Sluurpy > Restaurants in St. Augustine > Mayday Handcrafted Ice Cream

Mayday Handcrafted Ice Cream - St. Augustine - Photo album

Delicious! We got a late night hankering for something sweet and came across this place. Stopped in about 25 minutes before close and the staff was so welcoming. They told us to try as many flavors as we'd like and enjoy! My mum and I got a boozy watermelon flavor 🍉 (so refreshing!) and my uncle got

Portions are enormous. You really get what you pay for. You can easily split even one scoop with two people. Flavors were great. Had the strawberry and Nutella something.. it was delicious. Line is pretty long but it goes through fairly fast on the weekend. Def will be back!

Really nice staff. Great flavors. Can’t go wrong. I had rocky road. My father in law tried the Chai Tea and I already forgot what my husband got but they were all delicious. So glad we popped in.

Delicious ice cream made almost exclusively in-house! Don't limit yourself to just one flavor, and treat yourself to (or also share) the six-scoop flight. Personally we enjoyed the Queen Salted Caramel the most. And the servers were all very helpful and very nice!!

A cute little ice cream shop with a few dairy free options. Everything I tasted was delicious but ultimately I went with a split scoop of half Dirty Chi and half Toasted Coconut. It was amazingly creamy and light. Not overpoweringly sweet like some other ice creams can be.

The ice cream is the best! Different flavors! I liked the bourbon peacon!

Really nice employees. Many samples were offered. Recommendations were made. Very clean store. Appreciated non dairy options. Nice covered seating area outside.

Very good ice cream! Loved every flavor we tried along with the delicious waffle cone! Helpful and friendly staff as well! We went back a couple of times while visiting when we were close by and even took some back to the hotel. Thank you Mayday!