Freeman Sagui
"Who doesn't love lve Sinatra and Dean Martin music while sipping red wine, breathing in the scent of the ocean? The food was fresh and delicious. I..."
Angela Balacco
"We had a wonderful dinner!!! Food was fantastic & the wait staff was extremely professional..."
Tara Hickey
"Amelia’s By the Sea is a fabulous restaurant with superb service. Our server, Lauren, was wonderful and helped make our celebratory dinner even..."
Arthur Glauberman
"We had a small (4) birthday dinner for a relative dining on the front enclosed porch. While the view is quite nice, the room was very loud. I will..."
Peter Marcin
"I had mixed feelings about this restaurant. My salmon was very good. My wifes shrimp was overdone. Her drink wasn't served ⁸to the table until we..."
Chris Harris
"Really lovely spot for a special night out. The food is pricey but extremely high quality & delicious — we were all very happy with what we..."
German Dyson
"Upscale Italian eatery. Nice atmosphere, located in the beautiful Grand Victorian hotel right across from the beach in Spring Lake. Nice view from..."
Ron M
"Enjoyed dinner here on a very busy Saturday night, and we were really impressed by the quality of the food. The by-the-glass wine list, while not..."
Steve Welgoss
"Yum! We have been to every restaurant that has ever been in the Grand Victorian but this one is the best! Loved it! So romantic on the porch! Will..."
Maria Hidalgo Dolan
"Breaking down the review below: 1. Waitstaff -5! Jack was very attentive and accommodating to our table. 2. Service- 4! It took about 20 minutes to..."
Ritz The Reviewer
"Food was outstanding. What made the evening was the live entertainment . The singer was amazing. We saw him a few years ago prepandemic. Very..."
Andrew Kaplan
"Absolutely love this restaurant. Such wonderful service from everyone (something minor went wrong with our order and the manager was so lovely and..."
Marni Kagan
"Exceptional dining experience. Good bar service. Attentive staff. And the food is first rate. I highly their chicken dish, possibly the best..."
Tom Katsigiannis
"They were able to seat 7 people with no reservation on a Friday night - so appreciated! The Christmas decor was also..."
alice maggio
"Friendly and attentive service. Good and creative food. Even if you are not a fan of anchovies, the Burrata appetizer will open your mind about these..."
Irene Osorio
"Fantastic food on the coast of Spring Lake. Lots of seafood and vegetarian options as well as the meats. We had a seasonal fig & brie, and house..."
Sean Ryan Connolly
Ray's Cafe
82/100 (288 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
American
Italian
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Breakfast
Lunch
Brunch
Crab Cake
French Toast
Burger
Toasts
Omelette
Shrimp
Lobster
Pancakes
Salad
Scallops
Mussels
Tuna
Sit down
Italian
American
Café
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Television
BYOB
Reservations
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Mid-range
"The staff was very friendly and attentive and the food was real and delicious!!! Can't wait to eat here..."
Jeremy Paul
"Rays is a great place to grab a quick bite to eat in downtown Spring Lake. The service is pleasant. Well run..."
Gina Marcello, Ph.D.
"I can honestly say I have never had a meal that wasn't less than superb! Every meal is prepared and served so well that I have to go back again. The..."
Mark R
"Great staff and a friendly atmosphere. Food was..."
Jasmine Morrison
"Great little town café. Good food. Good..."
Gus Pampillon
"Staff is really friendly. I had the blacked chicken sandwich which was moist and the grilled ham was a great addition. I'll probably be back for..."
Carole
"Ray's Cafe in Spring Lake is always a great choice. Not only is everything on the menu delicious, but the service is second to none. It is evident..."
Niki Valentine
"I really enjoy this little hole in the wall. Very inexpensive and food was quickly brought to me. I got the pork roll egg and cheese and the bread..."
Joseph Anthony Harris III
"Other than two flies competing for the table scraps left in an overfilled bus pan and a waitress who look like she forgot to get dressed and was..."
Joseph Holland
"Great lobstah dinner on Sunday nights. The lobster is served in its entirety with corn on the cob and French fries. A true summer..."
Sheila Brennan
"Just walked in this place today for a delightful Breakfast. The bacon is outstanding! Very reasonable also! Will come back for..."
Holger Drallmeyer
"When dining at Ray's, you can rely on great food, friendly and quality service, along with an atmosphere that makes for a dining experience I always..."
Ray Golden
"We had a great meal and fantastic service! Definitely a place we would go..."
David Stupar
"Had a great night at Ray's Cafe. I had the Hawaiian Chicken and Coconut Shrimp dinner. It was..."
Dawn Beyer
Marco's Pizza
80/100 (1251 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Pizza crust is hand tossed and delicious. Highly recommended. Customer service is on point. No burnt crust and smiles getting your order. I like the..."
Nathan Neal
"This place just won the hearts of about 20 people. We get catered lunch every Friday at work and today we ordered from Marco's for the first time...."
Samantha Davis
"Marcos in Spring Lake is great. The staff gets to lnow you by face and even your phone number. . They call you by name. They know your special..."
Debi M Barbier Guzman
"The Spring Lake Marcos is the best I have been to. They have a great product and great service..this certainly explains why they are such a hit with..."
Randy Burrow
"Marco’s Pizza is Soooooo GOOD. I had it for the very 1st time today. I’d Never even heard of them Before, But ummm yeah I’ll definitely be..."
Tequisa Williams
"Love their fantastics pizza. Wish there was one in..."
Sonia Sonia
"..."
Laura Brokstad
"Friendly team members. They were pretty busy, and everyone was working hard behind the counter. I got a large thin crust. I'd had the regular..."
bryce bergman
"This is probably the best chain pizza in the area. They are always fast and friendly and the pizza is always good. I love that they don't gouge you..."
Kellea Krueger
"We hit Marcos quite a bit, they have a variety of pizza selections which we have tried many and those have been good. They have some other choices..."
Jon Harrison
"Amazing pizza, cheezy bread and wings and they always have deals online or on their..."
Tomoya T
"Angie pretty much rocked at her job today! She made sure that my order was perfect! Thank..."
robert babcock
"Much better than dominos or little Cesar's and they offer really great coupons. Minor mistakes with our orders have been fairly frequent, but if that..."
M A
"One of my favorite spots. Great pizza that's always fresh and hot. Service is always 💯..."
Jesse Eaves
"Garlic and parmesan crust is a must for any pizza here to top them off. Never had a bad experience..."
Zach K
"Good chain pizza restaurant. Fast pizza, friendly staff. Not a restaurant, delivery or pickup service, no..."
T
"1st time here since moving to Michigan!!! WE...WILL.. BE...BACK!! Great food better..."
Ryan Church
"Omg my bf & I LOVE this place! The pizza & wings are..."
Sheena Faith
"Very tasty pizza.. Warm, efficient..."
Julie Jensen
"Wow, my first time eating Marco's Pizza. My bf Bob got a XL All Meat and Root Beer. Angelique helped him. It was expensive but it was..."
Rena Wiseman
"Great pizza, the Pepperoni Magnifico is amazing, and the salads are crisp, fresh, and..."
Justin Aug9
"Quick and delicious! Hand tossed crust was perfect! I have been in the area for a year and sad we didn’t get it..."
Bethany Bacheller
"All-around great pizza and food. After placing an online order for pickup, the food was ready on-time. Employees were friendly and offered us..."
Jay D