We arrived in time for Happy hour. Two for 1 drinks and a slice of delicious pizza. Then ordered dinner. Decided to order the vodka pasta to share with a side of fabulous soup for husband an very nice salad for me. Thank goodness we shared!! We were served wonderful large half portion of pasta etc as well as their amazing soft bread sticks. Great fast service, fun decor and great food. Highly recommend.
Fabulous New Year’s eve dinner. Anybody in Saint Augustine I highly recommend this place you get a lot of food at a great value fabulous atmosphere one of my favorite places to get great Italian food served fast.
Had the Lobster ravioli in roasted red pepper sauce. Was excellent! I have had their pizza which I highly recommend! Great service, great food! You can’t go wrong!
Great food and fast and courteous service The pizza crust was good. I’d recommend the “garbage can” pizza
6 of us were there on Monday celebrating a birthday and had a good time. The happy hour is the best! And of course 🍕pizza is excellent. Great music too! Chance was our server and he was great. We come at least once a month as we only live 45 mins away.
The food was fantastic! We had some breadsticks that were the best breadsticks I have ever eaten. Pizza was so fresh and cooked perfect. Everything was great.
We used to walk by & get a taste of their pizza outside on the tray. We always brought
Our friends over too.
Then we finally started going inside for it.
Great tasting pizza. Good as our NYS pizza’s.
Nice staff, very friendly.
The best pizza and I request cesar salad the best salad I haved in my life
We tried the extra cheesey, extra crispy sample and we had to go inside for a couple of slices. Honestly some of the best pizza we have ever had
Absolutely awesome! Ordered way too much food but the pizza made me think I was back in NewYork. Bread sticks to die for, dont miss a chance to eat here.
Never disappointed! The Pizza is the best and freshest in town and the beer is ice cold! Go visit. It is a gem!
The pizza was amazing the staff was awesome A real nice place to eat .We try to stop in every time we are in town
This place is awesome you got to try it if you're in St Augustine great crust on the pizzas great cocktails just an all-around great atmosphere we will definitely visit again next time we're there.
We celebrated my mothers birthday here and it was awesome. Our server Mary was a sweetheart and the food, amazing! My family absolutely agrees that this is our favorite place for Italian.
Jennifer Parkman Tadlock
+5
We have eaten pizza all over the south, and this is still our favorite! Each slice can be personalized- family winner when it comes to our family of 5!! This is the first restaurant we hit when we make it to St Augustine!!
Without question the best pizza in town, including Jacksonville. I would recommend the Chicken Caccetore pizza or the Foccacia or the Meat lovers.
While shopping with our kids we decided to stop in. The service there was awesome! Our pizza was hot & fresh. We all 5 agreed it was the best pizza we ever ate! So glad we stopped by!
Best pizza ever! I'm a pizza aholic and this place rocks!
Excellent Pizza. The made-to-order pizza was delicious. The crust was sheer perfection. The charming young lady who made our pizza clearly enjoyed her work, and while she was making our pizza, offered suggestions for us to try at subsequent visits. Not only is this place an excellent value, the pizza is hard to beat. We ordered the spinach & feta (vegetarian) pizza, and it was pure heaven. I have certainly spent a lot more for a lot less.
This place is a must-go when you visit St. Augustine. And this recommendation comes from an Italian-American foodie.
My husband and daughter loved it. It was just okay to me but it is only because not enough sauce on pizza. I love a lot of sauce. I still ate all 3 of my pieces. We got a large for three of us and it was more than enough.
Best pizza in the SouthEast, sorry Vito & Frank.
Good find. Service was fabulous. Wings were perfectly cooked. Pizza had really nice crispy bottom, soft on top.
Yummmm Yummmm. When sauntering down St George Street, I'm often beckoned to try a sample from an employee with the duty or hawking their fare....and it worked!
When another fav pizza place couldn't be done w/o utilizing an ATM machine, I wandered in to try my luck at Pizzalley on St George....GREAT prices, good pizza, hot & gooey fresh from the oven, and great service.
Everyone seems to be having a great time too which adds to the overall enjoyment of the experience. :) Great work.
![Zomato]( "Recensione")
So yummy. We were walking down St. George Street when a woman asked if we wanted a taste of the pizza. I had read some of the reviews already and they were pretty good so we said sure and it was delicious. She then informed us that it was happy hour till 6 and that sold us. We returned about 5:30 and the place was pretty busy. The outdoor seating seemed busier but we are from South Florida so we are good not eating in the humidity all the time. The indoor area is a little strange to me. Being Italian I'm well aware that the colors are red, green and white but to have every piece of furniture and wall painted one of those colors is a little much. Not like it stopped me from scarfing down my pizza though. When we were there happy hour was 2 for 1 drinks and $5 off any 10 inch pizza (a 16in would have been $15). Needless to say we both got our own 10 inch pizzas for about $5-$7 dollars each and a few rounds of beer. For both of us with 2 pizzas and 8 beers our bill only came to $35 dollars not including the tip. Our waiter was great making sure he asked us about drinks a few minutes before happy hour ended to make sure we got the deal. I would definitely go back.
Great atmosphere for kids. Excellent pizza!
Great pizza place. We will be coming back soon.
My Favorite Pizza. My family rotates our vacation destinations through several of our favorite coastal selections, but when we visit Florida I make it an absolute necessity that we visit this restaurant. I meandered into the restaurant one day innocently enough, hungry from a long day of walking and shopping along the street and I have been addicted to their pizza ever since; I only wish that it wasn't 11hrs away from my home. To put it in the most simple terms that I can: Absolutely my favorite pizza.
We go here every time we are in town. Great pizza, sauce is very tasty and crust is very good. Recommend this place to all. We had two in our party with a gluten allergy. The chef let us bring our own wheat free crust and added sauce, cheese and toppings and cooked for us. They said that this was their first pizza in a restaurant that tasted this good. We all left satisfied, also try their fresh cut fries.
Debbie Rommeney Lowe
+4.5
Service is good. Pizza is fair but the calamari with Pomodoro is perfection! The absolute best Pomodoro sauce I've ever had. They say "carrots" are the secret. Who knows? I just know I'll order calamari every time!
Tasty!. Large portions, fresh ingredients, nice outdoor seating. Service can be hit or miss but for the most part they run a tight ship even when they are packed. Great spot for lunch on St. George Street!
Pretty good pizza. The pasta is also good. I like their interior with its wooden booths. Quite honestly, I eat at Pizza Time now that there in town. They're better.
So good!. Whats not to like about this place?! I have gone may times and ordered many a pizza and have never been disappointed. We often eat on the back porch which is also an added plus!
Best Pizza Around......... Great pizza, friendly people, good atmosphere. Yes, you have to order at the counter but it only takes a few minutes. Self-service refills are handy, too. You can usually get a sample at the door before buying.
My Favorite Pizza Place in FL. There's never been a time where I walked away from this place less than thrilled about my experience. Love and miss this place dearly.
Was wanting some Italian food and my buddy tells me about this place. He says he hasn’t been here in a few years so we both decided to see if it was as good as he remembered. Well, let’s just say it didn’t disappoint. The food was amazing and the service was great. Our waitress checked on us numerous times throughout our meal. I would highly recommend this place if you are in the area.
My husband and I LOVED the pizza from Pizzalley's!! We got the 10' to share, but definitely wish we got the 17' to bring leftovers home.. so well definitely be going back for more!
This place is amazing. The food is the best in Saint Augustine and we’ve never been let down. But, what makes us keep coming back is the service. Today we had Ivy and she was great. Very attentive and friendly and even gave my wife a courtesy pizza. We left nothing on our plates! This is why we will be coming back. If you are in town make sure you stop at Pizzalley’s, and stop at the bar and say hi to Ivy-she’s amazing!
This place is amazing! Super friendly hostess, comfy booth and great atmosphere. Our server (Karen) was the best! She never let our drinks go empty; she was prompt, efficient, and personable. The pizza was delicious, hot, and cheesy! The salad was HUGE! A definite must while visiting St. Augustine.
What lovely place for lunch with the family. Lovely atmosphere and staff. We sat outside and service was quick. We got the “Garbage Dump” pizza which fed everyone well. Will come again.
Amazing!! Ooh the burrata and pizza della nonna.. yum! Remember they only accept cash or you'll be stuck using their ATM.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes